'Old fashioned' England are 'no hopers'

Last updated 07:26 26/08/2014
Graeme Swann
Getty Images
'LOVES COOKIE': Graeme Swann has much time for England skipper Alastair Cook, but says he's got to go if team to have a chance at the World Cup.
Alastair Cook
Reuters
ENGLAND CAPTAIN: Alastair Cook.

Relevant offers

Cricket

West Indies beat England to draw test series 1-1 Tim Southee helps Rajasthan Royals to top of Indian Premier League Trent Boult gets one over Brendon McCullum in Indian Premier League Tamim Iqbal record-setting double ton saves Pakistan test for Bangladesh Black Caps not at risk from rebel league, NZ Cricket board member says England captain Alastair Cook scores first test century in almost two years after strong showing against the West Indies Black Caps bowler Mitchell McClenaghan leads Mumbai Indians to Indian Premier League win International Cricket Council probes company registrations amid fears of split Cricket Australia to offer players long-term deals over fears of rebel leagues Record stand between Tamim Iqbal and Imrul Kayes leads strong Bangladesh reply against Pakistan in Khulna

England have no hope of winning next year's World Cup because of their ''old-fashioned'' approach to the one-day game, according to former spinner Graeme Swann.

Swann, who retired from international cricket during the 5-0 Ashes series defeat in Australia in December, believes the one-day team need to do away with the old guard in favour of exciting new talent if they are to succeed in the 50-over format.

Swann said captain Alastair Cook, who is set to lead the side at the 50-over tournament in Australia and New Zealand in February, should just concentrate on skippering the test team.

''We won't win this World Cup,'' Swann, who took 104 wickets in 79 one-day internationals, told BBC radio on Monday.

''In four years' time, we might have a chance if we get in all the exciting players who have none of the baggage of the old-style brand we play.

''I used to sit in the changing room and always felt we were so far behind other teams because we play such an old-fashioned brand.''

Cook, who has scored 2967 ODI runs, should step aside and let Eoin Morgan lead the team, Swann said.

''I love Cookie dearly.

''But I don't think he should be bothering playing one-day cricket anymore. He doesn't need to. He's proved a very good point in test matches.

''He should just enjoy being England test captain. Let in the young people who just want to smash it everywhere.

''He's not the guy who should be opening the batting in one-day cricket for England. (James) Vince should be doing it with (Alex) Hales in a young vibrant team with Morgan as captain.''

Swann spoke after England's opening one-day international of a five-match series against India was abandoned without a ball being bowled in Bristol due to heavy rain.

The match was due to see talented opener Alex Hales make his ODI debut for England. The 25-year-old is a regular in the country's Twenty20 team and Swann believes his call up to the 50-over side is long overdue.

''Hales should have been in this side for two or three years,'' he said.

''He got 99 in a T20 international against West Indies at Trent Bridge. How did the powers-that-be not see that as the future of one-day opening bat?

''Cook, (Ian) Bell and (Gary) Ballance are not players who will win you a World Cup. Hales will, as will James Vince, Jason Roy, Eoin Morgan and Jos Buttler.

Ad Feedback

''They are players I wouldn't want to bowl at. Players who could potentially get you 360/370 on the board.''

England play India, world champions in the 50-over format of the game, in the second ODI of their series in Cardiff on Wednesday.

Share on Facebook

- Reuters

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should bouncers be banned from cricket?

Yes - they're too dangerous

Neutral - it is what it is

No - it's just bad luck when it goes wrong

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content