Black Caps' reputations in tatters again
By JONATHAN MILLMOW - The Dominion Post
Relevant offers
Cricket
OPINION: The Twenty20 World Cup has been good to watch except of course when New Zealand was playing.
Despite a draw from heaven they are on their way home after managing to beat only Ireland and Scotland.
Some will say "it's only Twenty20, no-one should be shot", but interest was high, the money was good and New Zealand were quick to talk themselves up.
Reputations have taken a hammering, none more so than Jacob Oram, whose confidence with the bat hit rock bottom though he remains good with the ball.
Questions will be asked too of the coach, Andy Moles, who in seven months is yet to stamp his mark on proceedings.
Moles is an affable man but it is not apparent yet who runs the cutter.
New Zealand's cause was hampered by injury to key players but in some cases it could be argued they were self-inflicted.
Jesse Ryder arrived from the Indian Premier League with a niggle, Ross Taylor was foolishly told to "bat on" with a strained hamstring in a dead rubber and Daniel Vettori slipped over in warmups.
Cricket fans will shake their heads rather than gnash their teeth over this latest disappointment. Twenty20, no matter how entertaining, does not break the heart like other forms of the game when results do not go your way.
Still, there are standards and New Zealand failed to meet those in England. Against the major teams they scored 127-5 against South Africa, 99 against Pakistan and 110 against Sri Lanka.
Brendon McCullum was New Zealand's leading run-scorer, but his 107 was only 20th on the aggregates. Martin Guptill (102) and Aaron Redmond (101) were 22nd and 23rd, respectively.
Ian Butler was 16th on the wicket chart with six wickets at 16.33 while Nathan McCullum was fifth in the economy stakes, his runs per over just 5.42.
If you were looking for an upside it was a long wait. It came on the last afternoon as Guptill embarked on a solo effort against Sri Lanka's unorthodox attack.
Guptill is under-rated by New Zealand's decision-makers. He tore Australia to shreds at the Gabba last summer, only to be denied by the rain, but there he was the other day against Scotland not used in the top five. Guptill looks increasingly more capable of taking a game by the scruff of the neck than McCullum.
Vettori told reporters after the 48-run loss to Sri Lanka that senior players had to take the blame for the lame tournament.
"It has been difficult, but we have been lucky with a fortunate draw which meant we could win just two games before today against associate teams and still have a chance of making the semifinals.
"In a lot of a ways that probably wasn't right," Vettori said. "We were at full strength [today], apart from Jesse, and we still had the opportunity to turn up and win the game, so we are devastated.
"For a group of guys who had such high expectations, especially of our batting order, our highest score was about 120 and that's just not good enough."
Sponsored links
Maybe we should give the Black caps funding to the womens team who are in the finals of their 20/20 competition. Black caps are so over-rated and overpaid. Take some lessons from the womens team guys might learn something.
New Zealand are chokers. They had the one day series against Australia in the palm of their hand before ultimately managing to tie it. They also choked at the 2007 WC and at the 2003 World Cup. They will never win a major tournament or a series involving more than two teams.
Agree. Bye Bye Styris and Oram. They are goners, and should be left out of the SL tour. As much as I like McGlashan, sorry bud. You gotta go.
Redmond 20/20 and ODI's maybe - still a bit iffy on this. I still think Crowe got it right when he said he aint a international player. He got found out playing against a quality attack.
Nathan MCallum is an average bowler - lets be honest here, he aint an attacking bowler, he's a dibbly-dobbly. He cant even bat. He needs to go.
Here;s what I think.
DROP IMMEDIATLEY: Scott Styris Jacob Oram Peter McGlashan Nathan McCallum
yep, must say I am more than disappointed..and Oram looks like he plays, in bad shape!
To Damage # 23 The Aussies were in the pool group with Sri Lanka & the West Indies, both whom have made the semi's , we only beat Ireland & Scotland. Oz's losing form is better than our winning form ! Don't compare our cricket team to their's, Oz have won 4 world cups & been runners up twice, we as yet haven't made one final.
Living in South Africa and hearing their opinion about our cricketers I have to say I agree with what they say. Our guys are too chilled out and don't seem to care.
Oram has been over rated from day 1 same with Franklin. The fact the Franklin rates Oram as his favorite cricketer just shows the attitude of the team. His favorite should be Wassim Akram or Younis for crying out loud! Oram still hasn't proved himself at this level despite years of opportunities, its one thing for a 1o year old kid to idolize him but one of our other bowlers???
Our cricketers seem to be there for a good time and I don't know how to change that other than dropping them all and starting with some young guys who want to kick some ass and be number one.
Martin Guptills name keeps popping up. He genuinely cares and his performance was outstanding. The "big names" who play IPL didnt stand up and probably dont care because they have got their wallets filled with cash.Drop them.Selection is based on performance. Bring back Patel and Elliott they have some fight.
No, the Black Caps' reputation is not in tatters. It's reputation has most likely not changed, but rather been consolidated. That is, their reputation as one of many average teams which has the occasional flash of both brilliance and mediocrity in equal measures. It's been like that for a long time, probably will be for quite a while. We seem to forget that a few good games doesn't make a good team, our memories are incredibly short. All it takes is one win over Australia and they're suddenly awesome, even if they were beaten by Bangladesh a few months before.
Even though we lost, it was nice to see Guptill was genuinly gutted on the sidelines - it shows he actually cares. Seems NZ cricket just can't handle pressure. Taylor wasn't fit and should not have played. Ryder was a big loss too. I like Oram, but he did look out of sorts. Just seems anytime we're in a big game the wheels fall off - the fielders made mistakes, some poor bowling and the batsman lost it (though to be fair, Sri Lanka are a good bowling team). I believe NZ could win the World Cup one day (the real 50 over one) - just need to get it all together at the right time with a fully fit team (and our best players like Bond).
'Mad Dog' after another All Blacks scalp
All Blacks wary of loading English gun
World Cup party's over for Phoenix
Huge European football match-fixing ring exposed
Team NZ and Synergy start level for decider
Women pursuiters chase gold in Melbourne
Paddy O'Brien apologises to referee Dickinson
All Whites up six places in FIFA rankings
Henry says Ireland replay would be fairest
Unlocking counter-attack key for All Blacks
Hundreds march over government inaction
Memorial service for shooting victim
Mother of separated twins: 'We don't want them back'
All Blacks wary of loading English gun
Sleepwalker found not guilty of wife's death
World Cup party's over for Phoenix
Oprah says ending show 'feels right'
Police officer killed as floods devastate UK
Miley Cyrus tour bus overturns, one dead
Huge European football match-fixing ring exposed
Nice Kiwi blokes - shame about the women
'Brainless' stunt by NZ 'idiots' a global sensation
Miley Cyrus tour bus overturns, one dead
Praying for Ben after explosion
Mother of separated twins: 'We don't want them back'
Kiwi Kevin Percy claims Harry Potter castle
Women pay top dollar for evening with bachelor
Nice Kiwi blokes - shame about the women
Rokocoko to play against All Blacks
As Henry shows, footballers can't be trusted
$450,000 march is political manipulation
Who is your preferred choice as coach of the Black Caps?
Related story: Make the Wright choice: Snedden
Newest First
Oldest First
Oram + Styris + Broom + Diamanti + Mcglashan -------OUT!!! Southee + Patel + Elliott + Williamson + Hopkins ---------- IN!!!
Nz Choked.