ARL outlaws use of the shoulder charge

Last updated 22:17 20/11/2012
Shoulder charge
LIGHTS OUT: Knights Kyle O'Donell gets knocked out by a shoulder charge from Sam Burgess

Relevant offers


Warriors preparing to farewell Nathan Friend as team takes on West Tigers Sydney Roosters win 11th straight, end Manly's NRL finals hopes Souths hooker Issac Luke may have played last game for club after shoulder charge ban NZ Warriors won't block Simon Mannering from going on Kiwis tour to England NRL boss Dave Smith will deliver TV goods says leading digital media expert Auckland sides to battle Canterbury Bulls for national rugby league crown WaiCoa Bay Stallions set high targets for National Premiership NRL veteran Wille Mason confident of playing on next season Savory: No Origin baggage makes Kiwis much better option for NRL clubs Robbie Farah says he was told he will play reserve grade if he stays at Wests Tigers

NSW skipper Paul Gallen is shocked at the  ARL Commission's decision to outlaw the shoulder charge and claims  reducing the number of interchanges would have been a better step.

The commission reviewed a detailed report into the shoulder  charge conducted by Sydney Roosters chief executive Brian Canavan  and made the decision after a meeting tonight.

It accepted a management recommendation that the increased size  of players was creating a situation where the shoulder charge could  lead to an unacceptable injury risk.

The review found that shoulder charges made up 0.05 per cent of  the 142,355 tackles made in 2012, with less than four per cent  resulting in injury to the attacking player and less than one per  cent to the defensive player.

Seventeen per cent resulted in contact with the head of the  attacking player.

''I'm still in shock,'' Gallen told Triple M radio.

''We don't want players getting hurt, but it's taking some of the  toughness of the game.''

''When you have a look at the highlight reels they're all big  hits, the fans love shoulder charges.''

Gallen said reducing the number of interchanges would make it  harder for bigger players to produce so many huge hits.

''Personally I think it would change a lot of things,'' he said.

''If you have blokes who are 115-135 kilos scratching around,  they would simply have to lose weight and become fitter.

''It will make the bigger men tired and certainly take the  collisions out of the game.

'People are always complaining about the lack of halves and  players not taking on the line, but when you're 85 kilos running at  someone who is 130 kilos it is going to hurt, especially when they  are fresh.''

Gallen's Cronulla coach Shane Flanagan echoed his skipper's  sentiments and said he was concerned at how the new ruling would be  interpreted.

''It sounds easy but it's not,'' Flanagan told AAP.

''How are do they determine that a player wasn't affecting a  tackle when his shoulder comes into contact with the head?''

This can happen sometimes when a player lowers his centre of  gravity when running with the ball. I just want to know the  difference between that and a shoulder charge.''

Flanagan said reducing the interchange from 12 to eight would  encourage more playmakers to come into the game.

Ad Feedback

''It would see more footballers who are not just athletes,'' he  said.'

'We are too athlete-based. We need to become more  football-based. This would bring the smaller players back into the  game and make fatigue more of a factor.''

NRL interim chief executive Shane Mattiske said banning shoulder  charges would reduce the potential risk of serious injury to  players.

''The commission has gone through a thorough review process and  been public in warning players about the risks of illegal play,''  Mattiske said.

''The report shows that the shoulder charge is not a significant  part of the game and its removal is not likely to impact on the way  the game is played.

''With the increase in size and strength of the players, we  believe this is the time to eliminate a potential risk.''

NRL general manager of football operations Nathan McGuirk will  consult with the game's Competition Committee to finalise proposed  rule amendments in relation to the shoulder charge.

The proposed rule amendments will be put before the commission  at next month's meeting.



Special offers
Opinion poll

Who is your pick for international league player of the year?

Shaun Johnson

Jesse Bromwich

Sam Burgess

James Graham

Greg Inglis

Johnathan Thurston

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content