Central Pulse paid the penalty last Monday too

Last updated 05:00 06/03/2014
Irene van Dyk
UNDER PRESSURE: Irene van Dyk of the Pulse tries to get a pass away.

Relevant offers


Georgie Salter has been named Netball South coach for the 2017 national league Southern Steel sharpshooter Jhaniele Fowler-Reid helps Jamaica to netball series win over England Whitney Souness regaining fitness, ready for new netball national competition Southern Steel netball sharpshooter Jhaniele Fowler-Reid helps Jamaica to test win over England Netball South quartet make NZ U21 squad Search for Netball South development league coach intensifies Tiana Metuarau, daughter of Wai Taumaunu, named in Central Pulse squad for 2017 'Super Sundays' main feature of new NZ national elite netball league Life after Laura Langman, Silver Ferns squad includes two newcomers Netball makes overdue play for south Auckland with new Northern Stars team

It wasn't only on the scoreboard where the Adelaide Thunderbirds were winners.

In beating the Central Pulse 45-44 on Monday, the defending trans-Tasman Netball League champions handsomely won the penalty count too.

The Thunderbirds gave away 78 to the Pulse's 47, as infringements rained down at a rate of more than two a minute.

The Pulse lost Monday's game - no-one disputes that. But the cynicism of the victors deserves scrutiny too.

Depending on what level they're playing, basketballers are ejected from games after picking up five fouls, or six when it comes to the NBA. Thunderbirds goal keep Kate Shimmin conceded 23 penalties on Monday night. Three other Thunderbirds were in double figures.

Those numbers speak for themselves and, on this occasion, they'll have to speak for Pulse coach Robyn Broughton too.

"It's very difficult to say something in netball," Broughton said yesterday.

"We just have to look forward to the next game and put this one behind us. I was very disappointed not to win. We led all the way and should have been able to kill that game off."

Broughton has reviewed the tape several times. The players did their individual analysis too and they all sat down and dissected it together late yesterday afternoon.

There was a common theme in what Broughton saw but, as she indicated, saying what that was would see the league's governing body come down on her like a tonne of bricks.

Looking on from the outside, it's evident defenders can infringe with impunity. There is provision in the rules for those that transgress in a persistent fashion to be suspended, or stood off court, for a period of play. But that step is so sparingly used by umpires that players basically disregard its existence.

Which leaves the Pulse with wounded bodies and pride, heading into Saturday's clash with the Southern Steel at TSB Bank Arena.

Broughton was happy with the way wing defence Joline Henry and goal attack Donna Wilkins played against the Thunderbirds and some of the composure shown by new centre Elias Shadrock. The quality of the passing out of defence was another aspect that impressed her, but there remains work to do at the other end.

Mind you, given the hard ride Irene van Dyk and Wilkins were getting from Shimmin and Rebecca Bulley it would have been hard for any feeders to find them.

The Steel were 60-44 losers to the Queensland Firebirds and won't present quite the same test of the Pulse's courage.

Ad Feedback

- Fairfax Media

Special offers
Opinion poll

Who should play goal shoot for the Silver Ferns?

Bailey Mes

Catherine Latu

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content