Merci beaucoup, that's just what we all needed

BY TOBY ROBSON
Last updated 08:35 22/06/2009
Brad Thorn
ROSS GIBLIN/Dominion Post
SHINING LIGHT: Brad Thorn is lifted in a lineout during the All Blacks v France second rugby test at Westpac Stadium, Wellington.

Relevant offers

Opinion

Rugby the deserving winner at Halberg Awards Sir Bob Jones' boxing tirades becoming tiresome Awards can be divisive Terry's racism trial exercise in hypocrisy Contador judgement doesn't feel like justice Adams lighter and brighter Great sevens win, but where are the women? World Cup most important aim So many questions, not many answers A game of loyalty versus ambition

OPINION: France and fate have combined to do New Zealand rugby an immeasurable favour.

Marc Lievremont's side brought a mix of flair and experience that provided a true and worthy challenge not provided by an inbound touring side since England knocked the All Blacks over in 2003.

Fate handed the All Blacks an injury list of epic proportions and the well-timed excuse to test the country's playing depth.

The result was not an A+, but it is hard to think how young players like Isaac Ross, Liam Messam, Kieran Read, Tanerau Latimer and Bryn Evans will be worse for their experiences in the past two weeks.

Likewise Lelia Masaga, George Whitelock and Aled de Malmanche, who must now boast the briefest All Blacks debut in history even if it did not count as a cap.

In the short term, the series has provided some relevant pointers toward the Tri-Nations.

We now know Ross has a cool head and a bright future, mentally capable of calling the lineouts and physically of locking horns with grizzled test veterans.

Read's future may lie at No 8. He could even be a challenger, in coming years, to the long reign of incumbent Rodney So'oialo.

Messam has talent. He is close to achieving test level, but still struggles to contain his zeal at the top level.

Latimer, not Adam Thomson, appears a better investment in the search for an understudy for Richie McCaw on the openside.

Isaia Toeava is not a test midfielder, talented, but still too quiet to impose himself when his teammates are struggling.

Cory Jane has long-term test potential on the wing. Joe Rokocoko's Super 14 struggles were not a trick of the mind and Stephen Donald still has his foibles as a test first-five.

The series also reaffirmed that Ma'a Nonu has become the key cog in the All Blacks backs and that the value of experience from the likes of Keven Mealamu's and Brad Thorn never be underestimated.

It is hard to see how such useful information would have been gained if the All Blacks had been at full strength, or France at halfmast.

In the long term we now know:

* That the depth of New Zealand rugby is not bottomless and that there is a sizeable gap between our best and the rest.

* That the outflow of second tier players has started to affect the readiness if not the quality of the next player on the production line.

* That Europe is closing in on the south and that even on home soil the All Blacks are vulnerable.

Ad Feedback

* That New Zealand needs to brush up on old arts like rolling mauls or all the flair in the world will count for nothing.

Best to note all that down now rather than at the start of 2011.

Thank you France for bringing players such as fullback Maxime Merdard, halfback Julien Dupuy, flanker Thierry Dusautoir and prop Fabien Barcella to our shores.

But more than that, thank you for providing a welcome break from the normally turgid June tests and the salutory reminder, though as a nation you may have overdone this point in recent years, that international success is not ours by right.

- © Fairfax NZ News

6 comments
Post a comment
SAVAGE   #6   12:51 pm Jun 24 2009

"* That Europe is closing in on the south and that even on home soil the All Blacks are vulnerable."

"* That New Zealand needs to brush up on old arts like rolling mauls or all the flair in the world will count for nothing."

I disagree that Europe is closing in on the south, only because of the ELVs. Now that we've sorted the rules out once and for all, I believe that you'll see Sth Africa and ourselves revert back to our traditional forward oriented games. We do need to brush up on the old arts, but as the ABs showed in the weekend, a boot up the backside is a wonderful and an effective incentive to make people focus. The under 20s final also showed why I disagree about Europe catching up. If they haven't figured out that forward dominance in todays game MUST be complimented by pace and skill, and haven't passed that on to their age groups, what hope do they have for the future? Their problem, not ours. We're in no way anywhere near the golden path, and by this I mean our domestic competion needs sorting out.

Matthew   #5   04:10 pm Jun 23 2009

Why is Henry so adament with using McAlister, There were 1st 5s who played S14 this year who should get a run before Luke, they didn't run overseas to get the big bucks & hide after the world cup debacle. As Brad thorn said in his post if you can't give a 110% to the Jersey don't put it on. We need to get back to what the Jumper means, & the pride you need to wear it, Put some of the under 20's stars in against Italy, they are the same as when Luke got in, or does Henry owe him something. I'm a proud Kiwi living in Aussie for the last 35yrs & I put the jumper on before every test & back the boys, & my country, they have to do the same. Lets go back to the big tours of the 60's & 70's where the small unions played international teams aswell. I can remember watching Pierre Villpreaux do a drop goal from his 22 at Mclean Park Napier against a strong Hawkes Bay side & watched it sail through & the whole crowd stood & cheered, the money has taken the gloss off it all. Show some Kia Kaha

anon   #4   03:54 pm Jun 23 2009

Good article - very positive writing.

Brent   #3   02:00 pm Jun 23 2009

Seems that we have lost our so called "flair", not sure if this is due to miss Dan Carter or just the limitations with the current selections. We seem to be fairly predictable in the backline. I often wonder how devastating we could be if we played with a bit more depth like the Aussies tend to do - can you imagine the problems Nonu would produce if he was running onto the ball at pace rather than having his usual 2 metres of space to get going? let along the change of angle we could use. No longer do we have the players of old like Christian Cullen or Jeff Wilson that seemed to sparks things from nothing.

Mark   #2   10:22 am Jun 23 2009

I have to agree with most of this although I'd like to add that we also learned that numbers 1-5 need to do their job properly for the rest of the team to function.

We learned that the players we thought were our world-class players really are world-class players and influence games significantly.

We learned that there are some young guys who have the skills and temperament to play at test level such as Ross, Jane, Read, and Latimer.

The most significant thing we learned was that Brad Thorn is probably under appreciated as a hard man, workhorse, and inspiration to the young guys. The way he threw himself into that last game was superb.

Sam Neale   #1   01:32 am Jun 23 2009

The games were great contest to watch, better than any other June tests since that English one. Good on the French - I look forward to them playing the Wallabies this week.

Pity Henry did not let the All Blacks know how they could win the trophy though. I live in Sydney now and today faced constant stick in relation to the All Blacks being unable to count. Embarrassing.

I would have defended Henry, but I completely disagree with the way he devalues competitions outside of the world cup (ie the 2007 Super 14, the NPC on life support and now the Dave Gallagher trophy).

Don't start me on the McAlister Muiliana perfect strangers midfield combo in the world cup quarter final.

I feel better after that vent.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content