Ineffectual team-mates hurt McCullum's batting

BY DUNCAN JOHNSTONE
Last updated 10:20 12/03/2010
1 of 9 Black Caps captain Daniel Vettori
JOHN SELKIRK Zoom
ON APPEAL: Black Caps captain Daniel Vettori successfully appeals for the LBW decision against Australian skipper Ricky Ponting.
1 of 15 Black Caps vs Australia - 3rd ODI
MARK TAYLOR/Waikato Times Zoom
Brad Haddin gets 100 runs.
1 of 8 Daniel Vettori and Michael Clarke
JOHN SELKIRK Zoom
ON YA MATE: Australia vice-captain Michael Clarke gives Black Caps skipper Daniel Vettori a pat on the shoulder after he almost guided New Zealand to an unlikely win in the second ODI.
1 of 12 Black Caps Shane Bond & Scott Styris
MARK TAYLOR/Waikato Times Zoom
AUSSIE SLAYERS: Shane Bond (left) congratulates team-mate Scott Styris after hitting the winning runs in an unbeaten 49 from 34 balls.

Relevant offers

Opinion

Forgive Proteas' quake jitters - they turned up Kane Williamson should skip the short stuff Dressing room insight an A-League winner Time for Halbergs facelift and focus on sport Erin Baker our 'best ever', Adams looming fast Protea cricketers already getting hearts racing Super franchises in battle for hearts and minds Hard to take that jab on the chin The winner is...the Halbergs, of course! Get runs, stop theirs to win in 50-over game

OPINION: The New Zealand batsmen are responsible for getting their star player Brendon McCullum out as much as the Australian bowlers.

As the Black Caps put the microscope over a series of lacklustre batting efforts that undoubtedly cost them the Chappell-Hadlee series there will be plenty of focus on what skipper Daniel Vettori has quite rightly labelled "soft dismissals".

The hard-hitting McCullum will find himself in that category too with some rash shots blighting a solid series against the Australians where he has been guilty of failing to make the most of his good starts.

But should all the guilt lie with McCullum in his case? I don't think so.

His fellow batsmen have contributed to his a downfall and that was clearly apparent at Eden Park last night as the series slipped away.

McCullum got off to a flier but once his opening partner Martin Guptill was dismissed he started to lose his way.

He was eventually the fourth batsman out, having scored half of the 120 runs on the scoreboard but by then he had well and truly lost his momentum.

Ross Taylor, Shannan Stewart and Scott Styris were all guilty of failing to turn the strike over to McCullum.

When he is hot he is the sort of batsman who likes to stay on the front foot. He needs to be facing the bowlers rather than watching from the other end.

As that trio poked around ineffectively McCullum cooled off and eventually lost his wicket through frustration as much as anything else.

The Aussies knew this and Ricky Ponting cleverly fed the other batsmen singles off the last balls of several overs just to keep McCullum stranded at the non-striker's end.

The Kiwis, paupers looking for anything they could get, hungrily accepted the singles without thinking of the bigger picture.

At one stage they collected 33 singles in a row as their only form of scoring. You could sense it driving McCullum crazy.

As New Zealand contemplate the dead rubber in Wellington tomorrow where they need a win to gain some sort of momentum going into the test series, they will contemplate a bizarre batting display at Eden Park.

To go 22 overs through the middle stages of the innings without a boundary was inexcusable at a ground so small.

If it hadn't been for Daryl Tuffey's blazing effort at the end of the innings this would have been a total embarrassment.

Not even Duckworth-Lewis could save the Black Caps as the Aussies chased won a rain-affected target.

A series that started so sensationally fizzled out for New Zealand as they succumbed 3-1 with more to endure at the Cake Tin.

Ad Feedback

The Australians deserved their success.

The New Zealand bowlers were honest at best. They looked better when they bowled first. Under the pump with Australia chasing for victory in the last couple of matches, there was a more ordinary look to the New Zealand attack both in terms of taking wickets and containment.

The batting was disappointing throughout the series bar some outstanding cameos, particularly the Styris match-winning effort in Napier and Vettori's near miss in Auckland last weekend.

In the end the classy Australians came good as most suspected they would.

Their last two wins have come at a canter and it will take a significant turnaround for the injury-plagued Kiwis to save some face in the capital.

- © Fairfax NZ News

64 comments
Post a comment
Vetorri for PM   #64   06:43 am Mar 14 2010

I cant believe people are knocking him he is the most destructive batter in world cricket and much much better than that cheat Haddin Id rate him as the best batter in twenty twenty and one day cricket world wide even better than Tendulkar

Precambrian   #63   12:56 am Mar 13 2010

Yeah McCullum should' e been troubled by all this. I love CW cWCWWW

Chris   #62   08:29 pm Mar 12 2010

I have to agree. This article is bollocks. No batsman goes out to bat to get a run a ball 50 and then go out. When a played gets set their first responsibility is to face and score off as many balls as possible whilst retaining their wicket as long as possible. If a batsman is adversely affected by the run rate of others it identifies a weakness in their composure. Just consider the number of balls that were blocked and lost later in the innings that McCullum and other batsmen could of scored off, had they been there.

Tony   #61   07:56 pm Mar 12 2010

'When he (McCullum) is hot he is the sort of batsman who likes to stay on the front foot. He needs to be facing the bowlers rather than watching from the other end.'

Right, thanks for clearing that up. If anyone was in doubt that batsman need to be bowled to to score lots of runs they aren't now

You hype up McCullum way too much, but the simple fact is he doesn't bat long enough to dominate like the true heroes in cricket like Chris Gayle, Gilchrist and Sehwag et al. That is his problem, not his team mates. Come back and write this article when he is as god as those guys

First Slip   #60   04:17 pm Mar 12 2010

When Ryder comes back, open with him and Guptill and have McCullum bat number 6. he's a much better finisher! Who in the current line up could take the team over the line in a close game?

bigmatchtemprament   #59   04:10 pm Mar 12 2010

if you fail to perform in big matches then you deserve to lose your place. RYDER and ELLIOT have proved this. they have to play to add stability once they are fit.

Avereging 30 is not good enough. i am tired of seeing 40s get praised by our journalists and crowds. 80s and 100s win games.

Chris   #58   04:09 pm Mar 12 2010

McCullum is super-talented but like his team-mates plays some incredibly poor cricket shots (Napier, Auckland, Hamilton and, to a lesser extent, last night). He seems to want to hang out with and be seen in the same light as the likes of Ponting etc but he's not in the same class yet. The legacy of a great cricketer is based on consistency of performance ... McCullum and his batting mates don't get it. Cameos are not enough.

Jacko   #57   03:57 pm Mar 12 2010

In Bond and Vettori we have world class bowlers but Tuffey Southey and Mason would be Reserve grade players in any Australian city. Vettori sets a field and Southee and Tuffey bowl slow and short to the leg side which is Bread and butter to any batsmen. Tuffey is only 5 clicks faster than Styris. The Kiwi batting excuses are WOEFUL as is the mental toughness that is sadly lacking in this team. I'm not sure what the High Performance coaches are instilling in the Kiwi players but I hope its not.. Lets hope we get to play the Bangladeshi's again newt year as its our only chance of winning !

SA Rules   #56   03:39 pm Mar 12 2010

do'nt know what all the fuss is about. not like any of these two teams matter anyway.... NZ's too low on the standings. lol

i say send the bowlers & Batsmen to get caoched by a good mate of mine. Chris"Big Mac" Mcmanus down in welly then you'd have a propper team. LMAO

Trav of Perth of Auckland   #55   03:26 pm Mar 12 2010

Damn it!!! I wish my confidence in our team wasn't so misplaced!! I have to pay out heaps to my aussie mates now because we got touched up mostly because of our lack of patience and also we are abit mentally weak against the ockers!! Things need to change and batsman need to step up and also the bowlers. The whole series has been crap after the 1st game to be honest and we are going to get belted in the prob 6 day two test series. Cant wait for Ryder to be back in all formats. we have missed the big horse dearly. I just hope we put up a fight in the test series or it's going to be a long wait til the Bledisloe cup for me to make my money back off these gloating Aussie mates/floggers!! C'mon Blackcaps show so heart and keeps us keen!!!!


Show 5-54 of 64 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content