Magpies fighting for their lost generation

Photosport

BROTHERS IN ARMS: Hawke's Bay players celebrate their win over Otago in Dunedin on Friday night.

Relevant offers

Opinion

As Henry shows, footballers can't be trusted Olympics waste of money Stop getting our footballs in a tangle Time to stop the childish bickering Egypt v Algeria: when football's fair play died All Whites have earned a crack at Socceroos Beautiful win makes the game cool again All Whites' win may spark shift in NZ sport You'll kick yourself if you skip World Cup Rugby needs to entertain again

If you really love rugby you'll be barracking for the Magpies to dump on Canterbury from a great height and for the Stags to spear Wellington's scalp on their five-pointer antlers.

Neutral observers will be twiddling the television off-switch if fat cats Canterbury and Wellington win this weekend's national championship semifinals.

Media cynics and armchair critics have carped that the Air New Zealand Cup is a sub-standard affair. But any competition where the Auckland aristocrats fail to make the top-eight can't be all bad.

What do the naysayers expect? Super 14 or test-quality rugby in a semi-professional arena?

The charms of a 14-team national championship are its geographical scope and its throwback to an era where most had day jobs.

Yes, it was denounced by big unions. But their squeals about salary cap curbs smacked of vested interests.

Yes, it has had more teething problems than a nursery full of bawling babies during a national Bongella shortage. But this season we've seen Tasman, Bay of Plenty, Southland, Taranaki and Hawkes Bay make the quarter-finals cut alongside Super 14 power bases Canterbury, Wellington and Waikato.

Now I'd like to see Canterbury's personable coach Rob Penney win a national title in his own right. But I wouldn't shed crocodile tears if Hawke's Bay won at AMI Stadium because they have been robbed of their rugby legacy.

The Magpies were a New Zealand rugby talent factory in the 1960s under All Black great Kel Tremain's leadership. Has there been a better midfield partnership than Ian MacRae and Bill Davis? (North Harbour's Walter Little and Frank Bunce, perhaps).

Hawkes Bay also had some splendid players in the 1990s. But Stu Forster, Josh Kronfeld, Taine Randell and Paul Cooke were wearing the blue-and-gold of Otago then.

For a generation, rugby players topped apple boxes, logs and wine bottles as the biggest export items through the port of Napier.

The new national championship has restored rugby pride in Hawke's Bay where people now stride the streets of Napier and Hastings in Magpies jerseys and where homegrown talent like Hikawera the Happy Hooker and Israel Dagg (no relation to Fred) can now stay home and make Super 14 status.

Imagine the hype in Invercargill if the Stags were to win the first division title.

You wouldn't be able to walk the wide pavements of Tay St without tripping over oyster shells and champagne corks (or stoppers from Speights' peters). You'd never wipe the cheesy grin off Mayor Tim's dial. The glare from his pearly-white molars could be harnessed to power the Comalco smelter.

Now, we, in the media, rarely use the words NZRU and wise in the same sentence. But it was a sage call by the national body to retain 14 teams until the almost inevitable advent of a 10-team trans-Tasman competition.

Vexed questions

Has anyone in the history of New Zealand team sport combined charisma, world-class playing ability, team ethic and leadership better than retired rugby league legend Ruben Wiki? (And don't dare suggest Tana Umaga or Sean Fitzpatrick).

If the New Zealand Maori were kind enough to let old Uncle Rube canter 60m to the try-line at New Plymouth on Sunday, why were they so mean in exposing the Little General (retired), Stacey Jones's defence?

If the current global financial crisis continues can New Zealand afford to host the Rugby World Cup? Is ploughing taxpayers' cash into the Eden Park upgrade fiscally responsible?

Will Silver Ferns coach Ruth Aitken ever be bold enough to start a test without 30-something veterans Julie Seymour and Irene van Dyk?

Surely a series against easy-beats England is a grand chance to blood a new captain and a young goal shooting duo.

Will new RadioSport morning host Mark Richardson's show be less sleep-inducing than one of his groundhog day batting innings?

Newest First

Oldest First

Sam   #4   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Wiki has been past it for at least two years. He'd have done the same amount of good for the Warriors by being on the coaching staff - great mentor, former great player but should have retired ages ago.

Jack   #3   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Tony, well done for your positive coments on Ruben Wiki. I'm rugby union thru and thru, however there has been no-one in any NZ professional sport that is close to having it all and for such a long period of time as rugby league player, Ruben Wiki. And to be truthful, I wonder if ever again will we have a man of such ilk representing NZ in any code. Ruben is truly one of the greats of NZ sport. Even he probably dosen't realise just how outstanding he has been. To compare in union, we probably have to go back to George Nepia, when he played in every game, winning them all on the All Blacks 1924 overseas tour. "Cheers Ruben, you are one hell of a man, one of a kind".

Jack

Joseph   #2   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

Tom there is no comparison - I am a union fan through and through but our elite players even in Fitzy's day would have struggled with the same level of intensity required for "week in week out" NRL. Its not like Fitzy played test level rugby against the Boks each week for 5-6 months. Thats the level required every week in NRL.

Thats the level Rubes not only played at every week but he did this for 15-16 years...near on a decade more than Fitzy at his peak. Further he was one of their codes top performers week in week out. Look no further than Mark Ellis and John Kirwan who were still AB's when they switched but could not handle the weekly physicality of league. Thats why Tuqiri switched to our code to get more years outta his body.

i tip my hat to Rubes too Jim Kayes as he is truly a kiwi legend that has no peers for what he has put his mind and body through throughout his career.

Tom Guthrie   #1   05:26 pm Jan 28 2009

How can you ask a question based purely on opinion then demand people not to share theirs? Both Tana and Sean showed their class in all areas mentioned to a great extent. Unless you believe that being All Black captains' of great teams and arguably the best players (in their positions) in the world at some point in their tenure doesn't suffice?

Ad Feedback