Judoka has Glasgow selection appeal dismissed

Last updated 01:56 07/06/2014

Relevant offers

Other Sports

Sporting organisations suggest kids can be selected for stardom too young Ex-softballer breaks 50-year family legacy to play baseball in United States NZ's Tom Walsh chasing big-throwing Americans at Diamond League opener Vertigo, whip lash and retinas detaching all risks for bungy world record breaker Lance Armstrong gets engaged to longtime partner Anna Hansen The A-Z of the America's Cup Oscar De La Hoya: Floyd Mayweather v Conor McGregor a farce boxing might not recover from America's Cup skippers warn that carnage could continue America's Cup start postponed owing to strong winds forecast Quiz: Test your sports knowledge - May 26

Gisborne judoka Joy Williams has had her appeal for Commonwealth Games selection dismissed.

Williams appealed against the decision not to include her on "a number of grounds", the Sports Tribunal of New Zealand said.

"Including that Judo New Zealand didn't properly follow or implement the nomination criteria, she wasn't given a reasonable opportunity by JNZ to satisfy the criteria and there was no material on which the decision could reasonably be based," it said.

Williams complained that the selectors put too much emphasis on the strength and quality of her opponents in various contests leading up to the Games and the importance of that was not properly communicated to her when she decided which competitions to enter.

That claim was rejected.

The tribunal also rejected that Williams was treated differently to another athlete who had been nominated.

"That athlete's record and history was significantly different and there were extenuating circumstances in that case which didn't exist in [Williams'] case," the tribunal said in its report.

The tribunal was not satisfied there was any fundamental flaw or failure in the process the selectors took or that the selectors did not have all the relevant information available to them.

"The tribunal therefore dismissed the appeal," it said. 

Ad Feedback

- Stuff

Special offers
Opinion poll

Will Shane Cameron beat Kali Meehan on Saturday?

For sure. Cameron will knock him out.

It will be close but I think Cameron on points.

Meehan will knock him out. This is his last fight.

I'm tipping Meehan to win on points.

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content