Uncertainty adds thrilling rugby edge

BY TOBY ROBSON IN DUNEDIN
Last updated 05:00 13/06/2009

All Blacks ready to go

Related Links

France's big Bastareaud ready for All Blacks France 'taking on Monsters Inc' Family swamp new All Blacks skipper All Black tips 'crazy' French start Cory Jane fills Rudi Wulf's wing spot

Relevant offers

Rugby

Wyatt Crockett working to shed specialist tag Nerves or not, Chiefs' Tex has set his goals UK league coach searches for Crusaders' secret Quade Cooper's fixed-up knee gets early test Aussie teams face uneven playing field - White Smith and Dickson in Highlanders midfield Smith will lead Hurricanes in opener - Hammett Rebels look to lift for Blues in Super trial Whitelock boys set to re-unite on rugby field Sharpe to retire at end of Super Rugby season

Opportunity has rarely knocked louder than it will at Carisbrook tonight as the All Blacks test season swings into motion against France.

It will be riveting to see who answers its call.

The All Blacks injury crisis has brought forth a test lineup the like of which has probably not seen since the Baby Blacks took the field against Australia in 1986.

And although it is two years away, there is a World Cup undercurrent to a match that could reveal more about a crop of players on the cusp.

The timing, in many ways, could not be better for New Zealand rugby and it has provided the ingredients for an enthralling contest.

Wellington's Cory Jane was thrown the latest call-up yesterday when he was confirmed in the starting side in place of injured wing Rudi Wulf.

Jane will start in the No14 jersey with Joe Rokocoko switching to the left wing and Lelia Masaga in the reserves.

There is the inexperienced, but exciting, loose trio of Liam Messam, Kieran Read and Adam Thomson, rookie lock Isaac Ross, Isaia Toeava at centre and a maturing Luke McAlister on the bench.

The latter is worth special mention. There has been an edge to the All Blacks backline whenever he has switched in for Stephen Donald this week. At what stage will the temptation to try out his new toy overcome backs coach Wayne Smith?

And how will Donald respond to the pressure his test spot is suddenly under?

The first All Blacks side to be captained by Mils Muliaina screams potential rather than polish.

But would it be as intriguing if the full-strength All Blacks were lining up another June tourist?

The All Blacks are one injury away from a scrum featuring Hawke's Bay's Bryn Evans. That's why there is the sniff of an upset in the Dunedin air and it has brought with it anticipation and edge.

All Blacks coach Graham Henry has spent much of the week trying to keep his nervous young side calm, and yesterday he continued.

"He's an uncomplicated young fellow," Henry of said Jane. "He just enjoys having the opportunity and just wants to get into it.

"I enjoy his attitude. He will go out there and express himself I'm sure."

Masaga, 20 minutes from boarding a flight where he was set for a reunion with his grandmother for the first time in 18 years, was given a similar message by his coach.

"The big thing he has to do is try to be as relaxed as possible and go out there and show why he's a good rugby player. We don't want him inhibited by the occasion."

Ad Feedback

Only hesitation will allow France to achieve the improbable in their first test match on the ground affectionately known as "The Brook".

The tourists' team sheet is largely unfamiliar to most.

What is known is that they have experience out wide in wings Cedric Heymans, in his 50th test, and Damien Traille.

They have a massive centre in Mathieu Bastareaud and a pint-sized goal-kicking halfback debutant in Julien Dupuy.

In the pack, World Cup tormenter Thierry Dusautoir captains the team from blindside, while 74-test veteran Sylvain Marconnet adds starch to the pack.

History heavily favours the All Blacks, who have won 34 of the 46 tests between the two nations.

But history also shows that the French are most dangerous when asked to do the impossible or improbable and often at the All Blacks' expense.

Given half a chance, even on New Zealand soil, the Tricoleurs will pounce, as they did first in 1979 and twice in 1994.

What will unfold at Carisbrook, possibly the final test at the famous ground, is difficult to predict.

That is its appeal.

REFEREE'S BOX

-Ireland's George Clancy is an inexperienced referee at international level, having controlled just five test matches.

-Tonight's test will be the first time he has refereed a match involving the All Blacks.

-The 32-year-old has controlled 68 professional matches since 2004 and first picked up a whistle in 2000.

-He was elected to the world elite panel last year and will referee the All Blacks again, against Italy, in a fortnight's time.

THREE AREAS OF INTEREST

- THE LOOSE-FORWARDS: As always the battle for supremacy at the collision area will be crucial. France will fancy their chances against the All Blacks' second stringers and have a good balance in the back row. Fulgence Ouedraogo provides the speed, No 8 Louis Picamoles (106kg) the size and captain Thierry Dusatoir the work ethic and experience. The All Black trio have plenty to prove. Is Adam Thomson a test quality openside? Can Liam Messam cut out the errors that too often mark his play in the Super 14? And can Kieran Read make an impact at test level?

- THE LINEOUT: By no means a sure thing with rookie Isaac Ross calling the shots on debut. Without freekick sanctions Ross should have plenty to do as penalties are kicked into touch. He varied his calls for the Crusaders during the Super 14 and is sure to use Adam Thomson's height at the back, but would do well to give himself plenty of work. The French do not possess great height or experience in locks Pascal Pape (1.96m ) and Romain Millo-Chluski (1.94m) who boast just 26 caps between them.

- KICK AND CHASE: If the weather packs up, Stephen Donald's radar will need to be spot on as it mostly was for the Chiefs. Expect plenty of short chips and grubbers and cross kicks for the wings from the All Blacks. Otherwise, it will be long and chase with the French counterattack considered one of their most lethal weapons. The French have an untried combination in the halves in first-five Francois Trinh-Duc, and halfback Julien Dupuy, who on debut can expect a torrid time from opposite Jimmy Cowan.

HOW THEY LINE UP

New Zealand v France

Venue: Carisbrook, Dunedin

TV: Live Sky Sport 1, 7.30pm

TAB odds: All Blacks $1.10, France $6.25

Referee: George Clancy (Ireland)

New Zealand: Mils Muliaina (c), Cory Jane, Isaia Toeava, Ma'a Nonu, Joe Rokocoko, Stephen Donald, Jimmy Cowan; Liam Messam, Adam Thomson, Kieran Read, Isaac Ross, Brad Thorn, Neemia Tialata, Andrew Hore, Tony Woodcock. Reserves: Keven Mealamu, John Afoa, Bryn Evans, Tanerau Latimer, Piri Weepu, Luke McAlister, Lelia Masaga.

France: Maxime Medard, Cedric Heymans, Mathieu Bastareaud, Vincent Clerc, Damien Traille, Francois Trinh-Duc, Julien Dupuy; Louis Picamoles, Fulgence Ouedraogo, Thierry Dusautoir (c), Romain Millo-Chluski, Pascal Pape, Sylvain Marconnet, William Servat, Fabien Barcella. Reserves: Dimitri Szarzewski, Nicolas Mas, Thomas Domingo, Sebastien Chabal, Remy Martin, Julien Puricelli, Dimitri Yachvili, Yannick Jauzion, Alexis Palisson (two to be omitted later this afternoon).

- © Fairfax NZ News

8 comments
Post a comment
Andy   #8   09:43 pm Jun 13 2009

Well there we go. A McAllister brain explosion with a ridiculous dropgoal 2 years ago, and his return to Test footy sees a weak intercept to gift the game to France. Way to go Luke.

To be fair, some pretty woeful forward play in the 1st half lost this game. 2 tries down due to individuals trying to take on a team. Where were the numbers hitting the rucks? Mauls are a disgrace and a blight on rugby also. How do you contest the ball? The contest is a basic part of the game, but how can you do that when 7 men are allowed to be offside and protect 1 man? We are inches away from American foosball.

Great defence by the Frogs, yet again though. Played the ref and were up in the AB faces all night. However, it also begs the question, are the IRB taking the pi$$? Why do NZ v Fra games atract inexperienced, bordering on incompetent, refs? He had no idea at the scrums, couldn't keep a gap in the lineouts, seemed to not understand offside in the backline, and total disregard for the timing required to properly pack a scrum. Ref Clancy? More like Chief Clancy Wiggum.

Matt   #7   09:40 pm Jun 13 2009

0Although the AB's deserved to lose with there appalling effort...

The ref sucked.... anyone think he had a good game??? seriously???... OMG is it evident he has never played the game(and if he did he would have been reserve orange peeler... The scrums were case and point.... the french front row were taking the mickey by the end... see the high fives after the rediculous penatly for them popping? Neither front row had a clue what the ref was thinking...one word "lottery"

Well done the french.. AB's were below average at best

Paul Kennedy   #6   08:01 pm Jun 13 2009

J Lindsay, I could not agree more!

Margaret   #5   07:51 pm Jun 13 2009

Opportunity knocked loudly before the game even started for these young bucks to show us that they are proud to represent their country. I know this has stuff all to do with the comments of the article but I couldnt find anywhere else to vent my frustrations. I am fed up with the average kiwi idolising the All Blacks when the All Blacks cannot even show us how proud they are to be representing us. Luke McAllister spent the whole anthem with his head down looking at the ground, Weepu didnt even sing, neither did Nonu, Cowan, and others I can't be bothered trying to name. Thank you Isaac Ross for showing us how proud you are to be our newest All Black and representing our great country. Time to make it compulsory for the All Blacks to learn the words to our national anthem.

DJ   #4   03:51 pm Jun 13 2009

Realy excited to see just what we have here. This is not a weak French team. On the contrary. This All Black team just doesn't have a good feel. Not because of missing stars, but selection is all over the place. The reason the Crusaders go so well is because of the systems in place. So we wil see how good this program is. And no, I am not a Henry hater, Viva la kiwi.

rexhapi   #3   11:31 am Jun 13 2009

Why does Paddy insist on trialling his inexperienced refs in NZ v France tests? The last one was a farcical joke (Barnes). France will play it slow and try to drag us down to their level. It won't work but it will keep the score down. A whitle happy Irish ref will also contribute to a stop-start lack lustre affair. Pity.

J Lindsay   #2   09:28 am Jun 13 2009

"The All Blacks are one injury away from a scrum featuring Hawke's Bay's Bryn Evans. That's why there is the sniff of an upset in the Dunedin air and it has brought with it anticipation and edge"

Methinks having some of the proud and highly successful HB team in the ABs a cause for celebration and calm, rather than consternation....but thanks for your input anyway.

Amie   #1   08:24 am Jun 13 2009

I think this will be a great opportunity for new players to find their feet and make their mark. Too often coaches and teams start the experienced players to win the non important matches. These players either peek too early or fall to injury. Having replacements that are fresh and have had the chance to gain experience maybe our answer to finally winning the world cup.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Has rugby had a fair deal at the Halberg Awards over the years?

No. They should have won more gongs than they have.

It's been about right.

More than a fair deal. Other sports are more deserving.

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content