Dan Carter may be a Canterbury no show

BY HAMISH BIDWELL
Last updated 05:00 01/07/2009
george whitelock
PETER MEECHAM/The Pres
GEORGE WHITELOCK: Named for Canterbury, but could be called up for All Blacks duty.
owen franks
DON SCOTT/The Press
OWEN FRANKS: The fortunes of the All Blacks front row will determine whether he turns out for Canterbury.
wyatt crockett
DAVID HALLETT/The Press
WYATT CROCKETT: Another All Black who may see little or no time in red and black.

Relevant offers

Rugby

UK league coach searches for Crusaders' secret Quade Cooper's fixed-up knee gets early test Aussie teams face uneven playing field - White Smith and Dickson in Highlanders midfield Smith will lead Hurricanes in opener - Hammett Rebels look to lift for Blues in Super trial Whitelock boys set to re-unite on rugby field Sharpe to retire at end of Super Rugby season Rural clash sets up 'Canes for foreign fields Weepu to start at first-five for the Blues

Daniel Carter has been named in the Canterbury squad but is no certainty to play for the province in the Air New Zealand Cup.

Coach Rob Penney announced 35 players - the 30 predicted yesterday - along with All Blacks Richie McCaw, Brad Thorn, Kieran Read, Isaac Ross and Wyatt Crockett. They included Carter, who has not played since rupturing his Achilles tendon playing for Perpignan against Stade Francais in late January.

It has been well-publicised that the star first five-eighth would make his return to action via Canterbury, but the coach hinted that Carter could go straight back into the national side.

"He's back doing some work and we'll be guided by the (All Blacks) medical team and I've got no idea (when he might play for Canterbury)," Penney said yesterday.

"We're assuming that he's going to play some footy for us first, but there's probably no guarantees of that so we'll react to what the needs of the teams above us are.

"All I'm saying is that these discussions have yet to be had and we're sort of assuming one or two things, and things can change. I'd hate to say 100 per cent categorically that he's going to be available for Canterbury but it's highly likely.

"We just need to finalise these discussions as he progresses through."

Happy to play for the Crusaders, Carter has not always been so keen to turn out for Canterbury.

"He's got his reasons for that but if he's keen to play for Canterbury it's important that we give him the opportunity to get himself back to the physical fitness to represent the country in the way that we know he can," the coach said.

Penney named a squad of just 27 for last year's title-winning campaign and ultimately used 34 as All Blacks and injured players became available. Because the All Blacks Tri-Nations team will not be announced until Saturday he has included all of those in that mix, along with a lengthy list of wounded.

Not fit to play at present are Peter Borlase, Casey Laulala, Andy Ellis, Corey Flynn, Ti'i Paulo or Tu Umaga-Marshall. Borlase and Umaga-Marshall could be in a few weeks, but there is a good chance the others will not be right in time for Canterbury's competition-opener against North Harbour on August 1.

Ad Feedback

Penney said that while it was "very fair" to say the squad was light on experience in the tight five, it would not be a valid excuse for poor results.

"You could have a development focus on it but at this end of our domestic competitions it's elite and it's performance and outcome driven, so we won't be talking about this being a time to develop, a time to grow or a time to mature as a player."

CANTERBURY

FORWARDS: Andrew Olorenshaw (Burnside), Rodney Ah You (Linwood), Peter Borlase (Burnside), Owen Franks (Linwood), Corey Flynn (Sydenham), Ti'i Paulo (University), Will Catherwood (Burnside), Luke Romano (HSOB), James Broadhurst (Linwood), Sam Whitelock (Lincoln University), Isaac Ross (New Brighton), Brad Thorn (Burnside), Matt Todd (Christchurch), Michael Paterson (Christchurch), Kieran Read (University), George Whitelock (HSOB), Richie McCaw (Christchurch), Ash Parker (Burnside), Nasi Manu (Sydenham).

BACKS: Willie Heinz (Linwood), Tyson Keats (New Brighton), Andy Ellis (University), Dan Carter (Southbridge), Colin Slade (HSOB), Stephen Brett (University), Tim Bateman (Christchurch), Ryan Crotty (New Brighton), Adam Whitelock (HSOB), Casey Laulala (Marist Albion), Chris Small (HSOB), Sean Maitland (Linwood), Tu Umaga-Marshall (Sydenham), James Paterson (HSOB), Sam Monaghan (Christchurch).

- © Fairfax NZ News

15 comments
Post a comment
Dylan Williams   #15   11:43 am Jul 06 2009

Filipos gone to france because jacks coming back, cant remember which team filipos signed with though

Honest   #14   03:19 pm Jul 01 2009

Television is to blame for the continual decrease in attendances. Why would one bother to go to a game when the surroundings at home are much more enjoyable. Warmth, commentary, beers, food, friends CHEAP... makes so much sense. So much sense that everyone is starting to do it! its called a recession people... but its also called priorities... Rugby just isn't what it use to be... this is what happens when the All Blacks lose their Mana

PAUL   #13   01:14 pm Jul 01 2009

I cant believe the arrogance of the rugby union. They should be thinking of better ways to sell their product. If businesses go broke through lack of customers is it the customers fault? Last years NPC games were much better than the All Black rubbish to date. If local fans dont get to see the All Blacks at NPC or Crusader games support for the AB's is sure to disappear. AB games overseas at ungodly hours just dont cut it anymore. Bring back proper international tours. If Canterbury played Australia, Scotland, etc etc then the stadium would be full.

oakley   #12   01:06 pm Jul 01 2009

jeez they only got 18000 at christchurch (against italy)... bring the game back to the provinces like new plymouth (against samoa!) paying full price and selling out its 26,000 seats. Step up christchurch or lose out. However i still agree ticket prices are far too expensive... espesh as im starting to save for the world cup $1000 ticket prices already!

mike   #11   12:07 pm Jul 01 2009

PS - Kirwee have once again been shunned from representative honours.

Redraw.

mike   #10   12:04 pm Jul 01 2009

Andy #8, if you've been eating Fillet Steak for the past 10 years and then somebody serves you chuck steak and expects you to pay the same price... it's not going to happen. Christchurch gets the big games... Italy is not a big game.

There were plenty of reasons not to attend the test prior to the players providing (in hindsight) the most compelling. One of the biggest turn offs for me is the half completed stadium. Not much they can do about this I know, but the atmosphere is nonexistent. They simply should've played that test elsewhere, there would've been minimal complaints believe me.

Furthermore, if they play night games to maximise TV audiences and theoretically inflate the amount the NZRFU make by selling the broadcast rights... why are gate takings so crucial? I don't have a business degree but I'd have thought that gate takings are purely the cream on top... so they should get what they can. To argue the point, would you pay the same amount to see the All Blacks play Italy as you would to see them play the Boks? Which brings me back to fillet steak v chuck steak.

Tim   #9   11:54 am Jul 01 2009

Tyson Keats is very average. Steve Alfield has played well at half back for Christchurch club this year. he should be in the squad.

Andy   #8   10:37 am Jul 01 2009

Bruiser #3 - While you do have a point in that it's better to sell all the tickets at 3/4 the price, as opposed to half the tickets at full price, I don't think you've thought it through entirely.

Test tickets are the same price throughout the country. Carisbrook was sold out at full prices, so why should Christchurch get a discount just because they are too lazy to attend? Wellington was pretty close to a sellout, although there were a lot more empty seats. Which makes me wonder - If the prices are too high, how come some people bought a ticket but chose not to turn up due to the weather? A lot of money to waste I think.

18,000 tickets at prices ranging from $40-120 was all Chch could muster and it's our 2nd biggest city. I imagine they could easily sell that many tickets had the game been played in New Plymouth/Napier/etc (unsure of ground capacaties there, but you get my point). However, had they taken the Test there and Chch not got a game at all then there would be a huge outcry. The NZRU are bit damned if the do, damned if they don't at the moment. No matter what decision they seem to make there is always someone ready to condemn them all.

If we want to keep the ABs playing in NZ, just look in Oct. Last year was a big crowd in HK, this year will be a big crowd in Tokyo. If the NZRU can make their money overseas and the so-called fans in NZ aren't prepared to go to local Tests.......... well, you don't need a business degree to work it out!

Snake sharma   #7   10:35 am Jul 01 2009

I'm surprised there aren't a few more Belfast Cobras in there? Sssssnakes...

Glen   #6   10:11 am Jul 01 2009

Ray, Ross Filipo is playing for Bayonne in the French top 14.


Show 1-5 of 15 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Has rugby had a fair deal at the Halberg Awards over the years?

No. They should have won more gongs than they have.

It's been about right.

More than a fair deal. Other sports are more deserving.

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content