Richie McCaw is still world's best flanker

TAINE RANDELL
Last updated 05:00 14/09/2011
Richie McCaw
Getty Images
VERSATILE: Taine Randell believes Richie McCaw has adapted his game and is now an outstanding ball carrier.

Related Links

Quade Cooper a 'boofhead' for baiting McCaw Martin Johnson disappointed with Lawes ban Aussies buzzing over competitive edge Muliaina, Smith likely to return for Japan Where there's Will, there's Radike Samo RWC 2011 - Sticking to the winning plan

Relevant offers

All Blacks

All Black star Dan Carter won't fade lightly into the night Money the big factor in Dan Carter's move to Racing Metro Dan Carter confirms deal with French club Racing Metro Calls for alcohol-free sport 'Amazing' All Blacks can beat odds: Henry World Cup's not everything, says All Blacks coach Knowler: Steve Hansen still has work to do Steve Hansen appointed as All Blacks coach beyond World Cup Hansen expected to be offered All Blacks extension Carter tipped to be rugby's first '$2 million man'

OPINION: There has been a lot of recent speculation and some strong comments made about Richie McCaw's form.

The criticism seems related to the fact that he was injured for a long period in the Super Rugby season and that when he came back he didn't immediately recapture the form we all know him for.

As a result, there's been no shortage of people suggesting father time has caught up with one of our greats.

I can't agree.

When you judge the best No 7s in international rugby, it all comes down to what your criteria is - what you're looking at.

David Pocock and Heinrich Brussow may be catching the eye because they grab a couple of turnovers per game and people think that's fantastic play. They then compare that to McCaw who may only be getting one - and not in an eye-catching fashion as we've come to expect from him.

But that's a superficial viewpoint. You need to look at the way the game has changed. The game for a No 7 isn't so much about just getting those turnovers any more; it's also about making a number of tackles, proving yourself a destructive tackler and acting as a good ball carrier.

McCaw's game has developed to a point where his impact is not so much about getting in there and forcing those turnovers.

Given the rule changes which now favour the team with the ball, it's a change that was inevitable.

Against Tonga, McCaw made the most tackles among the All Blacks. If you compare that to the other No 7s at the World Cup, while also taking into account how the role of an openside flanker has evolved, I still think he's  the No 1 in the world.

Pocock and Brussow's ball carrying is non-existent compared to McCaw's.

So ask me to rank the top openside flankers at the World Cup in order and I'd have McCaw at No 1, David Pocock as the second best, then Brussow, followed by Wales' Sam Warburton then Thierry Dusautoir from France.

Pocock is a great player and may be the second best but he's still got a way to go with his ball carrying.

Brussow is the typical South African openside and is probably the best at that pilfering role.

He is short, stocky and powerful and is also well complemented in that he has some big South African loose forwards to play alongside.

Warburton is the up-and-comer. He is a young man who's still to mature physically, but he has the makings of a very good No 7 because he has a good combination of all of the requirements.

Ad Feedback

Dusautoir is more a tackler than a pilferer and has a very high work-rate.

The All Blacks team to play Japan on Friday is named this morning and there has been debate as to whether the coaches should have McCaw and Mils Muliaina play their 100th tests at the same time. McCaw is on 99 and Muliaina is at 98.

There should be no sentimentality towards them playing their 100th test together. That counts for zero at a World Cup.

The All Blacks have got to win this tournament and if the selectors think that Israel Dagg is the best fullback then they should keep picking him.

I'd love to see Mils get to 100 but unfortunately milestones like that can't be considered at a World Cup.

* Taine Randell was captain of the 1999 All Blacks' World Cup squad

- Stuff

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Who was the best-performed All Blacks forward on the northern tour?

Dane Coles

Nathan Harris

Keven Mealamu

Wyatt Crockett

Charlie Faumuina

Ben Franks

Owen Franks

Joe Moody

Brodie Retallick

Luke Romano

Jeremy Thrush

Patrick Tuipulotu

Sam Whitelock

Sam Cane

Jerome Kaino

Richie McCaw

Liam Messam

Kieran Read

Vitor Vito

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content