Carter ruled out of Rugby World Cup

RICHARD KNOWLER AND NEIL REID
Last updated 10:35 02/10/2011

RWC 2011: Dan Carter out for World Cup

Dan Carter injury
Getty Images Zoom
Dan Carter goes down in a heap with a tournament-ending groin injury.
Opinion poll

Can the All Blacks win the World Cup without Dan Carter?

Yes

No

Vote Result

Related Links

RWC 2011: Dan Carter out for World Cup Dan Carter injury Backing Black fan event in Wellington Graham Henry: Time to believe in Colin Slade Australian sympathy for injured Dan Carter Fox: RWC victory possible, but much harder Piri Weepu should be handed All Blacks' No 10 Time for Piri Weepu to back up Dan Carter

Relevant offers

All Blacks

Fox: Smith gets nod over Taylor for versatility Injured Richard Kahui to miss Ireland tests Barrett blown away - but not carried away I owe Dave Rennie, says halfback trialist Smith Graham Henry: Hansen not making mistakes Injury opens door for Zac Guildford recall Kerr-Barlow missed text from ABs manager Brad Shields has family night out to remember Late bloomer Luke Romano bursts into ABs No way back to All Blacks for Jimmy Cowan

LATEST: Dan Carter is out of the World Cup.

All Blacks first five-eighth Carter has been ruled out of the rest of the tournament because of the groin injury he suffered at yesterday's captains run and Colin Slade will now be expected to wear the No 10 jersey for the crucial play-off matches.

Carter has torn the adductor longus tendon in his left groin. His place in the squad has been taken by Manawatu's Aaron Cruden who was yesterday contacted by manager Darren Shand.

All Blacks coach Graham Henry said Stephen Donald was not considered as a replacement.

Henry said he spent time with Carter after the scan revealed the extent of the injury and said the player was coping "remarkably well'' with the bad news.

"I just feel huge sympathy for him and his situation,'' Henry, who has had the shine taken off his 100th test in charge of the All Blacks today, added.

He urged the media to show sensitivity but added the Cantabrian has a "huge strength of character''.

"It is devastating for Daniel. He has been probably one of the greatest players produced by this country and this was going to be his pinnacle. He was focusing on this tournament for the last couple of years and it is devastating he cannot be involved in that.''

He added it was a "tragic situation for a highly talented young sportsman'' and he felt "very sad'' for Carter.

"This was his scene really. A World Cup in New Zealand and it was going to be his big, big, big occasion if you like.''

The TAB reacted to the news, with the All Blacks still hot favourites to win the tournament, easing out to $1.60, while South Africa dropped to $6 and Australia $7.

Team doctor Deb Robinson said there was no reason for the injury or any indication this groin problem was flaring up. It just appears to be a terrible stroke of misfortune.

"He had no symptoms on the day. It just happened totally out of the blue. There is just no reason.''

This is a massive blow for All Blacks fans who are hoping their side will lift the Webb Ellis Cup for the first time since 1987.

Carter will consult a specialist in Auckland tomorrow and surgery could be an option.

And what makes this news even more devastating for Carter, and New Zealand fans, is that he has rarely been sidelined by this sort of injury.

The world's premier playmaker appeared to be in considerable pain when he suffered the injury during a kicking drill at the end of the light training run.

Ad Feedback

Carter who also played in the 2003 and 2007 tournaments will be gutted to have his world title dreams destroyed by such an innocuous incident.

It is not just his calm demeanour under pressure that will be missed by the All Blacks. He is a vital member of the team's leadership group and has the ability to snap open games with his magnificent skills - both with the ball in hand or when kicking for field position or for goal.

Henry added it was now important for his squad to recover from the shock news and not to lose focus for the remainder of the tournament.

"We need to move on as well. We have been dealt the cards we have got and it is very important that we play them superbly. The group, obviously, is shattered with this news but also are also a resilient group of people who are focused on doing this job right.

"It is obviously a tragedy but we just need to show strength in this situation.''

Henry is now likely to keep selecting Slade in the sudden death matches but can also ponder using Piri Weepu at first-five - as well as Slade.

Slade will start this afternoon's match against Canada at the Cake Tin.

Adding to the All Blacks' injury concerns is that captain Richie McCaw withdrew yesterday because of ongoing concerns about his right foot injury.

Veteran Carter, who has played 85 tests, was to captain the team this afternoon in McCaw's absence. Instead that honour has been flicked to Andrew Hore.

Openside flanker McCaw has been replaced by Victor Vito but the skipper is adamant he will be fit for next weekend's quarterfinal.

When told of the news last night, a stunned All Blacks great Waka Nathan said: "Christ, we've got problems ... it's bloody terrible.

"He [Carter] would be a huge loss. But injuries are one of those things."

Former All Blacks captain Taine Randell said Carter's loss would have a massive impact on the side's chances of success.

A veteran of the 1999 world cup campaign, Randell said Carter's kicking skills and ability to handle the pressure of test rugby would be near to impossible to replace.

"For us, he is crucial ... Carter is probably the most important guy," Randell said.

"I would still back the All Blacks but certainly not with the same confidence."

Both Nathan and Randell said they had concerns about Carter's back-up, Canterbury's Colin Slade.

Nathan said: "I'm not that much of a fan for Slade.

"I would maybe even change [Piri] Weepu into first five.""The drop in level to how Colin Slade operates is so big," said Randell. "That is why he [Carter] is so important to us."

- Fairfax NZ

* Comments are now closed on this story.

490 comments
Matiu Mete   #490   01:41 pm Oct 02 2011

Yes, this is a big blow for us but we have an awesome forward pack that is starting to hum along nicely. As we've seen at past world cups, and this one too, it is very foward orientated so we will go well...not as gr8 with Carter missing but we will go gr8...Put Weepu at first-five and Ellis at half-back...we have the best centre pairing in the game with Nonu and Smith and that is a huge confidence builder...We have awesome players in the rest of the positions too...We will do well, we will make to the final and good news will follow...Chin up AB's...get better soon Carter...Kia Kaha!!

Wayne branks   #489   via mobile 01:40 pm Oct 02 2011

Kiwifornian, well done good trainspotting.

Anna Morozova   #488   01:39 pm Oct 02 2011

Be ashamed! who wrights weeping comments. It does not sounds like kiwis to me at all. Rugby is about tactics and spirit. We have it all! Feel really sorry for Carter. It's a big personal tragedy for him. GO ALL BLACKS!!!!!

Cate   #487   01:37 pm Oct 02 2011

So sorry to hear about Dan, I am a Wallabies fan and ruptured a tendon walking back from the ABs/Japan game a few weeks ago. Need a total ankle reconstruction and tendon transplant. If I could give Dan my tendon, I would. He deserves to be there with Ritchie lifting Bill at the end. Do it for Dan now ABs.

mikster   #486   01:33 pm Oct 02 2011

Biggest loss of any team in any world cup for sure. But, Slade may not be Carter (Weepu may be a possible stand-in - I would pick Cruden, but concerns about match fitness) we are still only 4 wins away from a World Cup.

Every World Cup where the All Blacks are unbeatable favourites, we have lost. Now, we are wounded and look vulnerable - I think the boys can and will do it for Dan. There is still a stack of talent on the park - more so than most squads.

And while we have no flyhalf that even comes close Carter - neither has any other side.

Dan   #485   01:32 pm Oct 02 2011

It is a huge loss but I am certain the All Blacks can and will win the world cup. If Colin Slade does not step up in todays game I hope Aaron Cruden get s the call up. Failing this have Piri Weepu step into first five and Jimmy Cowan into halfback for the remainder of the tournament. The toughest match will be the semi final where I see All Blacks v Springboks. All Blacks will win but it will be a closely fought match. I see an All Blacks v Ireland final. Go All Blacks. Keep faith New Zealand.

dr phil   #484   01:30 pm Oct 02 2011

When in trouble When in doubt Run in circles Scream and shout

I say Bring Back Buck!

gotheABS   #483   via mobile 01:28 pm Oct 02 2011

The ABs can still win. Rugby is a teams sport and although DC is the best in the world the ABs still have the best squad. Colin Slade can do the job and we all need to stand behind him and the team so they know we belivev and support them. Now isd our time and true kiwi All Black supporters to stand our ground get in behind our team and support them and DC.

DC thanks for getting us to this point, godf bless and speedy recovery 2015 is now your goal and we all know you can be their. All teams have injury problems but we have Colin Slade and Aaron Cruden plus Weepu as back up we'll be fine. Go the ABs.

porky   #482   01:27 pm Oct 02 2011

who cares, he can have another rest now. Bring on the real men, the mighty Warriors who don't need a rest every 2nd week to recover from a meaningless game

Ian   #481   01:25 pm Oct 02 2011

The real question is not "Can the All Blacks win the world Cup without Dan Carter?" but "Can Dan Carter still model underwear with an injury like that?"


Show 431-480 of 490 comments
Special offers
Opinion poll

Which of the uncapped loose forwards named yesterday is most likely to be an All Blacks starter at the 2015 World Cup?

Sam Cane

Brad Shields

Luke Whitelock

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content