Cruden plays second string to puppet master

LIAM NAPIER IN ROME
Last updated 05:00 17/11/2012
Cruden STD
Getty Images
CHEER UP: Cruden will get his chance against Italy, but faces the possiblity he will return to the bench very soon.

Related Links

Schoolboy trip shapes Messam's rugby future Savea is on target for All Black greatness Read speaks about taking All Blacks captaincy Leadership skills derived from past legends Are the All Blacks too good to be defeated? Great All Black as humble as he was talented

Relevant offers

All Blacks

Wales without Sam Warburton for England 'redemption' before All Blacks series Whitelock hamstrung by injury and scratched from Super Rugby game against Blues Jeff To'omaga-Allen studiously avoiding any thoughts of All Blacks selection Highlanders fullback Ben Smith confirmed as All Blacks vice-captain for 2016 season Former All Blacks fullback Greg Cooper joins Stade Francais coaching team Leigh Halfpenny in line for Toulon return ahead of Wales' tour to New Zealand SBW gets award for giving RWC medal to English fan who got offside with security Wales legend Adam Jones reveals his Lions XV to face the All Blacks in 2017 New Zealand Maori will face Harlequins in London to finish their northern tour Liam Napier, Richard Knowler: Who should make the All Blacks starting line-up?

Aaron Cruden's test claims won't be much clearer after he plays Italy in Rome tomorrow.

It's not a slight on the Chiefs first five-eighth, but after his fifth test start he'll return to the bench in Cardiff and hand the reins to Dan Carter. That seems as certain as a 12th victory over the Azzurri at Stadio Olimpico.

Some argue Carter's influence on the All Blacks' game is greater than Richie McCaw's - the rationale being that Carter has the ability to both win and lose a match. Last week's victory at Murrayfield emphasised his status as the world's premier No 10.

This week, Cruden again faces the unenviable task of playing in Carter's shadow.

"I try to go out there and put my spin on it," Cruden said. "Dan has been the benchmark for a few years. We're totally different players.

"He had a fantastic start to the tour last week."

The problem is that Cruden can't build momentum in the black jersey.

Carter is the puppet master and his understudy rarely gets a chance to pull the strings.

Unless Carter suffers another long-term injury, there is no chance Cruden will be given enough consecutive starts to grow his game.

In last year's dominant World Cup semifinal victory over Australia, he was composed beyond his years. This season he played no small part in the Chiefs' first Super Rugby title.

And against Ireland in June, he produced a 25-minute masterclass before being injured.

On his day, Cruden's elusive pace and ability to take on the line can get the All Blacks' machine humming in the same fashion as Carter.

It may not be a stretch to suggest Carter admired Cruden's running game this year and realised he needed to bring his own back.

But it took only two scratchy starts against the Pumas and Springboks for doubts to emerge about Cruden's ability to take control of tight tests. There were even premature suggestions Beauden Barrett would soon surpass him in the pecking order.

Cruden could be forgiven for feeling his 18th test is another deja vu trial.

"To come in and command and be the voice doesn't come naturally to rookie players," All Blacks coach Steve Hansen said. "From what I've seen this week Aaron's learnt he needs to be the boss. He's stepped up really well and I'm sure that will go into his game."

The 23-year-old is conscious he needs to take control and is relishing the prospect of unleashing Ma'a Nonu, Julian Savea and Hosea Gear.

Ad Feedback

Aaron Smith provides a familiar face in the reunited Manawatu halves pairing, but he, too, will be a tad edgy.

Piri Weepu applied the pressure with his best performance of the year against Scotland, placing heat on Smith to regain his zip after a rare poor outing in the Brisbane draw.

Tomorrow's test might well be another ugly grinding effort.

The Azzurri have made eight changes to the team which scraped past Tonga last week, and the referee is pedantic Irishman Alain Rolland, who averages 20.7 penalties (one every 1:37 minute) per game.

The Italians' love affair with scrums will continue and their spoiling tactics are effective.

That might initially make life difficult for Smith and Cruden to shine, but even with 14 starting changes the All Blacks should improve on their previous effort against Italy, a 14-point margin. Fairfax NZ

- The Dominion Post

Special offers
Opinion poll

Who was the best-performed All Blacks forward on the northern tour?

Dane Coles

Nathan Harris

Keven Mealamu

Wyatt Crockett

Charlie Faumuina

Ben Franks

Owen Franks

Joe Moody

Brodie Retallick

Luke Romano

Jeremy Thrush

Patrick Tuipulotu

Sam Whitelock

Sam Cane

Jerome Kaino

Richie McCaw

Liam Messam

Kieran Read

Vitor Vito

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content