Rough justice for All Black Adam Thomson

Last updated 05:00 25/11/2012
Adam Thomson
JAPAN BOUND: Adam Thomson will play for the Canon Eagles in Japan.

Related Links

Adam Thomson 'exposed to double jeopardy' Adam Thomson's ban extended to two weeks Adam Thomson fired up by future plan Tour swansong possible for Adam Thomson Flanker Adam Thomson set to head overseas All Blacks are ready to squeeze Scotland ABs and the north have never seen eye-to-eye ABs take steps toward future development Welsh World Cup comments fire up ABs Wounded Welsh sound warning to ABs ABs sweat over Dan Carter's injured leg

Relevant offers

All Blacks

Tawera Kerr-Barlow still upbeat despite injury likely ruling him out of All Blacks Wales without Sam Warburton for England 'redemption' before All Blacks series Whitelock hamstrung by injury and scratched from Super Rugby game against Blues Jeff To'omaga-Allen studiously avoiding any thoughts of All Blacks selection Highlanders fullback Ben Smith confirmed as All Blacks vice-captain for 2016 season Former All Blacks fullback Greg Cooper joins Stade Francais coaching team Leigh Halfpenny in line for Toulon return ahead of Wales' tour to New Zealand SBW gets award for giving RWC medal to English fan who got offside with security Wales legend Adam Jones reveals his Lions XV to face the All Blacks in 2017 New Zealand Maori will face Harlequins in London to finish their northern tour

The end of the Adam Thomson saga was as insipid as its beginning.

As far as political footballs go, the All Blacks blindside was kicked from Edinburgh, to London, to Cardiff and back.

It was, in the end, a waste of everybody's time as the original two-week suspension was halved, then restored over a senseless three-week circus, leaving Thomson, the All Blacks third-choice blindside, available for selection against England next week.

The main act of this media circus was International Rugby Board boss Brett Gosper, who tweeted his way into the big top to kick things off in politically incorrect fashion.

And so, to last night's final decision of the independent appeal committee, and New Zealand Rugby Union chief executive Steve Tew's carefully worded response. Tew was critical of the judicial process, but clearly didn't see the worth in creating any bad blood with the new, outspoken Australian IRB boss.

"The process would warrant some review. Having to wait six days for the written decision before an appeal is made is far too long," Tew told the Sunday Star-Times at Cardiff last night. "The chairman of the appeal mentioned that in his summing up at the end. That is something the IRB will have to look at.

"The appeal provision is there and the IRB exercised that. Adam got a fair hearing and we're happy with the result. He's able to play next week if selected."

Tew lobbied to get the appeal - regulation 17 - erased from rugby's global constitution in May this year and Thomson's drawn-out case only reinforced his view it needed to be scrapped.

"This was one of the changes that got voted on in the most recent amendments. It was something we weren't particularly happy to see in there, but ultimately it got the support from the group. There is room for some ultimate body keeping a watch in case something goes fundamentally wrong.

"The question the IRB will be asking themselves is, if this was the right way to appeal or not. I would suggest from the result probably not, but that's a matter of opinion."

It's impossible to argue with Tew. Thomson's result served to highlight the IRB's glaring inconsistencies after thuggish South African prop Dean Greyling and Australian flanker Scott Higginbotham were slapped with wet bus tickets earlier this year. As for Gosper's need to appease the British press, Tew was reluctant to rock the boat so early in his tenure.

Ad Feedback

Privately, at least, there is little doubt he was irritated by the unprofessional manner in which the process was conducted.

"He tweeted they would be looking at it. It's not for me to comment. That's something for them to consider," Tew said of Gosper's opinion spilling into the public sphere without proper consultation. "He's got a job to do. I don't have a problem with that.

"I've already met with Brett on several occasions. He's obviously a very capable man in his own right. I'm hopeful he will do a very good job. I look forward to working with him."

- Stuff


Special offers
Opinion poll

Who was the best-performed All Blacks forward on the northern tour?

Dane Coles

Nathan Harris

Keven Mealamu

Wyatt Crockett

Charlie Faumuina

Ben Franks

Owen Franks

Joe Moody

Brodie Retallick

Luke Romano

Jeremy Thrush

Patrick Tuipulotu

Sam Whitelock

Sam Cane

Jerome Kaino

Richie McCaw

Liam Messam

Kieran Read

Vitor Vito

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content