How the All Blacks rated against England

Last updated 05:00 03/12/2012

Relevant offers

All Blacks

Rugby-mad cancer-surviving Canadian teen to meet ABs Charlie Ngatai to captain New Zealand Maori Reason: All Blacks believe as Wallabies grieve Patience pays dividends for loosie Victor Vito Romano gets chance despite lack of game time Mehrtens: Slade unlucky, but Carter call correct Carter call highlights importance to All Blacks Protected Carter still Hansen's go-to guy All Blacks name Dan Carter for northern tour All Blacks northern tour hope for Colin Slade

Fairfax rugby reporters Toby Robson and Liam Napier grade the All Blacks' performance against England at Twickenham.

Israel Dagg: 6

Went solo on counter-attack too often. Was caught out of position by some astute tactical kicking from the English and sliced a couple of clearing kicks under pressure.

Cory Jane: 7.5

After a horrid start where he missed a tackle, threw a pressure pass to Ma'a Nonu and kicked out on the full, Jane was superb. Had a role in all three tries.

Conrad Smith: 6

Cleaned up a lot of shoddy passes by taking the ball into contact and twice provided quick hands for tries. Made a blunder when he rushed out of the line, thinking Kieran Read had his inside when second-five Brad Barritt strolled through.

Ma'a Nonu: 6.5

Huge workrate. Had to deal with static, backward ball but attempted to make the best of a bad situation. Part of a midfield that was overshadowed though.

Julian Savea: 7

Another test, two more tries. Like Dagg, guilty of being individualistic at times but was solid under the high ball.

Dan Carter: 5

Something wasn't right with the off-kilter playmaker. He didn't admit to a ginger Achilles, but two pulled regulation kicks suggest otherwise. Unforgivably missed tackle on Tuilagi and, behind well beaten pack, there was no sign of his running game.

Aaron Smith: 6

Tailing form continued. Late to breakdown and wild passes contributed to a sub-par performance. Wasn't helped by timid forward display.

Kieran Read: 6

Not his usual high standard. Read has shouldered a massive workload this year and may have hit the wall. He gifted Tuilagi a try with an intercept pass and made a couple of defensive errors.

Richie McCaw: 6

Well looked after by England's loose trio. Didn't have his usual influence at the breakdown. Ran hard and defended with determination but quiet by his standards.

Liam Messam: 6

Went largely unnoticed throughout, other than looking after the bloke who manhandled Carter. A more physically imposing performance was required.

Sam Whitelock 5.5

Safe at kick-off reception and got one steal off in the lineout, but part of a well-beaten and out-muscled engine room.

Brodie Retallick 5

Being pulled just after half-time in search of more physicality wasn't a good sign. Didn't dominate the collisions but continues to have high energy and worked hard off the ball.

Ad Feedback

Owen Franks 5

Had a tough time with English loose-head Alex Corbisiero and, like Retallick, was pulled early in the second half.

Keven Mealamu 5

Short of a gallop after returning from injury. Easily contained with ball in hand and his opposite, Tom Youngs, was man-of-the-match.

Tony Woodcock 7

Probably the only tight forward to emerge with the ledger square. Had a ding dong battle with impressive tighthead Dan Cole. Carried strongly and defended the fringes with vigour.

Reserves:

Victor Vito: 5

Few good charges off the bench but needed more time to get into match.

Charlie Faumuina: 4

Test had opened up by the time he arrived. Hard for a prop to stand out in those circumstances.

Piri Weepu: 5

Had minimal ball to work with and, as was the case in Cardiff, spent much of his stint defending.

Luke Romano: 4

Turned to for physicality but couldn't find or puncture any holes in rock-solid England defensive line.

Dane Coles: 5

Sharp impact in the final 20 minutes, produced a strong fend and featured regularly in general play.

Wyatt Crockett: 4

Gave away a penalty by intentionally knocking ball down. Limited impact.

Not rated: Ben Smith

- Fairfax Media

Special offers
Opinion poll

Which three first-fives would you have taken on the All Blacks' northern tour?

Dan Carter, Beauden Barrett, Aaron Cruden

Dan Carter, Aaron Cruden, Colin Slade

Dan Carter, Beauden Barrett, Colin Slade

Beauden Barrett, Aaron Cruden, Colin Slade

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content