Super Rugby's burning questions: Is McCaw done?

Richie McCaw found the going tough against the Chiefs, but can he find form when it really counts?

OPINION: In our regular Friday segment, Stuff.co.nz's leading rugby scribes tackle the hot topics of the Super Rugby week.

Hansen has big calls to make on elder statesmen

All Blacks coach Steve Hansen has some decisions to ponder about Dan Carter, left, and Richie McCaw, right.

OPINION: Can the All Blacks coach rely on Richie McCaw and Dan Carter at the end of the year?

Knowler: Blackadder is really feeling the heat now

Todd Blackadder has always guided the Crusaders to the playoffs since taking over as head coach in 2009.

OPINION: With the Crusaders having won just four from nine, the task facing their coach is daunting.

Strang: Time to test Sopoaga in ABs jumper

The All Blacks should hand Highlanders first-five Lima Sopoaga a test jumper during the Rugby Championship.

OPINION: All Blacks selectors should initiate the Lima Sopoaga insurance policy during the Rugby Championship.

Robson: Carter, Barrett take pole position for No 10

Beauden Barrett would command a start for the All Blacks if the World Cup final was next week.

OPINION: The battle for the All Blacks No 10 jersey has effectively become a two-horse race.

Hinton: McCaw deserves better than this

Richie McCaw and his Crusaders mates may be short of their best at present, but time is on their side.

OPINION: The All Blacks great is no spent force after a slow start to the Super Rugby season with the struggling Crusaders.

Crusaders no longer the lords of Super Rugby

The Chiefs had plenty of reasons to smile after steamrolling the Crusaders in Christchurch on Friday night.

OPINION: Friday demolishing of the Crusaders affirmed what we all know - the Chiefs are now NZ's benchmark team.

Reason: Concussion rugby's biggest issue

Blues veteran Luke Braid has suffered two concussions this season and is expected to be sidelined for the next two weeks.

OPINION: Unless rugby acts on concussion now, it's finest warriors may one day be unable to feed themselves.

De Barra: Europe looming as ABs' main threat

Robbie Henshaw crosses for Ireland's match-winning try against England in this year's Six Nations.

OPINION: Cricket World Cup allows some fine performances from Europe's top teams go under the radar.

It's a no-brainer - cash will rule over jersey

Charles Piutau is off to Ireland after the Rugby World Cup.

OPINION: So Charles Piutau is off to Ulster and who can blame him, writes Ian Snook.

Toothless Sharks eaten alive by rampant Crusaders

David Havili dives over to score for the Crusaders in Durban.

OPINION: The Crusaders weren't going to allow a red card to Jean Deysel to screw them over this time.

Smith: A standard start to season for Crusaders

The Crusaders came undone against the Melbourne Rebels in Round One of Super Rugby.

OPINION: Crusaders doomsayers relax: Blackadder's mob are simply having their stock-standard slow start.

Gifford: Hurricanes look Super after another win

NOT STOPPING: Beauden Barrett on the attack against the Highlanders on Friday night.

OPINION: After five straight wins, the once brittle franchise has clearly found the formula for success.

Opinion: Super Rugby's three burning questions

CENTRE OF ATTENTION: The battle between centres Malakai Fekitoa (left) and Conrad Smith will be a highlight of the Hurricanes' visit to the Highlanders.

OPINION: Hurricanes or Highlanders? And are Dan Carter's World Cup prospects being compromised?

Deans drops in as Grizz's gang reunite

AROUND TOWN: Former Crusaders and Wallabies coach Robbie Deans.

OPINION: Robbie Deans returns to Christchurch but reminiscing with old Canterbury team-mates is the reason.

Opinion: Super Rugby's three burning questions

UNDERDOGS: Can Jamie Joseph and the Highlanders reach the playoffs for a second consecutive year?

OPINION: Fairfax Media’s leading rugby scribes tackle the three burning questions of the week.

Review: Ref's mistake blows full time on Blues

TOUGH LUCK: Sarel Pretorius from the Cheetahs celebrates his try during his side's win over the Blues in Bloemfontein on Saturday morning.

OPINION: Referee Rohan Hoffman cops criticism after penalising the Blues late in their loss to the Cheetahs on Saturday morning.

Fans vent as Crusaders capitulate against Chiefs

DESPONDENT: Crusaders first five-eighth Colin Slade following his team's hammering at the hands of the Chiefs in Hamilton.

OPINION: Backlash following defeat to Chiefs brutal. Some of the abuse vitriolic, some measured. Little missed its target.

Stars keep slipping through Blues' fingers

BAD MISS: Malakai Fekitoa was let go by the Blues.

OPINION: The Blues are in danger of looking like the Dick Rowes of New Zealand rugby.

Opinion: Cane you believe the hype?

ON A ROLL: Ma'a Nonu and the Hurricanes are two from two to start their Super Rugby campaign. Are they legitimate title contenders this year?

OPINION: Stuff.co.nz's leading rugby writers tackle the three burning rugby questions of the week.

Robson: Not-so-Super start for Kiwi franchises

OOPS: Highlanders centre Malakai Fekitoa loses the ball in the tackle of Crusaders lock Scott Barrett, left, and prop Owen Franks during their Super Rugby match in Dunedin on Saturday.

OPINION: If you're a Canes fan it's a case of who cares, but for everyone else it's been a predictably sketchy opening two weeks.

Review: Referees left seeing red in Super Rugby

SEEING RED: Blues lock Hayden Triggs is given his marching orders during the first half of Sunday's loss to the Stormers.

OPINION: When’s a punch not a punch? It depends on who is refereeing, it seems.

Opinion: Does DC still have it and is JK's job in doubt?

UNDER PRESSURE: Blues coach Sir John Kirwan is under pressure to get the best out of his Super Rugby franchise.

OPINION: Each week Stuff.co.nz's leading rugby writers will answer the three burning questions of the rugby week.

Pocock's principles an example of true leadership

GREAT EXAMPLE: David Pocock, left, with Clyde Rathbone during their time at the Brumbies.

OPINION: David Pocock's return to playing was great for rugby union, but he has made a bigger impact off the field.

Knowler: McCaw must make up his mind

STAY OR GO: Richie McCaw, who started at blindside flanker against the Rebels, is in the sunset of his career.

OPINION: The sooner Richie McCaw gets on with deciding his future, the better, writes Richard Knowler.

1st5R Super ratings - week one

QUICK OUT OF THE BLOCKS: Hurricanes playmaker Beauden Barrett started the Super Rugby season with a bang, leading the Hurricanes to a opening round over the Lions in Johannesburg.

OPINION: ABs regular starts with a bang and teenage youngster makes impressive debut as Super Rugby got underway.

Gifford: Crusaders open season with a whimper

BAD LOSS: Scott Higginbotham of the Rebels makes some yards against the Crusaders.

OPINION: It was bad enough to lose in front of a home crowd, worse still to lose to the Rebels.

Burdon: Still room on the Highlanders bandwagon

OUT OF THE BLUE: Highlanders centre Malakai Fekitoa burst onto the national scene last year.

OPINION: The reality is that space on the Highlanders bandwagon has shrunk like the polar ice cap over the summer.

Hinton: World Cup should be McCaw's final stage

NOTHING LEFT TO PROVE: Richie McCaw will make a decision on whether to play on after this year's World Cup in the coming weeks.

OPINION: All Blacks skipper to make a decision on his playing future in the coming weeks.

Robson: Sevens event's success a balancing act

SEVENS STAR: DJ Forbes of New Zealand.

OPINION: Is the Wellington Sevens about the rugby or the party, asks Toby Robson.

Ad Feedback
special offers