Page: Are coaches keeping up with the play?

Last updated 05:00 09/08/2014
Dan Carter
HURTING: Dan Carter watches the second half of the Super Rugby final from the sidelines after limping off hurt.

Relevant offers


Australia's domination of England chariot catapults them up World Cup power rankings Four burning questions about the Rugby World Cup with Toby Robson and Liam Napier Why can't the All Blacks put it together? Rugby World Cup pacesetting Wallabies set cracking pace for All Blacks stayers Mark Reason: England's ashes strewn all over Twickenham after record defeat Rugby World Cup nightmares to linger for England after loss to Wallabies John Campbell: Minnows with mojo sending a message Phil Gifford: All Blacks a misfiring Ferrari caught in suburban rush-hour traffic Toby Robson: Time for All Blacks to commit to their first-choice backline combination at the RWC David Campese: It's always a great feeling beating the Poms

OPINION: Having watched the 2014 Super Rugby final multiple times, it's worth pondering if coaches always make the right calls in the second half.

The Waratahs deserved to win that final; they played better throughout the 80 minutes, though questions must be asked as to what Crusaders stalwart Richie McCaw did wrong to concede the match-winning penalty.

All that aside, it seemed like Crusaders coach Todd Blackadder made some crucial errors that contributed to serious momentum shifts.

Those errors make you wonder if coaches are prepared to change the pre-match script when it comes to certain players, based on what they are seeing out on the field.

The first was the injury to Daniel Carter.

It made no sense that a man built like Carter, and with the skills he possesses in other areas was being used to crash the ball up like a 110kg midfield back from a lineout.

He is not going to bust tackles with raw power like Ma'a Nonu or Malakai Fekitoa and his kicking, passing and general eye for the game was far more valuable to his team than one bullocking hit-up that should have been left to centre, Ryan Crotty, a man who had done it many times in the past.

Carter doesn't shy away from the physical side of things like former pivot Andrew Mehrtens, but it was a needless play that cost Blackadder and now the All Blacks dearly.

The other was the substitution of prop Wyatt Crockett midway through the second half.

Just before he came off, the All Black had won two penalties for his team and destroyed two Waratahs scrums.

Clearly it was a move decided on pre-game, but surely the coaching staff could have seen he was going well and deserved to stay out there while he was still making a major impact.

These telegraphed substitutions make no sense.

These days players are being taken off five minutes into the second half,and it seems a waste.

Once Crockett went off, the Waratahs scrum steadied, his replacement Joe Moody suffered a head knock and was replaced after five minutes and the game had changed.

The situation was proof that things can change, and coaches perhaps need to move with the momentum to get the result they desire.

Ad Feedback

- The Timaru Herald


Special offers
Opinion poll

What did you make of this year's ITM Cup?

It was as good a season as I can remember.

It was great to see the smaller provinces perform well.

I caught the odd game here and there.

Sorry, it was an utter snore-fest.

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content