Quade Cooper vs Dan Carter? No contest really

Last updated 11:47 07/07/2011

Related Links

Quade Cooper's cult grows in Queensland Quade Cooper in Richie McCaw's sights Combination with Carter key for SBW - Deans Quade Cooper serious about switch: Tuqiri Jolts fail to blunt Carter's appetite for final win Crusaders 2011 Super Rugby images Crusaders v Stormers

Relevant offers


Page: Refs too quick to dish out yellow cards Snook: Taranaki's man from Gore a class act Reason: Man mountain Matfield still one of best Mehrtens: Beware of Boks as World Cup looms McCaw up off floor and to the fore once again Wilson: Boks picked on merit, not quotas Napier: Test match a long time in the making Snook: Give Barrett a chance or risk losing him Mehrtens: Refs a blight on international game Knowler: Blundering refs applying heat to IRB

OPINION: Quade Cooper is a poor man's Carlos Spencer. I'd stake my house on Dan Carter ahead of the flighty Queenslander any time.

The two go head to head in the Super Rugby final in Brisbane on Saturday night in what could be a pointer to bigger duels to come in the Tri-Nations and, most importantly, the World Cup.

Don't get me wrong, Cooper is a real talent and arguably the most exciting individual running around the Super scene this year.

He's made some big strides, bringing a bit more consistency to go with his electric game.

He's a handful for any defence who won't know what he's planning to do until it's unfolding in front of them.

But there are a couple of things that come with Cooper's unpredictable approach. It's a high-risk game he plays and it's also one based on confidence.

New Zealanders should be used to this. We went through the heart-attacks that came with Spencer's approach. Brilliant one minute, insane the next.

Is it a coincidence that Cooper looks a little like Spencer, body ink and all? Surprise, surprise, the Tokoroa-transplant concedes Spencer was one of his heroes.

Cooper has cleverly walked a tightrope this year but I can't help but feel that he's an accident waiting to happen, that he will produce one trick too many that will fall into the hands of the Crusaders or the All Blacks.

Those Kiwi sides make a living off turnovers, so think twice Quade, even though that isn't a trait of your instinctive game.

Then there's Cooper's goalkicking. It's streaky. Even in the semifinal against the Blues his kicking for goal was shoddy while the match was tight early. A sign of tightness and nerves? Perhaps.

The Aussies made much of his late dropped goal against the Blues as being a clever ploy that could pay dividends later in the season. Fair enough, but they overlooked his earlier wobbles from the kicking tee.

Cooper is a far from proven force at test level and it will be interesting to see if Robbie Deans has the ultimate faith in him as the international season unfolds.

Deans isn't short of alternatives from James O'Connor to Matt Giteau to Berrick Barnes.

Form would suggest Cooper has the Wallabies No 10 jersey for the Tri-Nations, especially with the strong partnership he has formed with his halfback Will Genia.

I sense the All Blacks won't mind that too much.

And I'm sure they will be more than comfortable with their playmaker in the ice-cool Carter.

Ad Feedback

Carter is a proven force at all levels. He has a consistency about his allround game, particularly at test level, that Cooper can only dream of.

Carter mightn't have quite the running game of Cooper these days and Cooper's slight of hand passing is impressive. But overall Carter's distribution is rock solid. He knows when something "is on" around him and with the outside talent Carter works with, he's more than content to let them express themselves.

But Carter cleans up in the kicking stakes - both in field kicking and shots at goal.

Carter also has a calmness that gives confidence to those around him. For all his individual brilliance, Carter plays an inclusive game.

Is it hard to weigh up the games of Carter and Cooper against each other?

It shouldn't be too difficult for New Zealand rugby fans.

Think back to the continual debate around Andrew Mehrtens v Carlos Spencer.

Who will be remembered more fondly between those two contrasting characters?

Your answer to that will certainly colour your thinking on the Carter-Cooper puzzler.

If a game was hanging in the balance, I'd go with Mehrtens ahead of Spencer. Which means I'm more than comfortable in the Carter camp right now.

- Fairfax Media


Special offers
Opinion poll

What would you rate as a fair price for a mediocre seat at the Rugby World Cup final next year?










Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content