A song and dance about something

BY MARC HINTON
Last updated 12:58 23/06/2009
Opinion poll

Do you think the All Blacks should sing the national anthem with the same enthusiasm that they perform the haka?

I sure do

No, it's not important

Vote Result

Relevant offers

Our Experts

Fox's cunning and Foster's flair good for All Blacks Hansen has much to prove as All Blacks coach Steve Hansen must now show likeable side Too early for Sir Richie, what about Sir Jock? Pressure on Hansen to keep All Blacks on top Crusaders pay for Zac Guildford's misconduct All Blacks assistant coaches may end up foes What part did All Blacks win play in election? Franchise idea super silly or Tew brilliance? Get on board the Twickenham guessing game

OPINION: The All Blacks are a disgrace. And, no, I’m not talking about their performances in the just-completed two-test series against France. That I can forgive.

I'm referring, of course, to their continued reluctance to sing their country’s national anthem before a test match. Something has to be done about this – and quick – before what's left of our reputation is in complete tatters.

It's not enough that visiting international rugby teams suffer indignities like having bottles hurled at them as they salute their fans in the stands and being assaulted in our streets as they make their way back to their hotels.

But now when they glance across prior to belting out their own anthems with trademark gusto, pride and enthusiasm, they are confronted with a bunch of stony-faced All Blacks, their lips pursed tighter than a bank's coffers and their eyes all glazed over, as the words of God Defend New Zealand ring out around the stands, but not in centre-pitch.

What must they make of it? A group of proud young men about to represent their country on the biggest stage, and they're incapable even of singing the one true symbol of their nationhood. It is called an anthem for a reason, after all. You're supposed to let rip, regardless of whether you think a high note is the warm feeling you get after you score a try.

But not our lads. When it comes anthem time they look like they do when they walk into their once-a-week media session. As though they'd rather be somewhere else.

OK, there are the odd exceptions. One or two players actually sing along, and a couple of others can be seen mumbling something under their breaths, though for all we know they could just be repeating their coaches' last-minute instructions.

But for the most part there is rigid disinterest in the verses of their country's song.

This behaviour has been going on for some time now. As long as I've been covering the All Blacks, which dates back to before the start of the professional era.

And it disturbs me. Never more so than now.

The eyes of the world are on us, whether we like it or not. We're little more than two years away from hosting the Rugby World Cup, which has grown so big and so driven by the commercial imperative that in many ways it represents a potential last chance for one of the ''smaller'' nations to ever host the event.

Granted, things like ground security, player welfare in the streets and even the prevention of livestock being carried into stadiums might seem like greater concerns than a mere national anthem. But as the wise man once said, image is everything.

Ad Feedback

And right now the image of the All Black as a proud Kiwi is for me in tatters.

What message does it send out to the people who have shelled out serious bucks just to freeze their butts off in the stands on a mid-winter's night and watch what has been — thus far anyway — some pretty ordinary fare on the rugby front?

What message does it send to the thousands upon thousands of fans who hand over their Pay TV subscriptions each month just for the right to witness the feats of these pampered professionals?

More importantly, what message does it send to the hundreds of thousands of kids who worship these young men as shining gods in their world?

Not a great one, that's what. That their country's anthem doesn’t mean anything to them. That they're professional rugby players and they don’t have to feel proud Kiwis.

Granted, that may be a misconception. But more and more it's one the people I speak to are drawing as they watch these fellows 'dis their national anthem.

I call on Graham Henry to do something about it.

I know he'll say it's not his place to interfere here and that what a player does before a game while the formalities are playing out is their business. So long as the individual is ready to play, and all that jazz.

I say bollocks to that. I say it is Henry's business. He's the head of this organisation. The man his players listen to.

And I reckon he should tell them from this week on that it’s compulsory to belt out the anthem before a test. No sing — no play.

Extreme? Yes. Necessary? Maybe.

I just don't buy the excuses that are inanely trotted out. "It's how I like to prepare for the game." "I'm singing it deep inside." "I like to soak up the atmosphere."

Just sing the god-defending anthem, people!

I'm serious... If it's good enough for them to get so excited, and so organised, about a haka that is only a  symbol of their country's heritage, then they should also be expected to produce similar unity and commitment at anthem time.

I know. No sing — no haka. That would really fix it.

And Henry has the power to solve this in one memo. He tells his players what to do just about every minute of their waking day while they're with the All Blacks. He tells them when they need to be tucked up in bed by, the things they should be eating and, often, what they should be saying.

Why not just add singing the anthem to that list. It would certainly make a lot of ordinary Kiwis — folk who still believe the All Blacks are a team not a brand — a heck of a lot happier.

Before the All Blacks play every test match there is a song, then a dance. For me they take only the latter seriously. It’s time to fix that.

Believe me this is not a song and a dance about nothing either.

* What do you think? Should the All Blacks have to sing the national anthem. Post your comments below.

- © Fairfax NZ News

560 comments
dj   #560   08:34 am Jun 24 2009

No wonder these guys are going over seas with suporters like this.

sandy   #559   06:33 am Jun 24 2009

I am always embarrased when I watch the All Blacks who are supposed to sing their national anthem,when you watch other rugby teams singing their anthem they do it with pride,and so should the All Blacks.And I do not go along with Henry saying it is not his job to make them sing,has he no pride either.Even if they cannot sing,just mouth the words to look as though they are singing,or do they not know the words.Get on with it A/Bs.

Darren   #558   06:21 am Jun 24 2009

I agree totally, I think it's pretty poor that they don't go to any effort to learn the words - stand up, be counted and be PROUD to be a New Zealander!

Justin   #557   04:21 am Jun 24 2009

Do you actually get paid for writing this?....You really need to get a life mate....this article is beyond ridiclous. What's your next story? How you don't like the coach's haircut.

Jonathan Gullery   #556   02:53 am Jun 24 2009

What country are they from? What country do they live in? What country do they represent? Its called the national anthem because its still the NATIONal anthem. So belt it out like there's no tomorrow and stop being a bunch of sissies, worried about whether it offends your sensitivities or not!

dave+   #555   02:42 am Jun 24 2009

It is embarrasssing watching the French or Welsh in full voice and passionate then watch the uptight, tight-lipped ABs and the NZ crowd too for that matter. Actually NZ need to enjoy the game more with some noise / cheering and singing and then they might not resort to idiotic, immature behaviour to have "fun", before and after the game. Mind you a new anthem would help too.

nick   #554   02:24 am Jun 24 2009

I'm more worried about them playing good rugby!

justin   #553   02:05 am Jun 24 2009

As an expat watching the all blacks through the anthem is is little to get excited about,about time these blokes got a kick up the back side and sing with the same passion as the haka

Andy   #552   12:31 am Jun 24 2009

While I agree the AB's need to sing it. I think it partially comes down to the fact our national anthem sounds weak, pathetic, and doesn't demand 'authority' and pride from those singing it. It just sounds like a 're-mixed' version of something that somebody wrote that no body ever heard of.

Brian   #551   12:08 am Jun 24 2009

Perhaps if we had a true national anthem that we all felt proud to sing there would be no need for such an article


Show 501-550 of 560 comments
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content