Cease paying the Wallabies for losing

BY GREG GROWDEN
Last updated 09:51 23/11/2009
Matt Giteau reacts after missing his last minute conversion against Scotland.
Reuters
AUSSIE ANGUISH: Matt Giteau reacts after missing his last minute conversion against Scotland.

Relevant offers

Our Experts

South African whinges will get them nowhere Super franchises in battle for hearts and minds Relaxed West Coast vibe contributes to fun Fox's cunning and Foster's flair good for All Blacks Hansen has much to prove as All Blacks coach Steve Hansen must now show likeable side Too early for Sir Richie, what about Sir Jock? Pressure on Hansen to keep All Blacks on top Crusaders pay for Zac Guildford's misconduct All Blacks assistant coaches may end up foes

OPINION: The Wallabies are not just the laughing stock of Australian sport. They are also the laughing stock of the international rugby world after suffering their worst loss in decades. This defeat was not as bad as being beaten by Tonga in 1973 but it's not far off.

To think that just over a week ago this group of players seriously thought they were going to emulate the feats of the 1984 Wallabies by completing a grand slam. More like a grand sham after they allowed a second-rate rugby team, which had no imagination and did little more than tackle for 80 minutes, to beat them for the first time in 27 years and 17 encounters.

Depressing as it may be when the Wallabies get belted by New Zealand and South Africa, at least their opponents are usually formidable. When the Wallabies give up, as they did in Wellington, it is hard for the fans to cop.

But getting beaten by Scotland? That is unforgivable. The Scots have done nothing in the Six Nations for ages and are rightfully ranked a lowly ninth in the IRB world rankings. They are little more than a bunch of scrappers who haven't a clue about how to score a try against a good team.

In the end, it was probably for the better that Australia did not emulate the grand slam feats of the 1984 Wallabies, because this crop is vastly inferior to that mighty side. And to think that magical bunch did it all for nothing and this mob of perennial losers are among Australian football's highest-paid players?

It begs the question of whether the Australian Rugby Union, which has an annual player salary bill of $27 million, is getting value for money? Hardly. The Wallabies struggle to score tries. They struggle to kick goals. They struggle to win games. What do they do? Not much really - the bulk of these players have won absolutely nothing of note in their international careers.

Most disconcerting is that Australia's highest-paid player and chief playmaker, Matt Giteau, had the chance to establish himself as the king dog on Saturday. He fell way short of the mark. He failed to provide midfield leadership, he kicked abominably at goal and took poor options. His ability to handle pressure must be seriously questioned.

Don't forget this is the same side that demanded to be paid for a pre-tour intra-squad trial match; the same bunch who had their noses out of joint when this column recommended that their pay structure be changed, suggesting a bonus scheme that rewarded them for victories and docked their wages for losses.

Ad Feedback

And what else can coach Robbie Deans do? He's tried everything. He's given so many players so many chances and they continue to waste their opportunities. Not even Vince Lombardi could get this mob up.

Undoubtedly, the calls will be made for Deans to move on. But, seriously, who is out there to replace him? No one. As with the players, the Australian coaching cupboard is near bare. The problem is not with the head coach, it is with the players.

Their skill level is uninspiring. They cannot back up. They have a losing mentality. They are lazy. And deep down they know they can get away with unacceptable performances, because player depth is so poor.

Forget feeling sorry for the players. They get paid big money. The quicker the ARU brings in a win-loss salary system for the Wallabies the better. Then, and only then, will the magnitude of Saturday's loss at Murrayfield really hit home to the players.

- © Fairfax NZ News

22 comments
Post a comment
Nomadnz   #22   10:50 pm Nov 24 2009

Has it crossed anyones mind that the Wallbies threw the match and are matching even more dollars at the bookies?

Sioto   #21   03:43 pm Nov 24 2009

The Wallabies does not have mentality and the "die for" attitude the AB's have. That's all I can say for this so called Wallabies

ruggerworld   #20   03:40 pm Nov 24 2009

Re Paul 18#

Agree that rugby in Australia is struggling and is probably 4th of the winter codes, to be fair howver it has always been either 3rd or 4th given the dominance of AFL and the NRL in NSW/QLD. Rugby not being able to keep its players is nothing new as the best were poached by league since 1907 and they shouldnt buy league players anyway but invest at grassroots. One thing about Aussie rugby is that its been battered and bought out by league in Aussie for 100 years but somehow continues to punch above its weight.

vaughan   #19   01:56 pm Nov 24 2009

Frank you must lead a very boring life,when thats the only comment you can make,i take it you are from the island where they allways choke at grand final time,or there cabinet is that full of dust as its so long since they had a trophy,(great to see southland have the(SHEILD)and canterbury are provincial champs once again,south island dominance.

Paul   #18   01:48 pm Nov 24 2009

Rugby is dying in Australia. The Wallabies performances are just the end result of a sick and terminal system. It is losing ground (and athletes) to all other winter codes and now runs a distant fourth to AFL, league and soccer. Once the sponsorship and TV revenues dry up in an ever more competitive market the ARU will no longer have the where with all to attract players like Tiquiri to the game or keep young players in the code. The sad thing is most Aussies couldn't care less.

Observer   #17   10:58 am Nov 24 2009

Is this a case of the influential players wanting to get the coach dropped perhaps...? Dean's has made some unpopular decisions (for the players) and there had already been talk of a rift between Dean's Giteau and Mortlock before this tour. Giteau in particular has played this angle before (with Mitchell in Perth), so is it outside the realms of possibilty that it's going on again? Perhaps that's a long bow to take, but something sure is seroiusly amiss in "Team Wallaby"....(That's John O'Neills pet name for them, not mine....)

evan   #16   10:53 am Nov 24 2009

the problem is with the players....a perfect example being when Robbie tried to set up a trial match and the players demanded to be paid to play in the trial. No right minded kiwi would ever dream of asking to be paid to trial for the ABs, shows how blaise the Aussies are about the Wallabie jumper and Deans has said as much following a few of their losses At this level of rugby...and even super14 for that ,matter players must be absolutely, 100% committed to the team and their team mates....and the level of commitment is never more apparent than the last 20mins of a tough physical rugby match...this is where the Aussies are coming up short

Crusher Wilson   #15   10:27 am Nov 24 2009

Has robby got the balls to drop Giteau for the next match ? I doubt it.

Richard   #14   09:45 am Nov 24 2009

Jordan #12 I can see your point but it is not entirely the players fault. It is the responsibility of the coach to motivate the players and he is not doing that for whatever reason. Despite what people think of Henry and Co (I haven't agreed with all their selections) they have created an environment where there is pressure from the fringe players on the main team for starting spots and this is what should be happening in Aus. Granted we have more depth then Aus but you can't tell me that with 4 Super teams they can't somehow create the same sort of pressure.

blogo   #13   08:47 am Nov 24 2009

careful, we may see after this weekends french match that the problem is not with the australian team, it's with the teams in europe making considerable progress relative to south african, and yes, new zealand.......


Show 1-12 of 22 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content