READER REPORT:

McCaw book marred by F bombs

JOHN YOUNG
Last updated 05:00 23/12/2012
Richie McCaw book
THE OPEN SIDE: All Black captain Richie McCaws biography is a disappointment, says reader John Young.

Related Links

Is McCaw really the greatest? McCaw greatest exponent of the game Richie McCaw: Captain Fantastic Richie McCaw: What makes a great leader? Is McCaw really the greatest? Six reasons why

Relevant offers

Stuff Nation

Wine was my friend, or so I thought Competitive couple ready for challenge Weather photo of the week: Sept 18, 2014 Ditch company tax to incentivise exports Jimmy Cowan is not the way to go for Tasman Final leaders' debate: top five comments Beauty while you were sleeping Minimum wage is not the answer Jimmy Cowan brings 'control factor' to Blues They don't get badder than Walken

Richie McCaw is a great All Black and always carries himself with dignity on and off the field, but his recent biography was a great disappointment.

The sprinklings of the F-bomb and blasphemy were a big let down.

As a former New Zealand primary school principal I was deeply disappointed and saw no need for it. If this language is in the All Black captain's biography does that mean it is now acceptable on the primary school playground?

Did the publishers, Greg McGee and McCaw himself not realise how young the readership is for a book like this? Would children from nine years and older want to read it? Yes. Would I stock it in a school library? Sadly, no.

It seems ironic that I write this when on the same website there is a story about a protester prosecuted for using obscene language in Auckland. I feel the language in McCaw's book is a bigger issue and made teachers' and parents' jobs harder.


View all contributions
Ad Feedback

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Which reader's plan would you support?

Arturo Pelayo - Community uses for vacant lots

Nick Teulon - Incentives to swap cars for bikes

Bruce Roberts - Educational support for Pasifika children

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content