READER REPORT:

Richie McCaw? I'm not a fan

BRETT STEP
Last updated 05:00 28/12/2012
mccaw carter
WHO'S THE BEST?: Dan Carter and Richie McCaw.

Related Links

Is McCaw really the greatest? Richie McCaw: Captain Fantastic Richie McCaw: What makes a great leader? Is McCaw really the greatest? Six reasons why Richie McCaw: How does he stack up?

Relevant offers

Stuff Nation

Breast was best, in the end A barking mad delight Dominance and demonic laugh are Jolie perfect Fan predictions: Premier League third round Molly loved to woof it down Exemptions undermining the All Blacks jersey Top five reader comments of the day No snake-oil quick fix can cure my pain Stop ignoring the Arts for uni funding Forget Buck, bring back Sonny Bill Williams

Going by win/loss ratio, Richie McCaw is one of the best rugby players ever, however he achieved this simply by playing a huge number of games and playing them as captain.

He has had many so-called achievements in his career - he captained a winning Rugby World Cup team, captained the All Blacks on an unbeaten run, captained the All Blacks when they dominated the Tri-Nations and also captained a provincial side that dominated rugby. I, personally, am not a fan., but I respect McCaw as you don't often get a player that can influence rugby so much with his style of play.

For me the only other player that is as great as McCaw is Dan Carter.

McCaw has the edge from a captain's perspective, but Carter will always be the best number 10 in the world. I have only seen him fail on a few occasions.  The only thing lacking from his artillery is to use the drop goal more effectively.


View all contributions
Ad Feedback

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should SBW have been given an exemption?

Yes

No

Don't care

Vote Result

Related story: (See story)

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content