READER REPORT:

Love The Beatles, not The Stones

JANELLE KENNEDY
Last updated 05:00 10/02/2013
Beatles

FLASHBACK: The Beatles played at St George Hotel in 1964 in Wellington.

Related Links

The album I can't live without: Late Registration Album I couldn't live without: Of a Simple Man Album I couldn't live without: Disintegration The album I can't live without: Stay with The Hollies Album I couldn't live without: Looking On Album I couldn't live without: Ziggy Stardust Album I can't live without: Heaven Up Here Album I can't live without: Apocalyptica's Reflections Album I could live without: Automatic for the People I'm I couldn't live without: Drifting off to simpler times Album I couldn't live without: Union The album I couldn't live without: Hunky Dory Album I couldn't live without: Exile on Main St Album I couldn't live without: Take in The Sun Album I couldn't live without: Dangerous The album I couldn't live without: Live at Fillmore East Album I couldn't live without: We Are Not Alone Album I couldn't live without: Available Light Album I couldn't live without: Forever Changes The album I couldn't live without: The Fragile Album I couldn't live without: Surrender The album I can't live without: The River Album I couldn't live without: Ride the Lightening Album I couldn't live without: American Idiot Album I can't live without: David Bowie Album I can't live without: OK Computer Album I can't live without: Physical Graffiti Album I couldn't live without: Deep Purple Album I can't live without: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road Album I can't live without: AK-79 Album I can't live without: Talk Talk Talk Album I can't live without: Machine Head Album I can't live without: Dave Matthews Band Album I can't live without: A Night at the Opera Album I can't live without: Psychedelic rock Album I can't live without: Iron Maiden Album I can't live without: Live from Mars

Relevant offers

Stuff Nation

All Blacks winners, but where to now? Bright future for Banda Aceh post tsunami Dirty Politics fallout 'ignoring' privacy laws Foraging for Fiordland fungi What do I fear? Just the universe Cats and dogs are different but equal Things that go bump in the night Reader photos: Pretty little things Top five reader comments of the day Taking your body to the extreme

What kind of music do you like? It's a question I always struggle to answer, because I have a lot of music, and I guess the easy answer is that it starts with The Beatles.

I'm not a fanatic, at about the time I was forming my musical tastes back in the 1970s The Beatles had already broken up, so my experience was already second-hand. I can remember hanging ABBA and Bee Gees posters on the bedroom wall, not so much the Fab Four, and I never did get in to the solo output of Paul, John, George and Ringo.

However, I do have all the Beatles' albums and I think they have provided the basis of the way my musical tastes have been shaped - an appreciation for great self-composed pop songs, exhilarating harmonies, the quirky arrangements in their later years and most of all, the sheer variety of musical forms that encompassed their career. It's led me to embrace all sorts of music going back to Tin Pan Alley to the 'unpopular' pop and indie music I enjoy today.

But one group that has not entered my music collection is The Rolling Stones.

I know all the singles, but actually listening to a record by them? Nope, no interest. This has possibly influenced the lack of bluesy, guitar based rock in my music library, though not perhaps some of the other big blanks there (no Bob Dylan or even Michael Jackson).

What I wonder is whether liking the Beatles and not the Rolling Stones (or vice versa) makes a significant difference to the make up of a music collection and someone's general appreciation of music?

Reflecting on some of my favourite albums from last year, such as Ryan Adams, and The Civil Wars, it would also appear that my age now plays a factor in the type of music I favour, and what used to be music to play on Sunday mornings has become all-week music.

Ad Feedback

So, will picking my way through the Rolling Stones back catalogue round my music collection out? Or should I hold out for a little bit longer? After all, unlike The Beatles, The Rolling Stones are still recording. Maybe they can surprise me with something to like yet?


View all contributions

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

What's your biggest fear?

The dark

Creepy crawlies

Sharks

Heights

Snakes

Death

Birds

Water

Something else

Flying

I have no fear

Vote Result

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content