READER REPORT:

Why Kyle Lockwood's New Zealand flag doesn't work

ANDREW CLARK
Last updated 09:32 14/03/2016
DAVID WHITE/FAIRFAX NZ

Kyle Lockwood with his successful flag design.

New Zealand flag: which way are you going?

Share your stories, photos and videos.

Related Links

Vote for positive reasons in NZ flag referendum Us overseas Kiwis want our say on flag, too Marlborough pupils hold their own flag referendum New Zealand sailors to use alternative - and current - flag in testing for Rio Olympics Opinions split on flag change in the South Waikato Anger has little to do with changing flags, but rather the prime minister John Key gives away the Silver Fern flag off his suit lapel NZ First calls for Hindi flag votes to be nullified, after translation differs Mailbox thieves stealing flag voting papers Hugh Jackman says it's time to get rid of the Union Jack on our flag Prime Minister John Key draped in current flag at NZ Open

Relevant offers

Share your news and views

The job market is cruel to graduates The real cost of curtailing free speech Abortion: A tragic response to lack of choice Want equality? Curtail free speech I'm 18 - stop asking me if I want kids My anxiety is called Walter Too many fish in the sea: Why dating apps have ruined dating Poor team unity undoing the Wellington Phoenix Breaking free from my Facebook addiction Christchurch's cathedral conundrum continues

Driving down the Kapiti Coast highway, I saw the Kyle Lockwood flag flying on a flagpole outside a café. The wind was blowing in a westerly direction and so the view was of the reverse side of the flag, and it didn't look right.

This view has, as it has been pointed out before, the fern rising from the bottom right to the left. This is an opposing orientation of the traditional image of the Silver Fern used as an emblem for New Zealand.

Unlike Canada's maple leaf, the image of the Silver Fern is asymmetrical, not balanced, and, therefore, has difficulty in providing the required symbolism in each of the different directions.

When you look at other Nations' emblems, most of them are symmetrical, the Scottish Thistle, Welsh Feathers and Japan's Cherry Blossom. Also, the Scottish Thistle and Welsh Feathers are on their soldiers' war graves and yet those emblems are not used on the country's national flag.

READ MORE: 
40 possible alternatives to our current flag
The NZ flag should be more than a brand
Flag debate a cultural minefield

In fact, none of the Commonwealth's gravestones use their country's flag, but they are buried under their service emblem or the emblem of their country.

As the image of the Lockwood flag has been marketed in the standard orientation of a flag, flying left to right, we have forgotten about the other orientations that a flag might be subjected to.

One of the most common orientations is the flag pole projecting out at an angle and the flag flying at a downward angle. This orientation will also put the Silver Fern in a downward angle, making the fern look as if it is beginning to wilt.

Worse still, if the flag is hung vertically downwards, the orientation of the Silver Fern on the Lockwood flag would simply look limp and broken. Not the sort of thing that would invoke pride in a nation.

Ad Feedback

Looking at the Lockwood flag in the four different orientations, only one out of the four properly represents the Silver Fern, the other three orientations let it down. It looks great on paper but fails in reality.

The Silver Fern is a bold emblem for New Zealand, but the time when it supposed to invoke national pride, the use of our country's flag, I'm sorry to say, it simply doesn't work.

Comments on this article are now closed.


View all contributions

Comments

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content