Labour yet to have its Kodak moment

From the Left

CHRIS TROTTER
Last updated 07:40 27/01/2012

Relevant offers

OPINION: Kodachrome's gifts, according to Paul Simon's 1973 hit single, were the "night's bright colours", the "greens of summer" and a magical ability to make all the world "a sunny day". The Eastman-Kodak corporation's eponymous product, for which Simon's snappy little ditty acted as a world-wide advertisement, was indisputably one of the hottest technological properties of its day.

Sad to learn, then, that in January 2012, America's colour- film colossus is finally closing its doors. The night's bright colours and the greens of summer no longer require a Nikon camera loaded with 36 of Eastman-Kodak's exposures.

Unlike the songwriter, the world's great pioneer of popular photography failed to read "the writing on the wall". It wasn't Mamma, but the instant images of the new digital technology that took Rhymin' Simon's Kodachrome away.

My friend, Barry Thomas, reckons the manufacturers of Kodachrome and the New Zealand Labour Party have a lot in common. Both were once at the cutting edge. Both had something to sell which masses of people were happy to buy. And both, by failing to keep pace with a rapidly changing world, have seen the power of their "brand" dwindle and fade.

Eastman-Kodak believed it was in the business of manufacturing photographic film, when it was actually in the business of preserving ordinary people's memories.

When film was no longer required to capture those special moments, the makers of Kodachrome should have been there with the digital technology that was fast replacing the photographic process. Nikon, Nokia, Samsung and Apple made the transition. Eastman-Kodak didn't.

The Labour Party believes that it's in the business of attracting electoral support. But the vote a person casts for a political party is only the last in a long series of decisions and commitments he or she has already made to its "brand".

When Paul Simon considered Kodachrome, what was in his mind? A tube of tightly-rolled, unexposed film in a chrome yellow box? No. What he saw were the "night's bright colours" and the "greens of summer". When a voter thinks about Labour his or her mind should be flooded with similar positive images.

It was once. Mention Labour to the voters of the 1930s and 40s and the image of Bob Semple driving a bulldozer over the picks and shovels of the hated work schemes would spring to mind. Or a row of brand new state houses gleaming in the summer sun. Or smiling children clutching their bottles of state-provided milk. They'd recall pictures of hydro-electric dams, and the friendly faces of Labour's leaders opening yet another school, hospital or factory.

Ad Feedback

Back then Labour understood that its core business was offering New Zealanders reassurance, security and an optimistic vision of the future. Once people were persuaded that these were the things Labour stood for, collecting their votes became a mere formality.

But speak the word Labour to a voter in 2012 and what - if any - images spring to mind? Architectural drawings of the new housing estates Labour is committed to building? No. The Labour leader arguing about how best to put an end to inequality with Occupy protesters? Hardly. Standing in solidarity with the Maritime Unions? Perish the thought! Unveiling a graph indicating how quickly Labour's new tax policy will reduce the share of New Zealand's income currently claimed by its wealthiest one per cent. Never. Announcing Labour's "Grow New Zealand" scheme for putting unemployed Kiwis to work. Nope.

Mention Labour in 2012 and most New Zealanders will struggle to conjure-up any images at all, apart from a succession of vaguely recognisable faces and a sorry string of embarrassing headlines.

The Labour Party Opposition should be in the business of displaying courage, thinking the unthinkable, searching for the root causes of the nation's problems and coming up with solutions that require the voters to discard their prejudices, step away from past failures, and take the risk of committing themselves to something new.

A successful Opposition doesn't waste time attacking the Government, it devotes itself to enlisting the electorate in a great adventure.

If a vote for Labour is anything less than a decision to join that great adventure then the party will share the fate of Eastman- Kodak.

It neglected its core business: preserving people's memories. Labour's core business, in 2012, must be stimulating New Zealanders' imagination.

Using digital, colour, and, when necessary, black-and-white.

- © Fairfax NZ News

4 comments
Post a comment
Dale Farkas   #4   03:31 am Jan 31 2012

Dear Mr. Trotter,

You write eloquently and, coming from the United States, I have no sense of your Labour Party, its history or its politics. Therefore, I have the good sense not to write about Labour. If I did I would certainly do some accurate research before standing on a soapbox and delivering a diatribe.

You obviously have no understanding of Kodak or the bankruptcy laws in the United States. Yet, you pretended to be an expert. You spouted completely inaccurate facts. That's not journalism. It's self-serving gibberish.

Here are the facts about Kodak, an honorable company you mindlessly defamed:

1) Kodak is not closing its doors! When a company declares a Chapter 11 bankruptcy in the United States is does not go out of business. It simply receives special legal protection from its creditors and pensioners until the company can right its economic course and become a healthy business entity again. This is a short term situation usually lasting one to three years. Many of our largest U.S. companies have gone this course and come through it successfully.

2) Kodak's management did recognize digital photography and took many steps to deal with it. They also understood their role in serving their customers. What happened was that the drastic change to digital was a bit like a tsunami or a perfect storm. Even the best preparations didn't prevent a drastic outcome.

3) Kodak still has billions of dollars in yearly sales and is fully operational in supplying its customers.

4) KEX (Kodak Express) stores in your country are independently owned and still open. Your article hurt them badly.

Suggestion: Please be ethical enough to print a clarification of your erroneous facts.

Dale Farkas, Dale Laboratori

Lance   #3   11:10 pm Jan 30 2012

It's just plain shameful that it got published with such a massive inaccuracy at the outset, where did the writer learn that Kodak was closing its doors? A horrendous error in research that burns the rest of the piece.

Pat the Rat   #2   11:26 pm Jan 29 2012

This columnist sums up New Zealand’s current political environment very well. Lack of leadership on both sides of the House is a malaise of which under – the – carpet episodes such as the Pike River explosion, the Rena grounding, the slow progress of rebuilding Christchurch, and a number of other episodes are merely symptomatic.

One doesn’t have to go too far back to see political leaders who were just that – they had leadership qualities - and vision. Keith Holyoake, Norman Kirk, Rob Muldoon, Jim Bolger, Jenny Shipley, Helen Clark. Labour today has no vision of the future, and, apart from asset sales, neither has National.

Whoever won the Treasury Benches in 2008 was going to be in for a tough time and if it wasn’t for Michael Cullen leaving some money in the kitty, National would have had a really hard time of it. John Key was returned to power last year under a mantra of building a brighter future, and given these economic times, he is going to have to pull something pretty good out of the bag in order to achieve this if he doesn’t want to reach his use by date prematurely.

stuart munro   #1   03:27 am Jan 28 2012

Labour's running prototype would something like selling Crafar farms to multiracial gay migrants. From England.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

A 'weatherbomb' is about to hit Taranaki. What will you be doing as you hunker down this weekend?

Board games and DVDs

To the mall for retail therapy

We'll be outside, whatever the weather

Vote Result

Related story: Weather bomb forecast widened

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

TDN dailynews long2

Follow the Taranaki Daily News on Twitter

Get Taranaki's frequent news and sport updates

Choose an iconic Taranaki photo as wallpaper for your computer

Computer wallpaper

Choose an iconic Taranaki photo as wallpaper for your computer