Little Englanders forcing Cameron's hand

GWYNNE DYER
Last updated 07:42 31/01/2013

Relevant offers

OPINION: The real problem is continental drift: Brussels, the capital of the European Union (EU), is getting further and further away from England, or at least that is British Prime Minister David Cameron's line.

Cameron made his long-awaited speech promising a referendum on continued British membership in the EU on January 23, and he placed the blame squarely on plate tectonics.

"People are increasingly frustrated that decisions taken further and further away from them mean their living standards are slashed through enforced austerity or their taxes are used to bail out governments on the other side of the continent," he said.

The frustrated people in question are the English, of course. Hostility to the EU is mainly an English thing, but that matters a lot in the United Kingdom, 55 million of whose 65 million people live in England.

The Scottish nationalists seeking separation from England in their own referendum take the opposite tack. They have promised the Scottish electorate that leaving the UK will not mean leaving the EU, although, in fact, Scotland would probably have to reapply for membership. But England is different.

The Little Englander glories in the notion of England being unencumbered by foreign ties and commitments.

It's the kind of nationalism that Americans call isolationism, and the phrase is now used to describe strongly nationalist, even xenophobic people on the Right of English politics.

Those people, always present in significant numbers within Cameron's Conservative Party, have now won the internal party debate.

Every Conservative leader has had to deal with these people.

They always managed to contain them in the past, because the EU is Britain's biggest trading partner, and it is obviously in Britain's interests to belong to the organisation that makes the rules for Europe's single market.

What has changed is that the long recession and relatively high immigration of recent years have increased the popularity of the extreme Right in England.

This doesn't mean that populist demagogues and neo-fascists are about to win power in Britain. Far from it: they would be lucky to get 10 per cent of the vote. But it does mean that the Conservatives are losing their more Right-wing supporters to the anti-EU, anti- immigration United Kingdom Independence Party.

The UK Independence Party could never win an election in Britain, but it could easily steal enough votes from the Conservatives to make them lose the next election.

So there has been mounting panic in the Conservative Party, and not just among its instinctively anti-EU members.

Ad Feedback

Cameron's promise of a referendum on EU membership is first and foremost an attempt to steal the UK Independence Party's thunder and win back the defecting Conservative voters.

He doesn't really want to leave the EU, but he does want to win the election that is due in 2015.

His reluctance to be the man who took Britain out of the EU was evident in the way he hedged his referendum promise.

The referendum will not take place until after the next election, and only if the Conservatives win enough seats in 2015 to form a government on their own. (Their current coalition partner, the Liberal Democratic Party, opposes the whole idea.)

Cameron says he will spend the next two years renegotiating the terms of Britain's EU membership, to "repatriate" many powers from Brussels to London, and make various changes in the way the EU is run. Then, if he is satisfied with the outcome, he will support EU membership in the election and the subsequent referendum, to be held by 2017.

But he had no satisfactory answers to the hard questions that followed his speech:

What if the 26 other EU members choose not to waste months in talks on changing Britain's relationship with the EU?

What if they do negotiate, but refuse to tie themselves up in knots just to ease Cameron's domestic political problems?

Will he support continued EU membership in the promised referendum if he doesn't have a "new deal" to offer voters?

Much could be done to improve the accountability and efficiency of the EU, but it is not helpful to open negotiations with 26 other governments by standing at the exit door and threatening to leave if you do not get your way.

The time may well come when Cameron will have to answer these questions, and he probably does not know himself which way he will jump. So for the next four years, all those foreign companies that have been using Britain as a convenient, English-speaking centre to produce goods and services for the European market will be rethinking their investment strategies.

If it is possible that Britain could leave the EU by 2017, is it really the right place for them to put their money?

It will probably be a long, dry season for the British economy.

How did an allegedly grown-up country talk itself into this position? It is an attitude that was summed up in an apocryphal English newspaper headline of the 1930s: "Fog in [the English] Channel; continent cut off."

Gwynne Dyer is an independent journalist whose articles are published in 45 countries.

- Taranaki Daily News

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Which of these organisations do you like better?

Fish & Game

Federated Farmers

Forest & Bird

Vote Result

Related story: Fish & Game are top of my popularity poll

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

TDN rachel stewart

Riding Shotgun

with Rachel Stewart

Matt Rilkoff's perspective of comtempory life

The Rilkoff Files

Matt Rilkoff's perspective of contemporary life

tdn kathryn collumn

Under the Sky Tower

With Kathryn Calvert

Gordon Burnside

Gordon Burnside

The self-confessed bard of Brixton, offers views on life, politics and Akubra hats.

TDN The Weekend

The Weekend

with Glenn McLean