Controversial internet file-sharing law passed

Last updated 11:55 14/04/2011
Parliament TV

Jonathan Young talks about Skynet.

Opinion poll

Rate new laws which will see people who break copyright online risk a 6 month suspension of their internet accounts:

Spot on

Too harsh

Too weak

Unworkable

Vote Result

Relevant offers

Digital living

YouTube enlists Hollywood to attract youth Fry puts focus on data limits Tech-savvy police trial iPhones Where private chats linger on 'Find my phone' app thwarts would-be thieves Man sues Twitter over hate blog Microsoft's man who monitors privacy Email hacking managed well, says Key App turns iPhone into adult toy Internet in Iran severely disrupted as elections loom

A bill that could see internet users have their access cut off if they repeatedly share copyright material has been passed by Parliament.

The Copyright (Infringing File Sharing) Amendment Bill, which aims to stamp out internet piracy, passed by 111 votes to 11 this morning.

It was supported by all parties except the Greens and independent MPs Chris Carter and Hone Harawira.

Fierce protest erupted last night as the Government used urgency to rush the bill through its final stages.

Opponents took to social media sites such as Twitter to revive the 2009 "blackout" protest that brought about the redrafting of the controversial illegal-file-sharing legislation.

The new law would allow copyright owners to ask for a six-month suspension of the internet accounts of those who repeatedly infringe by sharing protected material.

"Online copyright infringement has been damaging for the creative industry, which has experienced significant declines in revenue as file sharing has become more prevalent," said Commerce Minister Simon Power.

"This legislation will discourage illegal file sharing and provide more effective measures to help our creative industries enforce their copyright."

WHAT THE NEW LAW MEANS

* Establishes a 'three strikes' regime to stamp out illegal file-sharing.

* Copyright owners notify Internet Service Providers (ISPs) that someone is downloading material, such as films or video, without paying for it, through file-sharing.

* ISPs send warning notices to those customers telling them they may have infringed copyright.

* After three warnings, if the user does not stop, the copyright owner can take a claim to the Copyright Tribunal.

* The tribunal now has the power in impose a maximum $15,000 penalty on the internet account holder.

* However, after two years, if the new regime is not working - and a large number of people are still illegally downloading, then the Commerce Minister can introduce a tougher regime which could lead to the suspension of accounts.

* This would see the tribunal refer serious cases to the district court, who would have the power to order a six month suspension.

* The regime comes into force on September 1. The law does not apply to cellphone networks until 2013.

ONLINE REACTION

Twitter users stayed up to watch the bill be debated via Parliament TV last night.

MPs were criticised for their lack of understanding on file sharing and internet basics including New Plymouth MP Jonathan Young, who compared the internet to Skynet, the fictional artificial intelligence network from the Terminator movies.

"Oh no, Skynet references in Parliament," tweeted Chris Macr (@macrodubplates).

"WTF is this NZ MP wittering on about ... Internet = Skynet ... oh lordy lord," wrote Mike Riversdale (@MiramarMike). 

Others were disgusted at what they perceived as the Government using urgency to rush the bill through.

"The National Party clearly cannot be trusted: using #eqnz as a smokescreen to push through ideological legislation is evil. SHAME!" said Amanda Peet (@kiwinerd)

Ad Feedback

"Tonight I am disgusted in our government and in both major parties," wrote Keri Henare (@KeriHenare).

Many more used the medium to express their opinions on why they thought the bill was wrong:

Ben Gracewood (@nzben) said:  "Blocking internet because of piracy is like revoking a driver's license due to burglary."

AndHow Web Radio (@andhowfm) wrote: " [It's] Draconian. Where will it end?"

And Andrew McKenzie (@AMcKenzieWriter) wrote: "Entitlement because you are a fan simply doesn't carry. I like chocolate, can I steal as much Cadbury as I like? No."

- By MARTIN KAY and ANDREA VANCE/Stuff

471 comments
Post a comment
The Bull   #471   06:12 pm Feb 10 2012

Shut down the internet, after all it was created for global sharing of information. Now its "sharing to much" information.... I HATE THE UNITED STATES GOVERNMENT. THEY NOW STAND FOR EVERYTHING THE WORLDS DOES NOT NEED.THEY REALLY NEED TO TAKE THERE HEADS OUT THERE BUTS AND BREATH.

John   #470   11:05 am Jan 27 2012

I do believe that the movie "Terminator" was copywrited...strike 1...and here's a talking head, violating the laws he is arguing for. Oh crap, the debate was televised, and than reproduced on the net....strike two, I better shut my computer off, before the Gustapo comes and throws me in the gulag

bob   #469   06:11 pm Oct 07 2011

are we stil aloud to jail break our ipods ?

Saadi   #468   01:31 pm Sep 19 2011

wow no offence but Jonathan Young sounds like a typical hillbilly politician/douche who hasn't really got the faintest idea of what he's on about, not a good image for our country and the rest of New Plymouth. I hope this bites them in the ass one day and the media has field day and they get fined and all the publicity/resignation that goes with. Just for this incredible act of cruelty and denial of self expression through file sharing I'm not voting National. John Key just lost my respect and I actually liked the guy. Doesn't matter anyway, most of the grads in my year are moving overseas this year, and the country will be left with a load of clueless douches like JY, is that what the govt wants? to be a backward nation??

f*ck john key   #467   12:31 am Sep 04 2011

i say we shoot them in the foot with there own game, someone should make some song or something and then as a copyright holder of said song simply find out and accuse all those in parliament including john key of breaching copyright and download your material then lolz as they somehow try and prove they didnt

ahh nahh   #466   10:59 am Sep 02 2011

Thats so silly.. there aint no way they gonna be able to stop it..

Its not like wre getting the content for free we have to pay for the internet it uses to download..

Plus if you realy wanted to download whats stopping u from going to wifi hot spots or buying a $5 sim card and using there data plans then discarding it and getting a new one each time?

Nev   #465   12:36 am Sep 02 2011

Aww come on people how else is the New Zealand government going to get us off the internet.They should just ban the internet all together so no foreign visiters can find out how third world our damn internet feed is.File sharing,thats a laugh it takes me a week to get an audiobook via torrent and I can get one from the library in 5 minutes lol.

daniel   #464   07:29 pm Sep 01 2011

how does this law make any sense at all?!

also...can i still download free software using torrent? or is that illeagil to..

Cory   #463   03:46 pm Sep 01 2011

This is not going to stop people pirating... Trying to control the internet is like trying to control nature. Impossible.

Khryss Roq   #462   12:07 pm Sep 01 2011

WOW im now officially ashamed to have J. Young as my electoral MP. what a douche.

YOU CANNOT STOP FILE SHARING. PERIOD. THE INTERNET WAS CREATED AS A MEANS OF FREELY SHARING KNOWLEDGE AND INFORMATION.

REPRIMANDING ME FOR FILESHARING IS LIKE 2 WEEKS IN JAIL FOR GIVING MY FRIEND A BOOK I HAVE ALREADY READ.

SHOULD I PAY COPYRIGHT FOR A MOVIE MY FRIEND BOUGHT AT THE WAREHOUSE ($39.99) THAT HE NO LONGER WANTS?

CERTAINLY NOT! THAT FEE HAS ALREADY BEEN PAID.

VIVA LA PIRATEBAY! VIVA LA DEMONOID! VIVA LA FREE WORLD!


Show 412-461 of 471 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content