Tax plan will hit property investment

BY VERNON SMALL
Last updated 11:21 09/02/2010
TAX CHANGES: Mr Key signalled that the changes would be included in the May Budget.
REUTERS
TAX CHANGES: Mr Key signalled that the changes would be included in the May Budget.

Related Links

Voters ready for tax change – and Key's big test Bruce Sheppard blog: Political meddling with property has never worked

Relevant offers

Business

Price hike for network repairs rejected Enable offers more for less Trust's business aid grants top $3.7 million Online presence the priority for many companies Telogis stays put, but needs staff Post-quake luxury-car sales boom Growth plans for city's festivals $400m energy scheme to heat city Couple 'sabotaged' by council reaction Star system to rate quake safety of buildings

John Key will unveil measures aimed at cooling New Zealand's love affair with property investment in a speech today that is expected to outline major tax reforms.


Join Stuff this afternoon for live coverage of John Key's speech from 2pm. Join our conversation with a rolling report of the Prime Minister's key points as he makes them, with comment and analysis from our political editor Tracy Watkins, property management expert and NZ Property Investors Federation vice president Andrew King, business journalist Jenny Keown and Business NZ CEO Phil O'Reilly.


The prime minister signalled yesterday that the changes would be included in the May Budget – and said the Government would be ready to implement them "shortly after that".

He ramped up expectations that the speech marked a step up in the Government's economic programme, saying the tax changes were the best way to boost growth.

Cuts to the top personal rate, from 38 per cent to 33 per cent or lower, are likely to be part of the package, but the Government needs to find revenue from elsewhere to do this. "We will be reasonably specific. I don't think you will come away from the speech wondering what we are saying," Mr Key said.

National has a long-term plan to lower all top tax rates to 30 per cent and Beehive insiders have suggested a rise in GST is on the cards.

Details of the changes were so secret yesterday that they were removed from drafts of Mr Key's statement circulated to ministers' offices. But they are certain to include measures that hit rental property investments.

Mr Key said the tax system had been favouring rental property and it was hypothetically possible for some investors to avoid paying any tax. "There is $200 billion approximately invested in that sector and the Crown lost $150 million last year. So you can expect to see some discussion on that in the speech."

It was wrong that some benefited from social spending without paying tax. "There are hundreds of thousands of Kiwis who are paying for you to drive on the roads, for you to access the health system, for you to have superannuation in your retirement, for you to educate your kids. That's not fair and a lot of those people are low to middle-income New Zealanders so I am just trying to put a bit of balance in the economy."

In his 20-minute speech – and in a detailed statement to accompany it – Mr Key is also likely to signal whether the Government will raise GST to 15 per cent to help shift taxation from businesses and wages to consumption. He could not say "hand on my heart" that support parties ACT and the Maori Party would back his proposals.

Ad Feedback

Other recommendations last year by the Tax Working Group included a low-level land tax and removing the right to claim depreciation on buildings. Property Council chief executive Connal Townsend warned that scrapping this would amount to a 2 per cent increase in business tax.

Mr Key is also likely to outline plans for welfare reform and signal moves to exploit minerals under conservation land.

NEW DIRECTION

Mr Key says he accepted some of the things to be announced today in the Government's policy programme for the year ahead could erode his political popularity, but believes the new direction will benefit the country economically.

He said he believed he would get both political and public support for the programme, which he will delivered in a speech in Parliament at around 2.30pm.

"I believe New Zealanders will see we are serious about a growth agenda, about lifting wages and opportunities for New Zealanders. I think they will see that we've carefully considered the position that there is balance, but we are taking some bold steps, I believe, to transform the New Zealand economy," he told reporters today.

There has been intense debate about all the Tax Working Group recommendations and Mr Key said not everyone would be happy with the Government's decisions.

"We are being asked to make some significant changes, but to do so without the fiscal head-room just to give away lots of extra money. That adds a different and more difficult dimension."

Mr Key said the line the Government was taking could cut in on his political capital, but that was to be expected.

"That may be the case, but in the end you're in politics to make a difference for New Zealand...I want to make sure that in my time in office I make a difference to making New Zealand a wealthier country, where our kids want to stay here.

"In the end political capital is a bit of an abstract concept, and whether people support our vision for New Zealand will be determined at the next ballot box. But in the end I've got to do what I think is right - and this is what I think is right."

Mr Key said preliminary discussions had been held with support parties about the reforms and while their votes had not been "signed in blood", he did not anticipate problems, including final decisions in the May budget and implementing them shortly after.

- with NZPA

- © Fairfax NZ News

153 comments
Post a comment
trueblue   #153   03:00 pm Feb 09 2010

Dragon #146 The brits can afford our housing because their pound is worth so much more than our dollar. They aren't the ones pushing up affordable housing - they buy at the top end of the scale.

And they reason you are able to charge lower rent is because I am subsidising your bloody tax bill while you write off your loss agains your income tax. Get a clue.

pee wee   #152   02:42 pm Feb 09 2010

Great news for NZ economy , sadly at least 30 years too late but better late than never . Its been a bean feast for many at the expense of low & middle class NZers . I also like the rise in gst . But it must be removed from fresh food & essential services low & middle income earners cat afford the present level let alone more . At least feed your people . Its a pity Key was not in gov earlier he knows right from wrong . good on him .

JR   #151   02:40 pm Feb 09 2010

Whilst i havent seen the tax intentions for property one surely has to ask where this will end. I have worked hard all my life, like a lot of other people and tried to invest wisely. Tax has been paid on my PAYE, GST, Rates, ACC Levies, Motor Vehicle Registrations, having a beer, road tax to name a few. In my view the Nats havent done anything that would spin my wheels in a forward direction one bit.

shas   #150   02:34 pm Feb 09 2010

Learn to adapt people or you will get left behind. Something most NZers need to wake up to.

Lockwood Smith is awesome.

AB   #149   02:13 pm Feb 09 2010

Dragon wake up buddy! "Look property owners/ investors still pay tax on all properties - there are just ways to minimise it. " – is called --- Loop holes in a bad system.

You want to be a Land lord, Pay Full Taxes like the rest of society, because you are not Adding ANY Value to the Country.

We currently borrow appox: $250 million a week to keep running, How long before someone pulls the plug on that loan. What are you going to do, export the “Sub-standard housing “ overseas?

Exports Out of NZ compared to imports is always decreasing, do we really want to be the next Zimbabwe of the pacific, where the money is worth less then the paper its printed on?

Ian   #148   01:57 pm Feb 09 2010

there is a myth that increasing property taxes results in rental increases - a little like saying reducing interest rates reduces rentals - this may be a long term impact if less people chose to invest - but is likely to be offset by stability in house prices.

Paul   #147   01:57 pm Feb 09 2010

(Muzza #102. I resorted to rentals as a security for my retirement with the hope of releasing the government from the burden of me when I retire.)

Are you saying you wern't going to claim government superanuation? I dont think so.

Great to see some of the loopholes being closed. I alway's hate to think I'm paying more tax than my boss, while he drives a flash car & sends his kids to private school.

The downside for me will probably the lose of equity in my family home. Hope I don't get laid off.

Dragon   #146   01:54 pm Feb 09 2010

Look property owners/ investors still pay tax on all properties - there are just ways to minimise it. You also have to consider immigration - there are so many brits coming here - who virtually scoff at the price of our houses and pay top dollar for them. They could be primarily to blame for the high prices, which no one seems to be discussing here. I have seen this in our local region - they just move here and buy up. I am a landlord and delibertly have a low rent to attract the tenants I want (families). We have worked hard to get where we are and are not out to 'rip' everyone off.

jonb   #145   01:52 pm Feb 09 2010

To all you moaners complaining about the National party pandering to the rich. Get real. This policy has the real chance of being political suicide for National (because the 'Rich' only make up 10% of the voter base - not quite enough for election victory) yet National will do it. Unlike the previous populist government who has created the welfare state we live in, this government actually wants the country to grow, and to grow the "rich" need to invest (their extra money) in areas that will create jobs. So the next time you knock the 'rich' just step back and look at who employs you. Don't bite the hand that feeds you. and no I'm not the 'rich', just middle income

Bruce   #144   01:51 pm Feb 09 2010

If it wasn't for the property investors, who would provide rental properties for people to rent? The Government has long ago sold off most of its State Houses as they could not afford to keep providing. The price of houses may drop as a result of tax changes but there are a lot of people who will never be able to buy their own house due to a variety of personal financial issues. Where will they live if property investors leave the market?


Show 94-143 of 153 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content