Peters slams rest home foreign owners

BY SHANE COWLISHAW
Last updated 16:55 03/08/2010
peters
Don Scott
Winston Peters spoke to a faithful crowd of about 250 at the Rangiora RSA.

Relevant offers

LATEST: More than 250 people turned up in North Canterbury today to hear New Zealand First leader Winston Peters denounce foreign companies who own aged care facilities.

Peters used his speech to the Returned Services Association in Rangiora to accuse foreign companies who own aged care facilities of lining their pockets while the standard of care slips.

The speech signalled another stage in the road to Peters' political recovery, ahead of another tilt at Parliament next year.

Peters is rumoured to be considering using Whanganui Mayor and former political aide Michael Laws as his strategist but today dismissed the speculation as "a media beat up''. He refused to deny the reports, however.

The speech comes just a day after Prime Minister John Key refused to rule out working with Peters again in the future, should his party cross the 5 percent threshold needed for seats in Parliament.

Speaking to a faithful crowd of about 250 at the Rangiora RSA, Peters railed against the foreign ownership of New Zealand assets and the "rubber-stamp brigade" at the Overseas Investment Office.

Selling such assets including resthomes and dairy farms was equal to treason, he said.

Kaiapoi resident Jan Morriss said she agreed with eveything Peters said, especially the folly of splitting up the electricity grid.

A lot of money was going offshore and it was worrying as a nation, she said.

|The homes were not being run for the benefit of residents but instead the aim was to enrich the pockets of their foreign owners, he said.

"They are here solely for profits - big profits - and they make sure they make them and send the money back overseas.”

Last year the Overseas Investment Office approved sales of aged rest care facilities worth $1.5 billion while caregivers were paid an average wage only slightly above the minimum wage.

While some rest homes had caring staff and provided excellent care there were others where old people were rationed in the number of showers they could have each week, he said.

The eldercare sector would be in for some "surprises" if NZ First were returned to Parliament at the next elections, Peters said.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

12 comments
Post a comment
Richard   #12   10:02 am Aug 04 2010

How does this guy get away with all he has done in the past? We are stilll waiting for the momey you were supposed to pay back Winston.

Darryl Rhodes   #11   09:02 am Aug 04 2010

Again Winstone is big on rhetoric but short on actual facts. Why does he not show the actual level of profits companies that own rest homes recieve and compare with what they could get in other "big profit" investments. He fails to mention the overseas owned Not for Profit companies that do not pay dividends but return any money made to the facilitites they run. He also fails to mention the funding role of government and that in real terms the funding to aged care has been declining for some years while costs have been increasing. Some of these increasing costs are due to the ever increasing accountabilities placed on facilities which, like many laws, increase the burden on those who already are working hard to provide a high standard of quality care while being ignored by those who are not. It is governmental philosophies that have pushed aged care into the business model, necessitating a profit outcome, so the businesses that operate them should not be criticised for doing well what governments have wanted them to do, ie run as profit making businesses. Mr Peters has been in politics long enough to have tried to change the fundamental model from which New Zealand provides aged care and has he done so? I suspect he sniffs an opportunity to get back into parliament or is it that he is developing an acute case of caring about this issue as his own potential need for aged care draws closer?

R. Barron   #10   04:58 am Aug 04 2010

I have a cunning plan...lets get all the NZ Companies, and individuals who own businesses and commercial real estate overseas to relinquish their holdings and profits and do the honourable thing and give it all back......... what planet are you people on.

theresaj   #9   07:37 pm Aug 03 2010

Some of the men commenting here have very little experience..I worked in an elderly care hospital for three years. When I started there it was owned by a Christian Trust..it was bought out by an overseas corporation. Immediately,they started cutting everything. They changed to cheap, nasty ,incontinence products. The quantity and standard of food declined. Ancillary staff were deemed unnecessary. The place became lean mean and hungry..they employed a weird manager and did the same at another facilty. At another place the first thing another corporation did was halve the food bill. Many patients did not get any bread.. As usual everything Winston says is true.

Az   #8   05:24 pm Aug 03 2010

Gotta love Winston

He might only ever pop up with the same scare mongering tactics every 3 years but he knows there's enough bigots out there to keep him in the running. If there's ever a book written on how to be a politician he deserves his own chapter.

Now that he's attacking foreigners once again - while pretending to be the pensioners champion it won't be long before he attacks Maori and throws a financial consiracy or two in the mix for good measure.

I don't like you... but it was a little boring without you

dwayne crombie   #7   05:02 pm Aug 03 2010

As someone who works for a large foreign owned provider of aged residential care, Winnie is well wide of the mark when it comes to facts. Around 70% of the aged care homes in New Zealand currently are run by NZ people or NZ controlled organisations (around 20% are Australian and 10% is British). If we had politicians who were willing to deal with the real issues of caring for older people and the strategies we should adopt as a country instead of cheap talk and grandstanding, then we might make a difference for older people in care.

Bob G   #6   04:06 pm Aug 03 2010

Winston is right I know of caregivers with many years of service, qualifications, etc who earn about 50 cents an hour above minimum wage. They work alongside many unqualified people whose standard of care leaves a lot to be desired but the overseas owners, while charging premium prices to the oldies, keep staff working on a pittance. Sadly, most experienced caregivers, because they have a propensity to really care, are exploited in spectacular fashion. Government does little to help, the Nurses union largely does little for this sector as well - it is gross!

Auld   #5   03:52 pm Aug 03 2010

Funding was increased by Ruth Dyson in 2007 however it didn't flow through owing to both DHBs and businesses absorbing most of it (Geoff #3). Elders or seniors deserve more respect than 'fosils' also.

Ken   #4   03:48 pm Aug 03 2010

Nothing new here, Winston playing the fear card to get votes from the growing population of our elderly citizens. What needs to change is our attitude to our elderly citizens, not seeing them as a problem to be put into a home but a family member to be cared for, including as part of the family unit rather than as a separate part.

geoff   #3   03:43 pm Aug 03 2010

Winnie the pooh. If there is so much money in running one of these places why does he not not invest his own money in owning one. Sucessive governments have not increased the payment for each fossil so only large corporates can afford the scale of operation required. Winnie yet again, or is it still, tells great stories and ignores all facts.


Show 1-2 of 12 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you cycle in Christchurch?

Yes

No

Occasionally

Vote Result

Related story: Cyclist's plea for changes after nearly losing leg

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content