Chinese copies of NZ websites

BY JO GILBERT
Last updated 05:00 25/08/2010

Relevant offers

Duplicates of dozens of New Zealand university and polytechnic websites have appeared on the internet in the Chinese language, upsetting tertiary authorities who are trying to find out why.

Shanghai-based Education in New Zealand promotes its 41 New Zealand university, polytechnic and private training establishment websites as the Chinese-language versions of the institutes' official websites.

The websites contain information about New Zealand, the institutes, courses and tuition costs. Their purpose remains unclear, but contacts for three Education in New Zealand agents are listed on each site.

Although discreet disclaimers state they are not official institute websites, the logos, images, layouts, colours and web addresses are similar or identical to the official portals.

Not all the published information is accurate, with Auckland photos displayed on pages representing Christchurch institutes, and the false Canterbury University site claiming the campus has circus-training equipment.

Matt Huntington, a spokesman for Universities New Zealand, formerly the New Zealand Vice-Chancellors' Committee, said the association was "trying to get to the bottom of it" as a few of its eight members were "quite upset" about the mock sites.

The body would decide whether to take action within the next 24 hours, he said.

Websites replicated by the organisation, which claims to be an education agency, include all eight universities, the Christchurch Polytechnic Institute of Technology, the Southern Institute of Technology and the New Zealand College of Chiropractic.

Export education body Education New Zealand chief executive Robert Stevens said his agency had never heard of the organisation or its contact, Shanghai-based Luo Cheng. "We don't know anything about this person or this outfit; they're not on our database," Stevens said. "If I was any of these institutes being misrepresented, I would be talking to a lawyer."

A man who said he was Cheng spoke to The Press last night. Asked about the websites, he said in broken English that they were "changing" and he would get an English speaker to make contact today.

Institutes spoken to by The Press said they were "looking into the matter".

However, Victoria University had requested that the Chinese group remove the mock website. A spokeswoman for the Wellington university said the request was made yesterday because the university preferred to run its own websites.

Internet law specialist Rick Shera said the imitations gave institutes "good grounds" for legal cases regarding copyright, fair trade and intellectual property law.

Ad Feedback

"It's certainly trading off the integrity of the [official] websites and has the potential to cause confusion," he said.

Shera said the "scraping" or lifting of information, images or data from websites to other sites without acknowledgment was becoming increasingly common.

- © Fairfax NZ News

3 comments
Post a comment
Michael   #3   03:35 pm Aug 27 2010

This article doesn't imply that the Shanghai agent has published these websites to advertise false schools or false diplomas.

Independent agents in China (and in other countries) get commissions from our universities when they find international students for them. That's part of how we market our education overseas - through local agents. Some of our schools pay 30-40% of student fees to the agent who introduced the student.

This guy is marketing online to attract students to study in New Zealand. He's presumed that translating the entire site for each school directly is better than writing a new site about them. He just hasn't bothered to ask the schools' permission to do so, thinking they probably wouldn't mind because the objective is to find more students for them.

It was probably cheaper for him to pay someone to translate the sites than to pay someone to write new ones. These aren't 'fake' websites, they're just unauthorised translations. At worst, they may be poor translations.

Sounds very much like this guy has been lazy and sloppy. That's hardly newsworthy. Lots of people copy information from other sites and paste it on their own, and usually without claiming they created the content themselves. Just because he's used the whole site doesn't make it any more shocking. The real item of interest in this article is that the Kiwi universities seem to be morally outraged about a storm in a teacup. Says more about us than it does about the Chinese.

Christopher   #2   12:08 pm Aug 25 2010

Was this in the small print of the FTA ? Or perhaps they've just got a wee bit muddled with their acqusition timetable; dairy farms this year - universities next year. Or then again maybe they've just opted to go straight to the intellectual capital.

auld   #1   10:48 am Aug 25 2010

I think the certificates / diplomas, as if someone has completed a course they haven't, are available for sale too. Cheapens the real thing for those who did the courses. I'm not sure if that is these sites or somewhere else in China / Thailand and thereabouts.

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers
Opinion poll

Do you cycle in Christchurch?

Yes

No

Occasionally

Vote Result

Related story: Cyclist's plea for changes after nearly losing leg

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content