Review: Domingo oozes power in Christchurch

Opera superstar's stunning performance

TIMOTHY JONES
Last updated 05:00 07/10/2011

Related Links

Opera stars make Christchurch 'come alive'

Relevant offers

REVIEW: Placido may be 70 but he still has what it takes.

His is, quite obviously, not a young man's voice but from his first phrase, shaped and polished like a jewel, this concert was going to be a treat.

That whole first aria, O Souverain from Massenet's Le Cid, was a model, with every phrase oozing expressive power and coloured to perfection. With his vast experience, maestro Domingo knows just what his voice is doing and just how far it can be pushed. This he never misjudged.

I find both his English and German less than persuasive, with unidiomatic vowels and unnatural placements of emphasis, but no item on the programme was other than warm and opulent, and utterly charming. In the two items of zarzuela, on the other hand, he was right inside the music to the extent that it is hard to imagine them ever being sung better.

By comparison, Katherine Jenkins sounded monochrome, but I accept that that is a very tough comparison to make. I enjoyed the gypsy song from Carmen and the Tonight duet from West Side Story, but found her Mon coeur s'ouvre à ta voix just a bit too passive.

However, her communication with the audience and with Domingo was superb, and all their duets were most impressive.

The NZSO National Youth Orchestra played their hearts out and offered a very professional supporting sound, though through the amplifiers, it is hard to know who was doing what.

Their director, Peter Walls, conducted orchestral excerpts from Carmen, which really came to life.

Watching the concert on big screens and listening to it through speakers, both unavoidable in such a vast venue, was a bit like being in the fanzone when you really wanted to be at the match itself. With the music, then, there was little to fault; the inadequacies of the arena as a concert venue, it's hard to know where to begin.

Placido Domingo and Katherine Jenkins, with the NZSO National Youth Orchestra conducted by Eugene Kohn, at the CBS Canterbury Arena, Thursday,  October 6 at 8pm.

Ad Feedback

- © Fairfax NZ News

Special offers
Opinion poll

Can we afford a commuter rail service for North Canterbury?

Yes, it's long overdue

No, there are other options

Vote Result

Related story: Traffic delays force commuter rail services probe

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Then and Now