Homeowner - at 3degC - is over EQC

Last updated 05:00 14/08/2014
Ken Keir

FRUSTRATED: Ken Keir believes if EQC had not apportioned his earthquake damage across two quakes it would already be fixed.

Relevant offers

Christchurch Earthquake 2011

Woman who pinned her $472k theft on employer on post-quake trauma loses appeal Court throws out $6.5m insurance offer for Henderson property CTV engineer inquiry 'not in public interest' Gap Filler celebrates five years of brightening Christchurch's vacant spaces Earthquake insurer Southern Response sets aside $4m for legal fees Canterbury families tell their stories of quake rebuild Holy Trinity church bells set to ring Lyttelton again Christchurch's 100-day blueprint took 67 days with only 20-odd days of design Leukaemia battle for Christchurch boy who lost his father in February 2011 quake Oamaru woman reunited with fingers 80 years after death

Ken Keir was happy when he was paid out $113,000 by the Earthquake Commission after the February 2011 quake.

Then it asked for the money back.

He was told his damage was being apportioned over the September and February quakes and therefore it was under cap.

But, Keir said, the house was not damaged in the September quake.

He was told earlier this year if he paid the money back, his Aranui home would be fixed by winter. He paid. A few days ago he took out the thermometer in the living room. It was 3 degrees Celsius. The home is still to be fixed.

"It's just been a battle. It's wearing me down. It creeps up slowly but I've had enough. It becomes too much."

Keir has gone through four jobs as he struggles to keep focused.

If he had held on to the money his home would be fixed by now. Instead, liquefaction material remains under his floor boards, his house has sunk and dislodged double-glazed windows are useless against the cold.

Keir's sister-in-law Adrienne, who lives with him, said she was constantly sick.

"The wallpaper is peeling off the bedroom walls. I can't get any answers from anyone. It's just absolutely freezing. Nothing is happening."

EQC's Canterbury Home Repair Program (CHRP) general manager Reid Stiven said Keir was offered a cap payment prior to the introduction of apportionment. That money then needed to be split across both earthquakes as EQC deemed there had been damage in the September quake.

"This property has also undergone technical review regarding engineering solutions, and with this now complete, along with costings, repairs through the CHRP can move forward."

A 2011 High Court ruling decided that EQC cover was renewed after each earthquake event as long as the property remained insured. EQC said apportionment for each quake was necessary to determine when the damage occurred so that it could be work out what costs EQC needed to cover and what potentially rested with the private insurer.

An EQC spokesperson said a works order for Keir's home repairs was likely to be issued next week.

Ad Feedback

- The Press


Special offers
Opinion poll

Which memorial design do you like most?

Memorial Wall with a reflective pond

Table and Chairs

A Green and Peaceful Landscape

Call and Response

Riverside Promenade

A Curved and Inclusive Memorial Wall

Vote Result

Related story: Christchurch earthquake memorial designs unveiled

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content