One-way door policies not the only solution

MIKE YARDLEY
Last updated 06:59 18/06/2013

Relevant offers

Columnists

Do you have a loopy problem? Call Paula! The dummy who drove with jet lag Great company of the ages Cecile Meier: A week without spending Johnny Moore: Can't blame red tape At an age of comfort over style Michele A'Court: The rules for women Is a larger world conflict looming? Mike Yardley: Rail out but email in A world full of noise and a mailbox full of bother

OPINION: Last week I argued that most one-way door policies imposed on the hospitality trade have subsequently been abandoned on the grounds of ineffectiveness.

Some correspondents have challenged me to furnish those claims with supporting evidence. Fair enough, too!

ALAC assessed Christchurch's previous one-way policy, concluding in their own publicly available evaluation that it failed to achieve its stated goal of cutting crime by 10 per cent.

Across the creek, many Australian cities have ditched their one-way policies, or lockouts as they call them, notably Melbourne and Sydney, who both trialled and scrapped 2am lockouts.

Meanwhile, Brisbane and Adelaide are both pursuing a 3am lockout, which is decidedly more generous than the strangulating 1am deadline slated for our city.

I think a 3am shutdown in central Christchurch is entirely reasonable, but banning people from entering any licensed premises at 1am will cast a deep shadow across our nightlife scene, unfairly blunting its verve and sparkle.

Why should responsible nightspots and their responsible patrons be treated like public pests?

Parliament should hang its head in shame for coughing up the opportunity to tackle the trouble-makers with targeted law changes.

For example, why not reinstate public drunkenness as a summary offence?

Instead, the police have to wait until the drunk descends into disorderly or offensive behaviour before they can pounce.

Why not implement a star ratings system for licensed premises, as Sydney is doing?

And I concur with the British deputy Prime Minister's call for drunken revellers who snarl up A&E with self-inflicted injuries, to be charged for medical treatment.

Administering such a charge might well be too problematic, but the sentiment is well-placed.

Yes, Minister

Thank God for Gerry's "media missile". Without it, we'd still be in the dark that the city council's consenting process was in major schtook.

The culture of secrecy and the failure of senior staff to inform the council's governance arm of the "intention to revoke" letter has all too familiar echoes of a Yes, Minister script.

Meanwhile, in stark contrast to the CCC fiasco, Waimakariri continues to be the recovery's pace-maker and standard-bearer.

The district council's consenting process, swamped with unprecedented and unwavering demand, has steadfastly remained on top of the job - 98 per cent of consent applications are processed within 20 working days, with the average turnaround taking 9 to 10 days.

Polar plunge

Ad Feedback

With winter in force, a little comfort food sure helps warm the cockles. Icecream is probably not the most logical sweetener but my winter weakness is a regular hit of hot custard and Tip Top candy-floss icecream.

Nutritious? No. Electrifying? Yes.

- The Press

Comments

Special offers
Opinion poll

Have you ever cheated at the checkout?

Yes, I do it all the time

Once or twice. It's just too easy

No, never.

Vote Result

Related story: Taking self-service to a whole new level

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content