Robbie Deans: Should he stay or go?

MARK REASON
Last updated 08:19 01/07/2013
robbie std
KNIFE EDGE: Wallabies coach and former Crusaders coach Robbie Deans could be on borrowed time.

Relevant offers

Rugby

Ryan Crotty shaving his beard for charity Canty win three-in-a-row Nonu out for season, Carter back for Cantabs Carter unlikely to play in Rugby Championship Revamped Canterbury side for Northland clash Recovery: The long road back Hansen admits All Blacks 'gutted' to miss win Coach Todd Blackadder's job at Crusaders safe Dan Carter to miss Bledisloe Cup tests Nemani Nadolo: Racist slur won't ruin it

OPINION: Bill Pulver has a problem. What in Campese's name does he do if Australia win the final test in Sydney and with it the series?

What then?

Does Robbie Deans stay on as coach? Does the Australian Rugby Union chief executive ignore all the disquiet, turgid tactics and the animosity around the country just because the Wallabies won a series that could have gone either way?

On Saturday night Deans' future was attached to the end of Leigh Halfpenny's boot. If the finest goal kicker in current world rugby - no, make that one of the finest of all time, the evidence of this tour demands it - nailed his penalty kick from somewhere near Melbourne's Docklands then Robbie was out of here.

With a winning record under 60 per cent and a 2-0 defeat by the Lions, Deans could not survive.

Conor Murray tried to steal a yard or two on Halfpenny's behalf but the impressive Craig Joubert would have none of it.

Halfpenny's kick was just on the Lions' side of halfway. And maybe, just maybe, that extra yard or two saved Deans. Halfpenny was at his limit. He pressed for the extra distance and lost his timing.

But why should this make any difference to Deans' future? The first two tests turned on events outside the coaches' control. They have turned on luck and goalkickers and injuries and referees. They have not been turned by the men in the glass box.

Pulver should look at the way Australia played on Saturday, he should look at all that has gone before, and he should pull the lever.

We expected the Australians to come in waves in the second test. We expected Ben Alexander in his 50th test to barrel over the Niagara, we expected James Horwill to take out his rage on the Lions, we expected Will Genia to boss the game and Israel Folau to rampage over belittled defenders.

Instead, we were left treading water like Lara Bingle, the poster girl of Australian tourism, internally shouting: "Where the bloody hell are you?"

We waited and we waited for Australia to show up. In the end it seemed entirely appropriate that a man on one leg won the man-of- the-match award.

Genia was clearly carrying a knee injury. The Wallabies halfback struggled to pass to his left across his wounded right knee, opening up chest-on to the receiver, and yet he still won the vote as the game's star man, although for my money Sam Warburton was just as worthy.

Genia was a small mercy that we were very thankful for because this was an unimaginative game of rugby played between two fearful teams.

Ad Feedback

James O'Connor's misguided efforts at No 10 for Australia are becoming an ongoing criticism of a coach who thinks he can play there.

The All Blacks are vulnerable at the moment but at least they try to play a bit of footie.

Australia have game breakers all over the pitch yet they bash up these endless pods, all going the same way, until they reach the touchline. Then they go back the other way.

If they aren't going from side to side across the pitch, they are playing the "territory" game. What a boring phrase this is, what a boring way to play.

Side to side, up and down, like some primitive computer game. Only when Australia had no choice, only when they were six points down and chasing the game, did they emerge from their own fear.

Nearly 25 years ago they lost a series against the Lions and David Campese was widely blamed for trying to run out from his own line. Campo won far more matches than he lost and the inferiority of the Australian forwards was the real reason they lost that series.

Men such as Mark Ella and Campese seemed to epitomise Australian rugby, but the ghost of Campo was nowhere to be seen on Saturday.

After the match, captain Horwill was asked about the spirit of his men and how they keep coming from behind.

Horwill pointedly said you can't coach that. It came from within. It came from a place that coaches can't reach. And Robbie looked at his captain sideways, he looked at the man who refused to endorse his coach last week, and you could sense the separation.

Coach Mickey Arthur lost control of the Australian cricket team and he is gone. The larrikins kicked up and the South African lost his job. Deans lost control of the larrikins in his rugby side long ago but somehow he held on and held on.

It is not altogether his fault. Australia's culture is very different to Canterbury's and Deans is not at home here.

But Pulver must not be swayed by results. Deans was outcoached on Saturday as Australia were hammered at the breakdown, the area that was supposed to decide the series. Only when his men chased the game and Genia and Folau played off the cuff, did Australia come through.

The Dullabies were rescued by two special players who changed direction. It is time for Pulver to do the same.

- The Press

Comments

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content