'Puppet' used to hide SCF Shark deal, Crown says

EMMA BAILEY
Last updated 05:00 06/08/2014

Relevant offers

South Canterbury Finance (SCF) directors used a "puppet director" to conceal a related party, the Crown alleges.

On the first day of the Crown's closing yesterday, Colin Carruthers, QC, outlined the first count against Robert White and Edward Sullivan, which relates to Shark Wholesalers.

Sullivan's nephew, Geoffrey Sullivan, was the general manager of Specialised Sales and Marketing (SSM), which sold heating appliances. He identified that SSM had a funding problem. His uncle proposed that a new company, Shark Wholesalers, purchase SSM stock and resell it to SSM as needed. Sullivan appointed his brother-in-law, Peter Symes, as the sole director and shareholder of Shark. SCF loaned $5.2 million to Shark so it could purchase the stock from SSM.

Count one alleges both directors made a false statement in prospectus 55 by not properly declaring the lending and involvement with Shark and not identifying it as a related party. The Crown needs to prove that both men knew they had been reckless and made false statements in the prospectus and that it would induce people to invest in SCF.

Carruthers said Symes, who has since died, had no active role and was a "puppet" of Sullivan.

Of Symes' interview with the Serious Fraud Office, he said "his evidence is modest, even if the consequences of it are not. Simply that his brother-in-law asked a series of favours, that consisted of being a director and shareholder of various companies he had no involvement in and took no part in other than to sign documents.

"Mr Sullivan cannot realistically say he thought the insertion of Mr Symes into the transaction meant that it was no longer related-party." White had also failed to act, he said, as he knew Symes was related.

Ad Feedback

- The Timaru Herald

Boys spoken to about break-in

Three boys, aged 12 and 11, will be spoken to about a break-in at Pleasant Point Primary School.

Special offers
Opinion poll

Should Timaru drop its community Christmas dinner?

No - I would hate to see us lose this.

Yes - it's becoming a struggle every year to find volunteers. Time for a rethink.

Vote Result

Related story: Festive dinner under threat

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content

Email or call (03) 687 1383
Website ideas: Email or tweet us
Book an ad: Email or call (03) 687-1337
Place a classfied ad: Email
  or call (03) 687-1395

Subscribe: Email
  or call (03) 687 1392 or 0800 100 129

No paper click here
Stop or start your paper click here
Buy a photo
View or sign up for the Digital Edition
Discover how to use Newspapers in Education
Make timaruherald.co.nz your homepage

Family Notices
POINTER death notices

Death notices

View obituaries from around the region.

POINTER celebrations

Celebrations

View marriage and birth notices from around the region

Community links
Pointer: Job seekers

Wanted: Job seekers

Search here for a job.

Follow us
Pointer: Timaru Herald Social icons