Funding for a planned cardboard cathedral could be in jeopardy after a judge ruled that Christ Church Cathedral insurance money could not be used for the project.
Anglican leaders had planned to use $4 million of insurance money from Christ Church Cathedral to fund the $5.3m transitional project near Latimer Square.
But Justice Chisholm ruled on Thursday that the insurance money could be used only for a project on the original Cathedral Square site.
"Given the site-specific purpose of the cathedral trust, it is difficult to see how any insurance proceeds arising from the insurance over the cathedral could be used off-site," he ruled.
The ruling was made as part of a case brought by the Great Christchurch Buildings Trust claiming the Anglican Church's deconstruction plans breached an act of Parliament protecting church buildings and that the church trustees were obliged to repair the cathedral.
The decision put a hold on demolition of the cathedral but said the church was not required to replicate the building as it stood before the Canterbury earthquakes.
The High Court decision also granted a judicial review of the cathedral decision.
The temporary cathedral, which would seat 700 people, was expected to open in February.
Trust co-chairman Philip Burdon said the church would have to abide by the judge's ruling on the insurance funds.
"The judge has ruled that all insurance money be applied to the rebuild of the cathedral and that is clearly a reality that the church will have to respect," he said.
Anglican diocese legal representative Jared Ormsby said the funding would have to be reconsidered.
"We have to look at that again in light of what the judge is saying," he said. "He is not saying the transitional cathedral itself is a bad decision, but you need to quite quickly have a look at the funding question and sort that out as quickly as we can. We may need to get further clarity from the court."
Ormsby said the ruling was "tentative" and they would ask for clarification from the judge. Fairfax NZ
- Fairfax Media