Bain compensation fight setback

Last updated 11:34 03/12/2012
David Bain
KIRK HARGREAVES/The Press
David Bain

Relevant offers

National

Family of manslaughter victim Matthew Coley want discussion about New Zealand youth violence Man critically injured after crashing into garage Robbed Christchurch dairy owner: 'I thought they were going to kill me' Students use knives and hurl chairs in South Auckland KFC brawl Police will now attend all house break-ins Axe-wielding man threatens Christchurch dairy owner as wave of robberies continues Nuclear family a thing of the past, new research shows Akaroa caregiver's trust gets $587,000 despite suspicious behaviour Blackface and terrorist costumes condemned Father of alleged gunman Max Winders takes the stand in the George Taiaroa murder trial

David Bain's fight for compensation has hit another hurdle - with Justice Minister Judith Collins ordering a review of recommendations.

It has been widely reported that Canadian Supreme Court judge Ian Binnie concluded Bain was innocent on the balance of probabilities of the murder of his parents, two sisters and brother in 1994. The report has not been released publicly.

Collins has delayed her decision and Prime Minister John Key this morning confirmed Collins has ''some real issues'' with the recommendations, and has sent it to a QC.

''She hasn't been happy with the advice,'' Key told Newstalk ZB. ''I think she's got concerns and said go away and check some of this stuff.''

Key has only seen a ''top line analysis'' of the report - but discussed concerns with Collins.

Cabinet makes the final decision on whether Bain will be compensated for wrongful imprisonment.

Bain spent almost 13 years in jail, and was acquitted at a retrial in 2009.

Former justice minister Simon Power asked Binnie to consider the compensation claim and he reported back in September.

Collins initially said she would make a decision before Christmas. There is speculation Bain stands to get a $2 million payout.

The justice minister is overseas this week and a spokeswoman could only confirm the decision will not go before Cabinet until next year.

Ad Feedback

- Stuff

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content