My American pros and cons list

Last updated 08:37 28/05/2012

Sometimes on this blog I can paint myself into corners in your eyes where I'm simultaneously an American-bashing Kiwi who should go home and an NZ-hating traitor who wouldn't be welcome back. 

The irony is not lost on me, and there're other factors and overreactions at play, but there's a strange modicum of truth in this. 

happyBecause America can prompt two independent and equally valid yet completely divergent responses from me when I consider my pending immigration application.

I don't know if one country can ever only prompt one separate emotion from us - can it? 

Mostly, I try to focus on how there're a lot of really great things about American life. 

As a journalist, there's more opportunity here. It's a tough climate globally for all media outlets, and there are a lot of layoffs going around here still. But there's a lot of hiring going on. And with such a large market, there is an incredible breadth of publications: from websites and blogs, through to the independent street press going free on street corners each week, to city-specific major magazines, national titles, niche titles, business news, community news, and dozens of mid-size and major metropolitan titles. Every type and every form and every brand and ideology of journalism is serviced extensively. There's also a boatload of media innovation. 

It's all very good to be around. And for a freelance journalist, there're always stories to be found. 

America is exciting. There's a lot to it. I'm excited to live in San Francisco - for the museums, the concerts, the book and record shops, the history, the pace, the culture and the counterculture. I'm looking forward to living in driving distance of Los Angeles. Maybe I'll even make my first trip to Coachella

There's a self-belief and a work ethic around in America, a respect for success and for reaching up and toward the stratosphere. In pockets of the country an incredible culture of knowledge and history of discovery manifests itself in places such as Stanford and Palo Alto and MIT, Harvard and Cambridge, and technology and medical sectors are multiplying at an incredible rate. 

There's a certain whoa factor to American life. And on top of this, you're in the middle of the world, closer to South America, Europe. Not everything is a half-day flight away.

But then there are the frequent moments when you can't help but sigh to yourself at this country, as though it is a bad drunk who just needs to be put in a taxi and told to sleep it off.   

sadI call these my "Really, America?" moments. 

First, there's the health insurance thing. I've been medically uninsured the past few months, which is silly and something that I've constantly meant to rectify but haven't. It means that I am living moment-to-moment with no safety net. Even with insurance, I could still end up substantially out of pocket in the event of a medical catastrophe.

The culture of misinformation that has branded the sorts of medical benefits and assurances that every New Zealander enjoys as state-sponsored socialism makes me grit my teeth. 

There's the general sense of economic decline across the entire country, and the constant frustration of a political system focused entirely on getting re-elected at the expense of fixing it. The governor of California, presiding over the world's fifth-largest economy, just announced that the state was facing an annual budget deficit that was almost twice as large as the state had recently estimated and that planned cuts were going to be even more severe. 

Student debt recently hit $1 trillion in the USA and more than 90 per cent of students borrow to study. Institutions of higher education are stratified and bloodthirsty and a tertiary qualification is not within the reach of everybody here.

As somebody who plans on having American children that I would like to educate, this terrifies me.  

Despite the passing of a bogglingly complex financial reform bill, JPMorgan Chase still managed to lose $2 billion. Foreclosure rates remain high. House prices are in the toilet. There's also the long work weeks, with only two weeks' guaranteed annual holiday. 

And so you have these structural fractures in America's education, financial, housing, government and medical sectors that aren't getting addressed. 

But to rub salt in the wound of worry, there's an irrelevant preoccupation with social and moral issues, and a constant stream of bigotry from national representatives. It feels as though there's an American answer to Colin Craig running his mouth off every day. 

Each of the two responses in me is genuine. 

But I choose as always to side with hope over exasperation, because it is just a better way to live. 

I know that when I begin the application for residency in the coming weeks, it is something that comes with a long pros and cons list. 

There's no resolving the two sides to the reality of an American life: Dr. Doom and Mr. Opportunity.

And isn't doubt a natural part of any reality? I like to see both sides of any situation. I think it is a skill, not a curse, which can save us all from fundamentalism and demagoguery.   

Become a fan of Voyages in America on Facebook: you'll get blog posts to your news feed, some great photography, and some good chatter. You can also follow the conversation on Twitter, or send an email and share your thoughts

17 comments
Post a comment
Mungous   #1   09:15 am May 28 2012

The American political and social landscape does two things, if I may stretch a metaphor - dangles a very attractive looking carrot of success to motivate those with ambition, while simultaneously using a pretty unpleasant stick to beat those who fall behind. While this phenomenon has the ultimate effect of stretching the bell curve of wealth distribution (from the obscenely wealthy down to those living it rough out of cardboard boxes), it also generates two other significant outcomes: (1) as success is highly prized, sought after and rewarded, the resulting high levels of success accelerates society's overall progress (when "progress" measured by the same set of capitalist benchmarks as "success"); and (2) as those who fall behind feel more desperate and hopeless, they may resort to extreme acts to try to shortcut the hard work required for "success" (whether it's a crack-whore, drug dealer or white-collar criminal looking for an easy extra million).

Compared to NZ, where the successful tend to be penalised (some call it tall poppy syndrome, but I suspect it is an artefact of the then-prevailing philosophical views of the British moralist philosophers in the 19th Century) and unskilled and unmotivated non-contributors are rewarded with free money and houses, it is no wonder that an ideologically New Zealand mindset struggles to understand the underpinnings of the American Dream.

The USA is a land of great contrast. You can either love it or hate it, but it is hard to be indifferent about it...

bjammin   #2   09:26 am May 28 2012

Excellent article, James.

Its an obvious point to make again, but many New Zealanders do not even begin to fully understand the scope of divesity America has. Definitely a country that frustrates and delights in equal measure.

There's more to the place than Iraqi invasions and Keeping Up With The Kardashians, folks. At least try and visit America before you sound off. It might help you get a more balanced view.

hmmm   #3   09:43 am May 28 2012

You're uninsured and you want American children? why do you want to be an American so badly?

MJ   #4   11:10 am May 28 2012

I think most New Zealanders find the US arguments against free healthcare baffling and labelling health insurance a "benefit" seems oxymoronic. Healthcare is a right not a privilege.

fred   #5   02:13 pm May 28 2012

bjammin #2 "At least try and visit America before you sound off. It might help you get a more balanced view."

I would, but I'd rather not have some strange guy shove his hands down my pants at the airport, and have my thumbprints and photo taken and entered into who knows what database. I'll stick to streetview and blogs for now thanks.

DeepRed   #6   03:21 pm May 28 2012

San Francisco is definitely one of America's better areas, as are Portland and Seattle. So much so they might as well be independent city-states.

@Mungous #1: right now the exact opposite of tall poppy syndrome - Social Darwinism - is gaining momentum in NZ, and it could prove to be even more destructive.

DeepRed   #7   03:22 pm May 28 2012

@fred #5: was that LAX? I've heard SFO is far more pleasant to fly through.

thomarse   #8   03:33 pm May 28 2012

@Fred #5, Not sure if you're being ironic. If you are, kudos.

Russell   #9   03:15 am May 29 2012

I've been reading these faux-blog articles for a while now and the thing that stands out is the sheer ignorance of the writer. It's as if he is willfully not doing even the most basic of research into his own life in order to make things easier for himself. He originally thinks he can simply live in the US for six months? He thinks that the US guarantees *any* vacation time for employees, let alone 2 weeks? He implies the NZ health care system isn't socialist when it is (& not a bad thing either)? Month after month, he writes in a manner that makes him look like someone that is just so woefully ignorant of the world around him that it actually makes me cringe - the cultural and social ignorance is frightening, not to mention the lack of any depth to his general knowledge. As someone living in the US for the past seven years, I guess he'll fit in to the US very well.

kiwijenn   #10   09:54 am May 29 2012

@Russell--Dude. Have a chai and spend some time in Downward Dog!

James is a writer. And this is a blog. He has simply shared his foibles with us--foibles that we all have. Everything about life is context, and not everything has to be precise and explained. (i.e.,while healthcare in NZ is technically 'socilaised', it is not socialism in the pejorative sense that many in the US see it as; also the accepted custom of most US employers providng two weeks of leave, regardless of any federal or state law mandating it).

As someone from the US living in New Zealand, I have really enjoyed the perspective James has on my home country--the good and the bad. You're right, Russell, in that he fits into the US very well, because he's smart, introspective, and strives to find the best in things and situations. But he also experineces cultural confusion, has misunderstandings, and makes mistakes that he admits. In short, he's human. Were we all so human, the world would be a lot better off.


Show 11-17 of 17 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content