US got Snowden's name wrong: Hong Kong

Last updated 19:24 28/06/2013
Edward Snowden
SPEAKING OUT: National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden.

Relevant offers


At 100 days, US President Donald Trump governs as he campaigned Woman shot at point-blank range during robbery in the US saved by her purse US President Donald Trump: 'Major, major conflict' with North Korea possible Fourth inmate to be executed in eight days in US state lurches and gasps as he dies Donald Trump order could open Pacific Ocean, Arctic to new oil and gas drilling Donald Trump says he thought being president would be easier than his old life Barack Obama seemed different, but he's just another money-grubbing politician After a long life together, elderly couple die minutes apart while holding hands From 0-100: Presidents' first days come at varying speed Delta passenger said he was kicked off a plane for using the toilet

Edward Snowden's bespectacled and goateed face was almost unavoidable in Hong Kong last week. It stared out from news stands, banners and giant TV screens on shopping malls and office buildings after it became known that the admitted leaker of US secrets was in town and in hiding.

Still, when the US asked the semi-autonomous Chinese city for Snowden's provisional arrest, its response was essentially this: Who exactly do you mean?

Justice Secretary Rimsky Yuen said Hong Kong officials weren't sure who to look for because the US government got Snowden's middle name wrong in documents filed to back its arrest request.

He said Hong Kong immigration records listed Snowden's middle name as Joseph, but the US government used the name James in some documents and referred to him only as Edward J Snowden in others.

"These three names are not exactly the same. Therefore, we believed that there was a need to clarify," Yuen said.

Yuen said US authorities also failed to provide Snowden's passport number. He said officials received the arrest request on June 15 and sent a request June 21 for clarification. Two days later, Snowden flew to Moscow.

"Up until the moment of Snowden's departure, the very minute, the US Department of Justice did not reply to our request for further information. Therefore, in our legal system, there is no legal basis for the requested provisional arrest warrant," Yuen said.

In the absence of such a warrant, the "Hong Kong government has no legal basis for restricting or prohibiting Snowden leaving Hong Kong".

US officials don't buy Hong Kong's explanation, and neither do some legal experts in the city.

"It's not like he's some mystery figure. He revealed himself on TV," said Hong Kong University law professor Simon Young.

"The whole world knows what he looks like."

Young and Hong Kong-based extradition lawyer Michael Blanchflower said authorities were able to exercise their discretion and use other methods to identify fugitives, who often used aliases.

"It may be in some cases that the person's name or passport number are not known, but for instance you could have a physical description accompanied by a photograph," said Blanchflower.

The decision to let Snowden go has raised tensions between the US and Hong Kong. US officials suggested that Beijing had a hand in letting Snowden leave Hong Kong, a former British colony that is now a semi-autonomous region with its own legal system. But Hong Kong leaders say they were following the city's rule of law in processing the US request.

Ad Feedback

The US Justice Department said the government gave Hong Kong all the information that was required under the terms of their extradition treaty.

"The fugitive's photos and videos were widely reported through multiple news outlets. That Hong Kong would ask for more information about his identity demonstrates that it was simply trying to create a pretext for not acting on the provisional arrest request," a spokeswoman said on condition of anonymity under ground rules set by the department.

"It wasn't a pretext at all," Hong Kong leader Leung Chun-ying said.

"We were just following the laws of Hong Kong."

Young, who specialises in criminal law, said that because of the "political sensitivities" involved in the case, authorities did not rush the case and had taken extra care.

"I think that the Hong Kong government was insisting on a fairly high standard of completeness, and that, I assume, is their practice. They know that our courts will look at these things very closely and they don't take shortcuts," he said.

Snowden, a former National Security Agency contractor and ex-CIA employee, disclosed the broad scope of two highly classified counterterror surveillance programs to two newspapers. The programs collect vast amounts of Americans' phone records and worldwide online data in the name of national security.

He was expected to seek asylum in Ecuador, but it's unclear where he was today. Russian President Vladimir Putin said this week that Snowden was in the transit area of Moscow's main airport, but a horde of reporters had found no trace of him.

The anti-secrecy group WikiLeaks said one of its staffers was with Snowden, and said on Twitter that he was well.

- AP

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content