Anger over anti-whaling 'moral crusade'

Last updated 12:27 03/07/2013

Relevant offers

Asia

Chinese Premier Li Keqiang arrives in New Zealand for visit and trade talks Shoppers injured when mall escalator reverses at high speed in Hong Kong Eleven endangered wild elephants rescued from mud hole in Cambodia Oscar Kightley: My brother served in the army, I nearly served – but nobody signed up to kill civilians Parents and newborn baby intercepted in desperate boat bid to reach NZ, detained in Indonesia Two gold mine accidents in central China leave 11 dead US judge grants Singaporean blogger's asylum request Body of NZ man who dived off a cliff to try to save his swept away girlfriend in Bali found Australian man given suspended sentence, fined $200, over jet ski death South Korean ferry that sank 3 years ago lifted from sea

Japan has told the UN's top court that Australia's anti-whaling stance is part of a ''civilising mission and moral crusade'' that is totally out of place in the modern world.

Tokyo didn't hold back in its opening submission to the 16 judges of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague on Tuesday (NZT Wednesday).

''The days of civilising missions and moral crusades are over,'' lawyer Payam Akhavan told the court.

''In a world with diverse civilisations and traditions, international law cannot become an instrument for imposing the cultural preference of some at the expense of others.''

Canberra last week argued Japan's Jarpa research programme was cloaking ongoing commercial whaling in the lab coat of science.

It therefore breached the 1946 whaling convention, which only allows harpooning ''for purposes of scientific research'', Australia said.

But Japan's deputy foreign affairs minister, Koji Tsuruoka, hit back on Tuesday (NZT Wednesday) by insisting Tokyo was conducting a ''comprehensive scientific research programme'' whose aim was to demonstrate that commercial whaling could be sustainable.

''The lifting of the (1982) moratorium requires that convincing scientific data be presented,'' Tsuruoka said.

The deputy foreign minister argued Japan had long lived in harmony with nature and it would be the last country to misuse marine resources.

''Australia can't impose its will on other nations nor change the International Whaling Commission (IWC) into an organisation opposed to whaling,'' he said.

Japan notes Australia engaged in commercial whaling until 1979  when then prime minister Malcolm Fraser vowed to fight for a worldwide ban.

Tokyo argues killing 850 minke whales in the Southern Ocean each year under Jarpa won't endanger stocks.

Professor Akhavan on Tuesday (NZT Wednesday) said Japan stood unfairly accused of 30 years of defiance and deception, but Australia's position was  based on a belief ''that whales are unique, sacred, charismatic mammals that should never be killed''.

Canberra was engaged in ''an emotional anti-whaling moral crusade that in the name of zero-tolerance tolerates Sea Shepherd's violent extremism, the politicisation of science, the collapse of the IWC and now, before this court, baseless accusations of bad faith against Japan''.

Professor Akhavan warned that if too many countries quit the  whaling commission as a result, there would be no regulation of  whaling.

Japanese government spokesman Noriyuki Shikata later told AAP that Japan was ''not talking about leaving the IWC'', however.

Ad Feedback

Australia's agent, Bill Campbell, QC, said he had expected Tokyo to put its case in a forthright manner.

''Ultimately we get an opportunity to respond and we'll be responding in a forthright manner,'' he told AAP after the hearing.

Campbell didn't want to comment extensively on Tokyo's ''emotive arguments'', but he said the ICJ case was a legal matter involving scientific principles and it should be decided  accordingly.

Japan also disputes the court's jurisdiction to even hear the matter.

Tokyo wants to invoke a reservation relating to disputes concerning ''maritime zones'' because its whaling activity takes place near Antarctic waters claimed by Australia.

- AAP

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content