N Korea execution by dog story was satire

Last updated 12:40 07/01/2014

After claims emerged that North Korean leader Kim Jong Un had his uncle executed by a pack of dogs, the source of the story has now been identified as a Chinese social networking website.

north korean purge
Jang Song Thaek being forcibly removed by uniformed personnel from a meeting of the Political Bureau of the Central Committee of the Workers' Party of Korea.
Kim Jong-un and uncle
North Korean dictator Kim Jong-un, right, and his uncle Jang Song-thaek, in 2012.

Related Links

Rare photos of North Korean 'purge' Why Kim Jong-un's uncle wasn't eaten by dogs Kim Jong Un's aunt dies, but how?

Relevant offers


Russian cruise missiles reportedly miss Syria, land in Iran by accident Thousands of Chinese holidaymakers stuck in 50-lane traffic jam Rising in Japan's workforce: Women Philip Blackwood a prisoner of conscience - Amnesty International China's bizarre 'Window of the World' museum displays 'Maorish' people A death in McDonald's and the rise of Hong Kong's McRefugees Choking Indian capital New Delhi vows pollution tax, car-free days to improve air Former Hong Kong leader Donald Tsang charged with misconduct in public office Villagers hope for luck from buffalo with crocodile-like skin Asian haze set to become worst on record

An international media frenzy over reports that North Korean leader Kim Jong Un's uncle had been executed by throwing him to a pack of dogs appears to have originated as satire on a Chinese microblogging website.

The story, which spread like wildfire after it was picked up by a Hong Kong-based newspaper, has created an image that Pyongyang's young ruler is even more brutal and unpredictable than previously believed.

While North Korea has said it purged and executed Kim's uncle, Jang Song Thaek, last month, it did not release details of how the man who was once the second most powerful figure in the isolated country was killed.

Initial speculation was that Jang had been killed by firing squad, a fate that media outlets said was the usual one reserved for "traitors". But an alternative narrative of the 67-year old's death emerged on what appears to have been a satirical post on the Chinese Tencent Weibo site that has been repeated by many media outlets worldwide.

The December 11 post on Tencent Weibo said Jang and five aides were killed by dogs.

The post records that it was viewed 290,000 times.

The Hong Kong-based Wen Wei Po newspaper released an article and a screenshot of the Weibo post, which it used to justify its report that Jang had been torn apart.

Wen Wei Po, although independent, is viewed as being pro-Beijing. Its report was in turn picked up 12 days later by the Singapore-based Straits Times and then by a wide range of US and European media from print to television.

Kim Jong Un, believed to be around 30 years old, has been in power for two years and presided over a nuclear test and two rocket test launches that are banned under United Nations sanctions.

In 2013, Pyongyang threatened to strike South Korea, the United States and Japan in fiery rhetoric that triggered an arms buildup in East Asia.

One of the pitfalls of reporting on North Korea is that few independent media have offices there and visiting media are tightly controlled in a country which ranks among the lowest in global surveys of press freedom.

Because of the lack of first hand information, many lurid stories about the country gain credence.

Trevor Powell, a Chicago-based software engineer, who first spotted the link to the Weibo post and reported it on his own blog said that analysts and experts were "still all missing the obvious fact that the original source of the Wen Wei Po story was a tweet from a known satirist or someone posing as him/her."

Powell blogged about the post here.

He could not immediately be reached for comment.

Officials at Wen Wei Po declined to comment on the article.

Ad Feedback

- Reuters

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content