NZ meterologist helped D-Day invasion

LSTs (Landing Ship Tanks), landing vehicles, and cargo are pictured on a Normandy beach in this June 1944.
LSTs (Landing Ship Tanks), landing vehicles, and cargo are pictured on a Normandy beach in this June 1944.
American assault troops of the 16th Infantry Regiment, injured while storming Omaha Beach, wait at Chalk Cliffs for evacuation in this photo taken at Collville-sur-Mer, Normandy, France, June 6, 1944.
American assault troops of the 16th Infantry Regiment, injured while storming Omaha Beach, wait at Chalk Cliffs for evacuation in this photo taken at Collville-sur-Mer, Normandy, France, June 6, 1944.
Members of an American landing party lend helping hands to others whose landing craft was sunk by enemy action off the coast of France.  These survivors in the photo reached Utah Beach, near Cherbourg, by using a life raft.
Members of an American landing party lend helping hands to others whose landing craft was sunk by enemy action off the coast of France. These survivors in the photo reached Utah Beach, near Cherbourg, by using a life raft.
General Dwight D Eisenhower gives the order of the day, "full victory - nothing else", to paratroopers in England, just before they board their airplanes to participate in the first assault in the invasion of the continent of Europe in this file photo from June 6, 1944.
General Dwight D Eisenhower gives the order of the day, "full victory - nothing else", to paratroopers in England, just before they board their airplanes to participate in the first assault in the invasion of the continent of Europe in this file photo from June 6, 1944.
An undated file handout photograph shows the flag of the Royal Navy beach party at an unidentified location in Normandy in northern France during Operation Overlord, 1944.
An undated file handout photograph shows the flag of the Royal Navy beach party at an unidentified location in Normandy in northern France during Operation Overlord, 1944.
Landing on the coast of France under heavy Nazi machine gun fire are these American soldiers, shown just as they left the ramp of a Coast Guard landing boat on June 6, 1944.
Landing on the coast of France under heavy Nazi machine gun fire are these American soldiers, shown just as they left the ramp of a Coast Guard landing boat on June 6, 1944.
American paratroopers display a Nazi flag captured in a village assault, shortly after the Normandy landings of June 6, 1944.
American paratroopers display a Nazi flag captured in a village assault, shortly after the Normandy landings of June 6, 1944.
US medical corpsmen give candy to a wounded French child during the D-Day invasion at a beachead dressing station in June 1944.
US medical corpsmen give candy to a wounded French child during the D-Day invasion at a beachead dressing station in June 1944.
US Army soldiers recover the remains of comrades at Omaha Beach, Normandy, France, in this June 6, 1944 handout photo.
US Army soldiers recover the remains of comrades at Omaha Beach, Normandy, France, in this June 6, 1944 handout photo.
A large group of American assault troops take a breather before moving onto the continent.
A large group of American assault troops take a breather before moving onto the continent.
British LCT's line the Normandy shore, each with a barrage balloon designed to discourage enemy air attack in this file photo taken sometime before the D-Day invasion.
British LCT's line the Normandy shore, each with a barrage balloon designed to discourage enemy air attack in this file photo taken sometime before the D-Day invasion.
An aerial view of the French Normandy coast, near Arromanches.
An aerial view of the French Normandy coast, near Arromanches.
British Royal Marine veteran George Amos looks out from a German bunker at Port-en-Bessin Huppain, Normandy, June 7, 2004.  Amos was held prisoner in the bunker, yet later led the surrender of the position to allied forces.
British Royal Marine veteran George Amos looks out from a German bunker at Port-en-Bessin Huppain, Normandy, June 7, 2004. Amos was held prisoner in the bunker, yet later led the surrender of the position to allied forces.
A Canadian veteran sits on Juno beach in Normandy, northern France, for the 60th anniversary of the invasion on June 6, 2004.
A Canadian veteran sits on Juno beach in Normandy, northern France, for the 60th anniversary of the invasion on June 6, 2004.

A New Zealander who was one of only six meteorologists involved in providing weather forecasts for the Allies D-Day landings 70 years ago today has given a striking account of how they nearly got it wrong.

Auckland-born Lawrence Hogben, 98, is only one of two surviving meteorologists from the six man team who advised General Dwight Eisenhower on the weather for the landing.

Writing in the London Review of Books (http://www.lrb.co.uk ) Hogben notes how difficult the forecasting was in 1944 and around Normandy, which was being hit by a storm.

“In 1944 we only just got the most important weather forecast in history right. But we steered the invading army away from a potential disaster at sea and helped to make ultimate victory feasible,” Hogben writes.

He says at the time the D-Day planners assumed meteorologists had total control of the elements. 

“Just name us five fine, calm days and we’ll go.”

Hogben says the six men worked out four possible days in June 1944 but worked out the odds on the weather on any one of these four dates conforming to requirements as being 13 to one against.

“So meteorologically, D-Day was bound to be a gamble against the odds.”

He writes vividly of how the D-Day forecast became a “telephonic affair”: the six forecasters would stay in three separate centres, joined to one another and to Eisenhower’s headquarters by GPO telephones (which worked). 

‘‘A non-forecaster would moderate our debates and then explain our agreed forecast to Ike and his staff. ‘‘

Hogben said the military were astounded to discover that, despite all the scientific expertise simultaneously available on his phone, an agreed forecast never emerged easily, even after hours of discussion.

He was one of two Royal Navy officers part of the six man team: “Geoffrey Wolfe, an urbane Cambridge man from Hove, on the English Channel, who not surprisingly turned out to be quite the most consistent forecaster of the six, and the youngest, myself, a New Zealand Rhodes Scholar and the first ever Naval Instructor to have won a DSC [Distinguished Service Cross] in battle.”

As the weather deteriorated ahead of D-Day, Hogbed says the telephone debates went on furiously if inconclusively. 

“We all agreed that the key depression whose front had caused the postponement would move north-east and threaten no more. But what would it leave behind?”

The gamble they made on a good day paid off.

“Although my naval colleague and I happened to forecast correctly for the two critical days, our forecasts were as much the fruit of our discussions with the others as of any singular ability. The team forecasts saved us, and the invasion.”

Hogben questions whether today’s weather forecasters would do any better.

“They certainly should, with their satellites, computers and weather models. 

“Fifty years ago our only satellites and computers were in our heads and we could find no analogue in our past records for what the Americans afterwards described as ‘a meteorological situation unique in the annals of June weather’,” he says.

“I am sure that in weather like that of May 1944 today’s experts would improve on us, and make reasonable five-day forecasts. But when one type of weather is changing to something radically different, as it did the following month, I am not so sure.”

Now living in France, Hogben says the timing and nature of a total change in the weather continue to pose questions which often are not satisfactorily answered. 

“For shorter periods, the accuracy of today’s forecasts is most impressive.”

Hogben grew up in Auckland and attended Auckland Grammar School. He was the top mathematics graduate of all New Zealand universities and was awarded a Rhodes Scholarship to study at New College Oxford in 1938. 

His studies were interrupted by the outbreak of World War II. 

After training at the Royal Naval College in Greenwich, he served on the cruiser HMS Sheffield as a lieutenant commander. He was a training officer, intelligence officer and meteorologist. 

After over three years at sea, Lawrence was awarded the first DSC ever given to a Royal Navy Instructor Officer.


Stuff