Queen divides Obama, Putin in awkward moment

12:12, Jun 07 2014
Barack Obama, Vladimir Putin, Queen Elizabeth II
CAUGHT ON CAMERA: Laughter erupted in the crowd at Sword Beach when pictures of Barack Obama and Vladimir Putin were projected together on a big screen.
Barack Obama, Vladimir Putin, Queen Elizabeth II
THE LINEUP: Barack Obama and Vladimir Putin were separated in the formal photos by Queen Elizabeth II, French President Francois Hollande and Denmark's Queen Margrethe II.
Barack Obama, Vladimir Putin, Queen Elizabeth II
NERVOUS WAIT: US President Barack Obama knew his Russian counterpart was not far away.
Barack Obama, Vladimir Putin, Queen Elizabeth II
FORMALITIES: World leaders each found a different point of interest in the dining room while French President Francois Hollande gave his speech.
Barack Obama, Vladimir Putin, Queen Elizabeth II
CLOSE ENOUGH TO TOUCH: US President Barack Obama was thought to have slowed his pace when walking behind Russia President Vladimir Putin in an effort to put distance between them.

Add another awkward chapter to the long-running story of the tense relationship of US President Barack Obama and Russian President Vladimir Putin.

This one came complete with a cameo from Britain's Queen Elizabeth II, who became an unexpected buffer between the presidents.

The dignitaries were in France overnight for ceremonies marking the 70th anniversary of the D-Day invasion on the beaches of Normandy.

The commemorations coincided with heightened tensions between the US and Russia over Moscow's threatening moves in Ukraine.

Obama and Putin had a short conversation inside the French chateau where they attended a leaders' lunch, marking the first time they have spoken face-to-face since the Ukraine crisis began.

But a public encounter during a pre-lunch photo highlighted the strain in the relationship, with Obama appearing to go out of his way to avoid contact with Putin despite coming within an arm's length of his Russian counterpart.


Obama was all smiles as the leaders gathered on the steps of the grand Chateau de Benouville for the group photo. 

He took his place in the front row next to Queen Elizabeth and waved and shook hands with other leaders.

But the US leader steadfastly avoided any contact with Putin when the Russian leader took his place about a metre away.

French President Francois Hollande and Denmark's Queen Margrethe II joined the British monarch in serving as a shield between Obama and Putin.

As the photo ended, Obama lingered with Queen Elizabeth while Putin sidled up to Hollande for the short walk to lunch. But the two pairs were soon back to back, with Obama so close to Putin that he could have easily reached out and tapped him on the shoulder.

Instead, Obama continued his conversation with the 88-year-old queen. More than once, he slowed his steps, putting some distance between him and Putin.

No media were on hand for the Obama-Putin conversation inside the chateau, which aides described as informal. But the leaders were quickly back on public display during the day's main event, an elaborate ceremony on Sword Beach.

As Obama and Putin took their seats, the image on the large screens in the outdoor pavilion split into two, with Obama's picture on the left and Putin on the right.

Putin appeared to catch sight of their pictures on the screen first and cracked a smile. Then Obama saw them and grinned, glancing sideways toward the Russian leader as the crowd packing the stands erupted in laughter.

For Obama and Putin, Friday's intense attention was nothing new. The two leaders have never displayed much chemistry, and their face-to-face encounters have come to symbolise the increasingly sour relations between the US and Russia.

During a formal meeting last year on the sidelines of a summit in Northern Ireland, Putin slumped in his chair and sat stone-faced as Obama tried to make a joke about the Russian leader's athletic skills.

When asked later about Putin's body language, Obama compared him to the ''bored kid in the back of the classroom''.

With two-and-a-half years left in Obama's term, there probably would be more awkward encounters with Putin. But the Russian leader would still be in power when Obama left office.

Putin was asked by a French television station earlier this week about Hillary Rodham Clinton, the former secretary of state and possible future presidential candidate.

The Russian leader said Clinton was ''never very subtle in her statements,'' adding that ''people overstep certain barriers of propriety, that doesn't show their strength but their weakness''.


It was a day of pride, remembrance and honours for those who waded through blood-tinged waves, climbed razor-sharp cliffs or fell from the skies, staring down death or dying in an invasion that portended the fall of the Third Reich and the end of World War II.

It was also a day of high diplomacy for a Europe not completely at peace.

After 70 years, a dwindling number of veterans, civilian survivors of the brutal battle for Normandy, and 19 world leaders and monarchs celebrated on Friday the sacrifices of D-Day, an assault never matched for its size, planning and derring-do.

The events spread across the beaches and lush farmlands of Normandy, in western France, had an added sense of urgency this year: It would be the last grand commemoration for many of the veterans, whether they relived the anniversary at home in silence or were among the some 1000 who crossed continents to be present despite their frail age.

For President Barack Obama, transmitting the memory of their ''longest day'' meant keeping intact the values that veterans fought and died for.

''When the war was won, we claimed no spoils of victory - we helped Europe rebuild,'' Obama said in a speech at the Normandy American Cemetery and Memorial.

It was the site where 9387 fallen soldiers rest under white marble tombstones on a bluff above Omaha Beach, the bloodiest among five beach landings by US and British troops. 

''This was democracy's beachhead,'' he said, assuring veterans that ''your legacy is in good hands''.

F-15 jets flew over the cemetery in missing-man formation, a 21 gun salute boomed and taps sounded.

The day of gratitude drew royals including Queen Elizabeth II of England, who dined at the French presidential palace in the evening, and the king of the Netherlands, Willem-Alexander, as well as political leaders from across Europe. German Chancellor Angela Merkel also joined in, along with a small group of German soldiers, as a sign of European unity.

Both symbolism and pragmatism were on French President Francois Hollande's agenda. With an invitation to Russian President Vladimir Putin, who had been elbowed out of G-7 talks a day earlier, the ceremonies also became a moment to try to deflate the tense situation in Ukraine. The West feared the ongoing fighting there could fan a new Cold War with Moscow, which has annexed the eastern Ukraine region of Crimea. 

Hollande's invitation to Ukraine's president-elect gave impetus to a diplomatic ballet of meetings behind the scenes. 

Putin, who was present as a tribute to the Russian loss of more than 20 million troops in WWII - the largest among Allies - met with Petro Poroshenko and Obama on the sidelines of the event. Obama met privately, and briefly, with Putin. 

''It is because France itself experienced the barbarity (of war) that it feels a duty to preserve peace everywhere, at the frontiers of Europe as in Africa,'' Hollande said.

Dancers re-enacted the drama of the Nazi takeover and battles across Europe against Hitler's forces on a stage at Sword Beach, one of the landing points near Ouistreham, a small port where British troops landed and fought their way to Pegasus Bridge, a key route. Ouistreham was the site of the main international ceremony. 

It was 6.30am on June 6, 1944, when soldiers started wading ashore. Operation Overlord, as the invasion by US, British, Canadian and Polish forces was codenamed, was the first step in breaching Hitler's stranglehold on France and Europe. Besides Sword and Omaha, Allied forces landed on Utah, Juno and Gold beaches - all codenames. 

Ahead of the landing, the US Army's 2nd Ranger Battalion went in with the 5th Battalion Rangers, scaling the craggy cliffs of Point du Hoc to put out of action six 155mm Nazi howitzers that could target landing areas. Paratroopers from the 101st Airborne division jumped into dark skies, some getting lost in hedgerows, shot down or caught in trees.

At least 4400 Allied troops were killed the first day, and many thousands more in the ensuing Battle of Normandy that opened the Allied march to Paris to liberate the Nazi-occupied French capital in August. Another August assault was launched by forces from North Africa into southern France.

''They left home barely more than boys. They came home heroes,'' Obama said at an observation deck in Colleville, overlooking Omaha Beach.

Seven decades later, gratitude for life is a theme that runs through some veterans' recollections.

''I was lucky I survived,'' said US veteran Oscar Peterson, 92, who fought with the 2nd Infantry Division, during his visit to Colleville. At the time, he said ''I would say that if I could survive this, I'll work the rest of my life for nothing to be alive''.

Clair Martin, 93, of San Diego, California, landed on D-Day with the 29th Infantry Division and said he kept fighting until he reached the Elbe River in Germany the following April.

''I praise God I made it and that we've never had another World War,'' he said. 

While many of the fallen in the Battle of Normandy - Americans, British, Polish and even Germans - lie in manicured cemeteries, some victims have been largely forgotten - the French.

Allied bombardments killed an estimated 20,000 French civilians, and Hollande paid tribute to them in Caen, largely destroyed in the bombings like many Normandy cities.

The Vichy government which collaborated with the Nazis - and which France took decades to admit represented the state - used the bombings as a propaganda tool, burying the extent of fatalities.

Historians now believe that nearly as many French civilians died in Allied air raids as Britons during the German Blitz. 

''This battle was also a battle of civilians,'' Hollande said. Normandy's residents ''helped the victory happen. They opened their doors to the liberators.''

US veteran Jack Schlegel, 91, of Albany, New York, who fought in the 508th Parachutist Infantry Regiment, 82nd Airborne, paid tribute to those who survived and are transmitting the D-Day message.

''I love, especially in this area, the patriotism I can see, that you're so thankful that the Allies ... helped liberate this country from the Nazis and giving the younger children a chance to grow up without this oppression.''