MH17: possible scenarios - none end well

Last updated 14:11 18/07/2014
MH17 crash site

CRASH SITE: An armed pro-Russian separatist stands on part of the wreckage of the downed Malaysia Airlines Boeing 777 plane.

FIGHTER: A Russian-backed militant poses for a picture atop a T-64 tank in Donetsk a day before the crash.

Relevant offers


Volcano 'explodes' in Alaska, alert level raised Christian-owned bakery loses discrimination ruling over refusal to make 'gay cakes' Man confesses to rape and murder of 4-year-old on live TV Plane crashes on takeoff at Malta airport, five aboard killed British politician John Rees-Evans apologises for claim that a gay donkey tried to rape his stallion Shakespeare's Henry VI co-author finally gets a writing credit, 400 years on France rumbles 'The Jungle': Fear and questions hang over doomed migrant camp Iceland braces for a Pirate Party takeover, as Western politics continues 2016 shake-up Theme park's 'house of horrors' collapses at Ireland's Tayto Park Onlookers dared refugee to jump in Germany

The rebels are suspect number one, but there are other scenarios in the shooting down of Malaysia Airline Flight MH17 above eastern Ukraine that will fuel conspiracies in the conflict. None end well.


Hardline rebels might be trying to force Russian leader Vladimir Putin's hand. The rebels recently declared the "Manifesto of Novorossiya", covering the breakaway region of south-east Ukraine but got little public backing from Moscow. The Kremlin was seen to have cooled on the Ukraine conflict in the face of Western economic sanctions. Perversely, this attack could bolster Russian support for the rebels if only to rein them in tighter. But it would be a huge gamble - and that alone seems to suggest it is improbable.


The Ukraine government has suffered humiliating losses. Rebels shot down a Ukraine military transport last month, killing more than 40 soldiers and the government has promised revenge. The flight to Malaysia might have been mistaken for a Russian aircraft. There is tragic precedent. A US navy ship in the Persian Gulf in 1988 claimed to have mistook Iran Air Flight 655 for a fighter jet and shot it down. The former Soviet Union also destroyed Korean Air Lines Flight 007 in 1983 after the jet was said to have wandered into restricted airspace. But again, the cost of the cover-up to Ukraine in terms of reputation and support makes this scenario unlikely.


Could Russia itself have deliberately precipitated a crisis? The takeover of Crimea in March was preceded by a series of underhand actions, where Russian commandos posed as Ukraine dissidents and seized control of key military installations. Putin is a ruthless character, no doubt, but it is one thing to send agent provocateurs across the border in a neighbourhood quarrel, quite another to deliberately target a commercial airliner with citizens from around the world. Chalk this up as impossible.


The rebel fighters were quick to brag about bringing down the plane - then just as quick to claim they had no involvement once it became clear it was a civilian jet. This appears most likely to be an awful case of mistaken identity. For 298 people, the consequences have been deadly. But the ramifications may cost many more lives yet.

Ad Feedback

- Sydney Morning Herald

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content