E.T. phone Rome

Last updated 11:05 11/11/2009
Pope Benedict XVI
AP
KEEP WATCHING THE SKIES: Pope Benedict XVI and the Vatican are looking at the possibility of extraterrestrial life.

Relevant offers

Europe

Greece surveys riots damage after austerity vote Riots as Greece approves austerity Girl buried in Kosovo avalanche rescued Woman sets herself on fire in Moscow Police arrest five at Murdoch's Sun newspaper Thousands protest in Athens Shock at River Cottage barn blaze Cruise ship disaster captain knew 'it was over' Argentina slams British 'militarisation' Greece strikes bailout deal

Four hundred years after it locked up Galileo for challenging the view that the Earth was the centre of the universe, the Vatican has called in experts to study the possibility of extraterrestrial life.

"The questions of life's origins and of whether life exists elsewhere in the universe are very suitable and deserve serious consideration," said the Rev Jose Gabriel Funes, an astronomer and director of the Vatican Observatory.

Funes, a Jesuit priest, presented the results of a five-day conference that gathered astronomers, physicists, biologists and other experts to discuss the budding field of astrobiology - the study of the origin of life and its existence elsewhere in the cosmos.

Funes said the possibility of alien life raises "many philosophical and theological implications," but added that the gathering was mainly focused on the scientific perspective and how different disciplines can be used to explore the issue.

Chris Impey, an astronomy professor at the University of Arizona, said it was appropriate that the Vatican would host such a meeting.

"Both science and religion posit life as a special outcome of a vast and mostly inhospitable universe," he told a news conference. "There is a rich middle ground for dialogue between the practitioners of astrobiology and those who seek to understand the meaning of our existence in a biological universe."

Thirty scientists, including non-Catholics, from the US, France, Britain, Switzerland, Italy and Chile attended the conference, called to explore among other issues "whether sentient life forms exist on other worlds."

Funes set the stage for the conference a year ago when he discussed the possibility of alien life in an interview given prominence in the Vatican's daily newspaper.

BURNED AT THE STAKE

The Church of Rome's views have shifted radically through the centuries since Italian philosopher Giordano Bruno was burned at the stake as a heretic in 1600 for speculating, among other ideas, that other worlds could be inhabited.

Scientists have discovered hundreds of planets outside our solar system - including 32 new ones announced recently by the European Space Agency. Impey said the discovery of alien life may be only a few years away.

"If biology is not unique to the Earth, or life elsewhere differs bio-chemically from our version, or we ever make contact with an intelligent species in the vastness of space, the implications for our self-image will be profound," he said.

Ad Feedback

This is not the first time the Vatican has explored the issue of extraterrestrials: In 2005, its observatory brought together top researchers in the field for similar discussions.

In an interview last year, Funes told Vatican newspaper L'Osservatore Romano that believing the universe may host aliens, even intelligent ones, does not contradict a faith in God.

"How can we rule out that life may have developed elsewhere?" Funes said in that interview.

"Just as there is a multitude of creatures on Earth, there could be other beings, even intelligent ones, created by God. This does not contradict our faith, because we cannot put limits on God's creative freedom."

Funes maintained that if intelligent beings were discovered, they would also be considered "part of creation."

The Roman Catholic Church's relationship with science has come a long way since Galileo was tried as a heretic in 1633 and forced to recant his finding that the Earth revolves around the sun. Church teaching at the time placed Earth at the centre of the universe.

Today top clergy, including Funes, openly endorse scientific ideas like the Big Bang theory, as a reasonable explanation for the creation of the universe. The theory says the universe began billions of years ago in the explosion of a single, super-dense point that contained all matter.

ORIGIN OF SPECIES

Earlier this year, the Vatican also sponsored a conference on evolution to mark the 150th anniversary of Charles Darwin's "The Origin of Species."

The event snubbed proponents of alternative theories, like creationism and intelligent design, which see a higher being rather than the undirected process of natural selection behind the evolution of species.

Still, there are divisions on the issues within the Catholic Church and within other religions, with some favouring creationism or intelligent design that could make it difficult to accept the concept of alien life.

Working with scientists to explore fundamental questions that are of interest to religion is in line with the teachings of Pope Benedict XVI, who has made strengthening the relationship between faith and reason a key aspect of his papacy.

Recent popes have been working to overcome the accusation that the church was hostile to science - a reputation grounded in the Galileo affair.

In 1992, Pope John Paul II declared the ruling against the astronomer was an error resulting from "tragic mutual incomprehension."

The Vatican Museums opened an exhibit last month marking the 400th anniversary of Galileo's first celestial observations.

Tommaso Maccacaro, president of Italy's national institute of astrophysics, said at the exhibit's October 13 opening that astronomy has had a major impact on the way we perceive ourselves.

"It was astronomical observations that let us understand that Earth (and man) don't have a privileged position or role in the universe," he said.

"I ask myself what tools will we use in the next 400 years, and I ask what revolutions of understanding they'll bring about, like resolving the mystery of our apparent cosmic solitude."

The Vatican Observatory has also been at the forefront of efforts to bridge the gap between religion and science. Its scientist-clerics have generated top-notch research and its meteorite collection is considered one of the world's best.

The observatory, founded by Pope Leo XIII in 1891, is based in Castel Gandolfo, a lakeside town in the hills outside Rome where the pope has his summer residence. It also conducts research at an observatory at the University of Arizona, in Tucson.

- AP

15 comments
Post a comment
Stephen Grove   #15   11:21 am Nov 20 2009

The catholic church capitulates ! - glad i'm not a catholic ! How dumb can you be, not too much theology going on there... If the son of God almighty died on a cross (on earth) Once and for all do you think God is concerned about aliens ? The Church's mission is on earth - NOT IN SPACE !! how many starving children are there in space... umm... hold on... let me guess...

mazza   #14   10:20 am Nov 20 2009

I want to live to see the day we discover other life out there. there has to be when you think about the size of the universe.

Sulli   #13   09:08 am Nov 20 2009

Hans, he said 1 billion people were starving, not in the world!! I can't wait to see what clues to God the Aliens have!! Shouls make for an interesting comparison!!

RG   #12   05:31 pm Nov 11 2009

These are people that pretend crackers are the body of some bloke that died a couple of thousand year ago, and that red wine is his blood, (does eating the pretend body and drinking the pretend blood make them pretend cannibals?) who worship ancient torture devices, and tell their followers they are not allowed contraception, abortions, or the use of condoms to prevent aids. Do they really have a place in science?

Marcus   #11   04:56 pm Nov 11 2009

Mark - I think that the Church accepts very much the existence of contraception and homosexuality. What the Church teaches is that the former should not be used nor should the latter be practised.

Charles - fascinating, that fits in with the CS Lewis trilogy that starts with "Out of the Silent Planet". About men travelling to Mars and interacting with the martians who were also known to and saved by God but in a different way.

MBelf - apostolate is a necessary and integral part of a Christian's life. We are called to salvation and to bring others with us. So yes, the Church is of course always looking for more to convert.

Carl - we are all called by and accepted by the Church, in all our failings. As a gay man, you are most certainly accepted by the Church. Are you accepted as you are? No. No one is, we are all called by Christ to follow him - to be Christlike. We are all sinners and all require constant struggling and God's grace to get to Heaven. So the Church does not accept anyone the way they are - we all need to be constantly striving to improve - hence the constant need for reconciliation/confession for all us, from the Pope downwards. Also, the Church does not reject higher education. Faith and reason are the two "wings" that must sustain each person's "flight" during this life. Finally, no the Church does not make it up as it goes along. It has the deposit of faith that is nigh on two thousand years old that it has a duty to defend. The Church is often forced to defend it from new challenges/heresies/circumstances but the faith itself does not change. May God bless us all.

Hans   #10   04:26 pm Nov 11 2009

Just correcting myself, the Vatican observatory was established in 1774; 1582 was when the Gregorian calendar was promulgated, which itself was based on astronomical data and mathematics.

Hans   #9   04:20 pm Nov 11 2009

To Carl #7

Your post is so historically and factually inaccurate that I don't know where to begin.

If the church persecuted science throughout history, then why was genetics was discovered by a Catholic Monk? Why has the Vatican had an astronomical observatory since 1582? How come Louis Pasteur whose work lies at the foundation of modern medicine was a Catholic? Countless scientists have been devoutly religious throughout history, and even today.

It may also shock you to learn that the Catholic church runs universities, and has a high regard for education, which is at the core of fully understanding scriptures and theology.

P.S. The world has an estimated 6 billion people, not 1 billion

Hans   #8   04:02 pm Nov 11 2009

You're being overly simplistic with your references to Giordano Bruno and Galileo. I don't agree with what happened to either of them, but this isn't the simplistic science vs. religion clash that people make it out to be.

Firstly, Giordano Bruno was NOT executed for his scientific views, but for a whole plethora of theological errors that he was promoting (including stuff like Jesus just being a clever magician). His confrontational manner didn't help him either.

As for Galileo, his one "proof" in support of Copernicus' theory that the earth orbited the sun (now known as fact) was based on the tides, and was invalid. In the scientific world, this is as good as being wrong altogether, and didn't help his case.

His next problem was that he crossed the boundary between science and religion, and tried to change the existing interpretation of the bible to suit an as yet unproven theory. Since he was a Catholic, that was understandable, but a cause of friction. Finally he unwittingly insulted the pope in one of his publications, which triggered a series of events that was an embarrassment to all involved.

Yes, he was right (but for the wrong reasons), and the clergy responsible for the rulings were in error, but he was declaring as true a theory that was, as yet, unproven. That's a far cry from modern portrayal that the church was suppressing irrefutable science for the sake of doctrine. Oh, and whilst Galileo was put under house arrest, he was never locked up in a cell (unless you call a nice apartment a prison cell).

Carl   #7   02:57 pm Nov 11 2009

Oh this is a joke. As a gay man who is not accepted by needy religious people who seek to breed us into extinction (1 billion people can’t afford to feed them selves, let’s breed more! GOOD THINKING!) I say the church with is numb, insecure, fact rejecting followers have no place in the realm of science which they have persecuted through out history. I thought they rejected higher education anyway! making the rules up as you go along?. Take your control mechanism and Go away!!

Jim   #6   12:35 pm Nov 11 2009

It would be a pretty dull universe if we're the most intelligent species in it.

I hope to live to see the discovery of alien life - even if it is only single cell organisms.

The universe is vast and something like half of the billions of stars out there have planets orbiting them, so there's likely to be many other places where life could have developed.


Show 1-5 of 15 comments

Post comment


Required

Required. Will not be published.
Registration is not required to post a comment but if you , you will not have to enter your details each time you comment. Registered members also have access to extra features. Create an account now.


Maximum of 1750 characters (about 300 words)

I have read and accepted the terms and conditions
These comments are moderated. Your comment, if approved, may not appear immediately. Please direct any queries about comment moderation to the Opinion Editor at blogs@stuff.co.nz
Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content