Crimea and punishment

Last updated 08:29 04/03/2014

Related Links

Live updates: Ukraine crisis US takes swing, Russia ups pressure Full coverage

Relevant offers


Hitler's older brother was in fact younger and died early, historian says Italian student burned alive by ex-boyfriend, police say British PM David Cameron faces revolt from Conservative MPs on Brexit Oh my Spaghetti! - German Pastafarians hold 'noodle worship' Hitler's secret coding machine sold on eBay for $21 Quiz: Are you a right royalist, or not? UK cancer researchers' retirement funds invested in tobacco industry German terrorists on the run for 30 years linked to brutal armed robberies 700 migrants feared dead in Mediterranean shipwrecks: UN Seventeen killed in Ukraine rest home fire

With events in Ukraine changing so quickly, it is impossible to predict what will happen next. But now that the Russian parliament has rubber-stamped Russian President Vladimir Putin's request to invade the country, a few observations are already in order.

What seems to have happened in the Crimea so far is a grotesque imitation of the Maidan protests that ousted former Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych from office. Under the cover of some street protesters, masked self-defence forces with the help of Ukrainian Berkut — evidently including units responsible for the crackdown in Kiev — captured government buildings to force a political decision to recognise Yanukovych as the president of Ukraine. Armed gunmen without identifying insignia captured two airports (as well as a centre for investigative journalism), disrupted communications with the mainland and have been blocking some Ukrainian military bases on the peninsula. Last weekend, the Crimean government then requested Russia's help, as did Yanukovych, who is now obviously Putin's puppet. That then let Putin plausibly deny his actions as an invasion, casting it instead as an internal Ukrainian affair. No shots have been fired, yet.

If the plan is to install Yanukovych in a Russian-controlled Crimean mini-state, it might work, for a while. But that does not mean it will be easy. Putin's imperialist gambit may turn out to be his Waterloo.

To see why, just open a map. That narrow strip of land tethering northern Crimea to the Ukrainian mainland, called the Perokop Isthmus, is the peninsula's lifeline. What's left out of most Western analyses of Putin's brazen military intervention is the Crimea's complete economic dependence on the mainland, which provides nearly all of its electricity and water and about 70 per cent of its food.

That's why the Crimea is even a part of Ukraine. Don't believe that myth about the peninsula being a "gift" from Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev to what was then the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1954. For laughs, people often add that he did it when he was drunk. That story was actually concocted during the early 1990s, when Russia first started making mischief with pro-Russian separatism.

Then, the movement had genuine public support because the collapse of the Soviet Union left a disgruntled Russian majority on the peninsula, including many military retirees for whom Crimea was like a Soviet Florida. But the only reason that Crimea had a Russian majority was because Joseph Stalin deported the native Crimean Tatars en masse to Central Asia after World War II and resettled Russians to replace them.

Ad Feedback

Crimea suffered terribly during the war. Its transfer from the Russian Soviet republic to the Ukrainian one made little substantive difference in the totalitarian Communist state. But it was a completely sober decision for Ukraine to take over the peninsula's rebuilding since Moscow was too far away and was mucking the whole thing up. The Russians that Stalin sent (usually not willingly) came mostly from forested regions. They knew nothing about agriculture in the dry Crimean steppes that are a natural extension of southern Ukraine.

Most of the Crimea is basically a desert, with less annual rainfall than Los Angeles. It is impossible to sustain its 2 million people — including agriculture and the substantial tourist industry — without Ukrainian water. Current supplies aren't even enough. In Sevastopol, home of the Black Sea Fleet, households get water only on certain days. In fact, on February 19, when snipers were shooting protesters on the streets of Kiev, Sevastopol applied for US$34 million (NZ$40.63m)  in Western aid (note the irony) to improve its water and sewer systems.

The Crimea's dependence on Ukraine for nearly all of it electricity makes it equally vulnerable to non-violent retaliation. One suggestion making the rounds of the Ukrainian Internet is that the mainland, with warning, shut off the power for 15 minutes. It may not normalise the situation, but it could give Moscow pause. Of course, Russia could retaliate by cutting off Ukrainian gas supplies, but that would mean cutting off much of Europe as well. Besides, Ukrainians proved this winter that they aren't afraid of the cold, and spring is coming.

So, while Vladimir Putin rattles his sabres, the authorities in Kiev might decide to just hold tight, for now. If Yanukovych destroyed his own power, he may very well destroy Putin's as well. The fugitive ex-president, whose greed extended deep into the peninsula, isn't a popular figure there either and any efforts to install him — especially if they bring real hardship to the locals — may spark a Maidan II.

That's because the Crimea has changed since the 1990s. After independence, Ukraine welcomed back the Crimean Tatars. Some 300,000 have returned from exile and their numbers are growing, with continued migration and birth rates higher than either Russians or Ukrainians. They strongly oppose any separatism, and they will not go peacefully into a Russian-controlled, authoritarian "Yanukistan" along the lines of Transdnistria. Not only are they extremely well organised, they are Muslims with friends. Representatives from Russia's Tatarstan region are already supporting them. Turkey, which controlled the Crimea for much longer than Russia ever did and has close ties with the Crimean Tatars, is watching. So are Chechen rebels.

The Crimea could explode into bloodshed. To prevent if from happening, maybe turning off the power for 15 minutes will force a reboot in Putin's aggressive, misguided and ultimately doomed scheme.

* Mary Mycio is a Slate contributor. Her most recent book is Doing Bizness: A Nuclear Thriller, about Ukraine's nuclear disarmament in the 1990s.

- Slate

Special offers

Featured Promotions

Sponsored Content