Fears that new Wellington waterfront building will exceed height restrictions
Concerns have been raised about the height of a proposed new building on Wellington's waterfront, which appears to be at odds with an Environment Court ruling.
An area of the waterfront alongside Customhouse Quay, known as Site 9, has been earmarked by developer Willis Bond & Co for a new five-storey office block that would be 21 metres high.
But according to an Environment Court ruling in 2012, the maximum height of a building on that site should be 19m, sloping to 16m.
Willis Bond secured a first right of refusal on Wellington City Council-owned site in 2014 as it worked on plans for the adjoining Site 10, which has since become the PwC Centre development.
* New waterfront development planned on Site 9 - but land price withheld from ratepayers
* Willis Bond & Co's multimillion-dollar Kumutoto building said to sell for $90m
* Kumutoto development on Wellington waterfront gets green light
It took years of debate and court proceedings before plans were approved for the Site 10 development and a similar wrangling is expected for Site 9.
The proposed new building would be used for commercial office space, serviced apartments or a boutique hotel.
Public consultation documents say the building is "generally in scale" with neighbouring premises.
"It would be smaller in scale than the buildings to the north and would transition down to the smaller heritage sheds to the south."
But Wellington Civic Trust chairman Jim McMahon had significant concerns about the height.
"The Environment Court was explicit in stating the maximum height of any building, including rooftop plant and structures, should be 19 metres above mean sea level for the northern half of the site and 16 metres above mean sea level to the south."
The trust was also concerned the proposed building would be overbearing in its relationship to Shed 13 and would create an imposing visual barrier, which was in breach of the District Plan, he said.
Site 9 is across the street from 20 Customhouse Quay, which is currently under construction and is being managed by Newcrest, which is opposing current proposal.
Newcrest development director Lincoln Fraser said the proposed Site 9 building was significantly higher than the Environment Court had determined and would overwhelm Shed 13. It also contradicted the District Plan by intruding into two protected view shafts.
"It exceeds the maximum heights by more than eight metres in some areas," Fraser said.
"It would obstruct the views of the waterfront from properties we own and neighbouring buildings, robbing them of valuable views ... leading to a drop in building values."
Waterfront Watch president Victor Davie was concerned that the purpose of the proposed building has not been disclosed.
"This is highly likely to become yet another office building on prime waterfront land," he said.
"Until the construction of Willis Bond's large office building on adjacent Site 10 is completed, and its impact on the Waterfront assessed, it would be irresponsible to proceed any further with this current proposal."
RJH, a company owned by Sir Bob Jones, is also opposing the development.
"The height restriction is there for a reason and has got to be adhered to," Jones said.
Public consultation closed on Friday and Wellington City Council received about 100 submissions.