Family of Gloriavale teen Prayer Ready ask for an inquest

Stuff Circuit

The death of 14-year-old Prayer Ready in the Gloriavale community was kept secret.

Family members of a teenage girl with Down Syndrome who died in strange circumstances at Gloriavale have asked the Solicitor-General to order an inquest into her death.

Prayer Ready, 14, was the focus of a Stuff Circuit investigation in 2016 into her death from asphyxiation after she choked on a piece of meat, while in an isolation room on which the door handles had been disabled.

Stuff Circuit has learned police have contacted the family to ask fresh questions about the events on that night.

Coroner Marcus Elliott did not hold an inquest, but did visit the isolated Christian community to investigate.

READ MORE:
* Gloriavale patriarch Hopeful Christian's troubling legacy
Gloriavale will implode - the only question is when
Hopeful Christian dies: What now for Gloriavale?

In his findings, he said, "Prayer was a much loved member of the Gloriavale community. Her death was a tragic accident. It did not result from any want of care on the part of her family or Gloriavale."

Prayer Ready was 14 when she died.
SUPPLIED

Prayer Ready was 14 when she died.

But, dissatisfied with that outcome, members of Prayer's family - her aunt Ruth Green, her sister Connie Ready and her brother David Ready - have written to Solicitor-General Una Jagose asking that an inquest be ordered under the Coroner's Act, which allows for further inquiry if there's sufficient reason.

Coroner Elliott was shown the isolation room where Prayer had died, and concluded, "The handle of the door to the room in which Prayer died was disabled. This meant it was not possible to enter or exit through the door at the time. However a window in the room provided a point of access through which a number of people came to attempt to assist Prayer when she was choking. The fact that the door was disabled did not contribute to her death in any way."

In the letter, Ruth Green wrote, "After the Coroner's visit, my sister Sharon Ready [Prayer's mother] and I had a conversation in which she shared with me the manipulation of testimonies given to the Coroner about the facts that led to her daughter's death."

Green also told Stuff Circuit that "not only was Prayer's death avoidable, any responsibility for the leaders' decisions that contributed to her death, was covered up."

Ad Feedback

A second Stuff Circuit investigation last year revealed the concerns of Prayer's siblings that the leaders of Gloriavale had manipulated the Coroner into believing the disabled door handles played no part in Prayer's death.

Connie Ready, now living outside the community, said, "Right outside that door is the central telephone system. You can't tell me… you can't… that it was just as easy to jump out the window, run around the verandah, into the hostel to get to the telephone, when you could [have just opened] the door, and it's right there.

"My mum said to me, as soon as Prayer started choking her first reaction was to go for the telephone, or open the door and call out, because everyone lives right there, call out for some help, but she couldn't do that."

When helpers did come, they had to climb in and out through the window.

An elder brother, David Ready, who was a first responder to the emergency, said a meeting was called by the leaders in advance of the coroner's visit to Gloriavale.

The purpose, he said, was to "sort out what we're going to tell the coroner."

And he says on the morning the coroner visited Gloriavale, "[the leaders] got the whole family together to make sure everyone was going to toe the line."

Asked whether he felt he could tell the coroner the truth: "I didn't even get an opportunity to talk with him.

"[The leaders] did most of the talking, they just totally dominated the situation, even though they weren't there when Prayer died."


Prayer Ready and her mother, Sharon Ready, photographed shortly before Prayer died. (SUPPLIED)

In the letter to the Solicitor-General, Green said, [My sister] told me…. she made every attempt to tell the Coroner that what she was saying to him, was what the leaders had told her to say.

"I believe the leaders at Gloriavale manipulated the Coroner because there were multiple aspects they didn't want him to hear.

"To achieve justice for Prayer, and a fair finding as to the reasons for her death, I firmly believe there needs to be an inquest at which all witnesses are able to speak freely."

A spokesperson for Crown Law wouldn't confirm the letter had been received or whether any action was being taken.

Normally, however, the Solicitor-General would make the decision based on a review of what had happened and information from police and the Coroner, the spokesperson said.

Since 2011, there had been 60 such requests. Five had led to calls for new or further inquiries.

Meanwhile, Connie Ready says she was contacted by the police about the statements she made to Stuff Circuit in False Witness, with a summary of questions on behalf of the Coroner.

She said she has since met with them and was given the opportunity to clarify the events leading up to what happened on the night her sister Prayer died, and what happened surrounding the visit from the coroner.

Connie Ready said she was also able to point out what she believes was wrong in the Coroner's report.

Stuff Circuit sought copies of statements given to police by Gloriavale community members on the night Prayer died, but police refused to hand them over, citing, in part, Prayer's privacy.

Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier upheld the decision, saying that "publication of the Coroner's findings containing the pertinent information gathered by police during their [initial] investigation" had satisfied the public interest in the case.

* Stuff Circuit is a team producing video­-led, quality long­form journalism for Stuff. The team of Paula Penfold, Toby Longbottom, Phil Johnson and Eugene Bingham have a background in high-­profile investigative stories.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Plea to remove meth pipes from $2 shops

Jahlee, Wiremu Keretene, Kak Wikaira and Erana Paraone want drug utensils removed from local budget stores.

A Far North couple are calling on local retailers to ban smoking instruments they say are being used to consume meth.

Rodney photographers snap up top placings

Laura's "Safer Communities Together" image.

Rodney photographers share their story telling images of Auckland.

Fight against extradition

Kyung Yup Kim left Shanghai before the body of  Peiyun Chen was found. (File photo)

Kyung Yup Kim denies killing anyone but has already spent five years in prison fighting extradition.

Media personality in court

A media personality has appeared in the North Shore District Court.

The man, who is charged with three counts of assault, appeared in an Auckland court today.

Wellington

Circular economy recycling's future

Recycling firm Method is owned by Steven and India Korner.

These Kiwi companies are trying to find solutions to the complexity of recycling.

Will DHBs dig deep? video

Nurses walked off the job for 24 hours across the country last week.

Nurses want more investment, but Govt says there's no more money. Will the impasse be resolved?

Fight against extradition

Kyung Yup Kim left Shanghai before the body of  Peiyun Chen was found. (File photo)

Kyung Yup Kim denies killing anyone but has already spent five years in prison fighting extradition.

Capital adjusting to bus network

Things went a bit more "smoothly" for Wellington's new bus network on Tuesday, according to the regional council.

Late and cancelled buses continue to hamper Wellington, but things are on the improve.

Canterbury

Carbs cut to tackle diabetes

Mike Harry follows a low-carb, high-protein diet to help manage his Type 1 diabetes. A device attached to his upper arm ...

Mike Harry's daily breakfast? Three eggs, six rashers of bacon and half an avocado. 

Armed police callout

A police spokesman says officers are attending an "event" at an address on Marshland Rd, Christchurch. (File photo).

Armed police have surrounded a house on the outskirts of Christchurch.

Snooping activists?

Alpaca farmers Jacob and Ineke Van Neuren say they love their animals and take good care of them.

Canterbury alpaca farmers are worried they are being targeted by animal rights activists.

Councils could lose water control

Local Government Minister Nanaia Mahuta is exploring whether dedicated providers should take over water management.

Govt signals big changes to who looks after NZ's drinking water - and how.

Waikato

Tractor crash stops traffic

The tractor appeared to be carrying a bale of silage at the time.

Drivers of a car and silage-carrying tractor both escaped uninjured after colliding in Hamilton.

Deaths gang slayings

Robert Nelson died on Sunday, July 8, in what Hamilton police called a "targeted" shooting.

Police have confirmed three homicides in Waikato are linked to the gang community.

Loaded gun at cop charge denied

Leon Colin Wilson, 49, appeared in the Hamilton District Court on Tuesday.

Leon Colin Wilson, 49, was arrested in an operation by armed police that shut down parts of Pukete.

Microwave fire in boarding house

The microwave caught fire while the occupants cooked breakfast at a boarding house in Thames (file photo).

One person treated for smoke inhalation after microwave fire torched Thames kitchen.

Bay Of Plenty

Toxic gas company gets warning

Genera staff vent methyl bromide after a fumigation at the port of Tauranga.

Warnings issued to fumigation company after four Port of Tauranga workers ended up in hospital.

Calls for Mudtopia audit

The Mudtopia Festival continues to make a splash, for all the wrong reasons.

The festival is gone, but the controversy around Mudtopia continues to stick.

Fine for gas leak

The fact the gas leak from the Ballance Agri-Nutrients plant did not affect more people was down to luck, said Judge ...

Company fined $82,500 for gas leak that left two in hospital.

Ngatai back where it all began

Charlie Ngatai is back at Westpac Stadium on Friday, where he made his Super Rugby debut and where he hopes he won't be ...

His Super Rugby debut was at Westpac Stadium against the Chiefs, now he's hoping it doesn't end there with them.

Taranaki

Costs of parking plaques revealed

Plastic plaques displaying each parking bay's four-digit number are replacing the painted numbers currently on kerbs.

The plaques replace the parking bay numbers painted on the kerb edges.

Wood used as weapon

A woman who struck her partner 10 times with a piece of wood pleaded guilty to the assault at Monday's hearing  in the ...

After violently assaulting her partner, she told officers she was fed up and just "snapped".

Gas leak sickens staff

Five New Plymouth office staff were hospitalised with carbon monoxide poisoning after a gas leak in July.

Faulty generator blamed for the hospitalisation of five New Plymouth office staff with carbon monoxide poisoning.

Orchids stolen from honesty shop

Continual thefts will be the death of roadside shops, Bricknall says.

"We're just trying to keep the tradition of the honesty box going."

Manawatu

Broken leg won't stop him

Palmerston North Boys' High School first XI football striker Jaeden Shaw toured the United States with the New Zealand ...

Palmerston North Boys' High School first XI football captain hopes to return to the US.

Council claim dodged

The Palmerston North City Council and developer Les Fugle have a history of courtroom battles (file photo).

A 70-square-metre strip was in the way of a new subdivision and Les Fugle wouldn't give it up cheap.

Crash zone upgraded

Garden of York staff members Rebecca Taiaroa, left, and Sorida Valino, where the road is about to be upgraded

Notorious crash spot to get safety improvements, three years after authorities petitioned.

Attacks on free speech

Donald Trump's "fake news" cries are far from the only threats to who says what.

OPINION: Trump's "fake news" cries are far from the only threats over who says what.

Nelson

Call-block trial popular

06092017 News Photo : Scott Hammond/ STUFF 
Phone scam
Brenda Deavin
Picton

Almost 90 potential trialists step up to test 25 call-blocking units in nationwide test.

Man dies at river

Emergency services at the scene where a man died in the Maitai River on Tuesday morning.

Passersby pulled a man from Nelson's Maitai River but despite resuscitation efforts he later died.

Dead tramper named

Mt Robert, in the Nelson Lakes National Park, has a number of popular walking tracks. A tramper died on the Mt Robert ...

The tourist who died while tramping in Nelson Lakes National Park has been named.

Family stuck in Nelson

A Blenheim family were told that they needed to stay in Nelson for an extra week in case of complications after surgery.

A Blenheim toddler's family are frustrated Nelson Hospital did not say they would have to stay in Nelson for a week.

Marlborough

Three appear after meth raid

An armed offenders squad and dogs raid a property on High St, in Blenheim, on July 4.

A man and two women arrested after a raid targeting a suspected meth-dealing network in Blenheim.

Drink-driver flees

A drink-driver has been spotted doing skids outside a school at Spring Creek, north of Blenheim. (File photo)

Drink-driver doing skids outside a primary school while five times the limit sprints across field to avoid arrest.

Drink-driver snoozes on burger run

Police found Dirk Van Der Torre, 28, asleep behind the wheel, parked up at the Blenheim Railway Station.

A repeat drink-driver found asleep behind the wheel of a running car says he is ready for rehab - again.

Military man's continental drift

Flight Sergeant Nathan Hodges was posted in the Middle East as part of a Zealand Defence Force detachment.

He joined the military to see the world and with just one continent left to visit, Flight Sergeant Nathan Hodges has almost achieved his goal.

South Canterbury

Farmer confronts 'visitors'

Alpaca farmers Jacob and Ineke Van Neuren say they love their animals and take good care of them.

South Canterbury alpaca farmers worried they are being targeted by animal rights activists.

'Hijinks' investigated

Waitaki Boys' High School perform the haka in their annual blood match with St. Kevin's College in 2017. Police are ...

Police now investigating July 4 incident where a Oamaru school pupil was run over.

Rugby ref allegedly assaulted

A 34-year-old Oamaru rugby referee was allegedly assaulted by a 20-year-old spectator at a match between Old Boys and ...

Oamaru charged with assault following a sideline incident with a rugby referee.

More drink drivers

In the past three weekends, South Canterbury police have made 14 drink driving arrests.

South Canterbury police disappointed as several more motorists caught drink driving.

Otago

Fans queue for Kendrick Lamar

Kendrick Lamar performing in Canada in 2017.

Hip hop star's touchdown in Dunedin preceded by two Boeing 737s - one with gear, the other with entourage.

Dunedin dairy robbed

Police were called to the Elgin Food Market about 8.40pm on Monday. (File photo).

The armed robbers took tobacco, cigarettes, chocolate bars and chewing gum.

Rugby coaches must speak up

Acting Sunwolves coach Tony Brown has never been afraid to say it how it is.

OPINION: Rugby needs fewer 'yes men' and more Tony Browns and Brad Thorns, writes Robert van Royen.

Goat pie comment hard to swallow

Police were kept busy with alcohol-fuelled behaviour in Queenstown on the weekend.

A taxi driver was assaulted after refusing to let a man eat pizza, while another man was hit in an argument over goat pie during a weekend of alcohol-fuelled bad behaviour.

Southland

Helping needy children

Jane Laurie and fellow volunteers in Fountain of Peace NZ are giving hope and care to vulnerable children in Uganda.

A Southland woman is helping to give children in Uganda a better quality of life.

Scout wins award

AJ Matheson is looking forward to receiving the Queen's Scout Award from the governor general Patsy Reddy later this year.

AJ Matheson, a student at SIT in Invercargill, will soon receive the Queen's Scout Award from governor general Patsy Reddy.

Wallace Group extends operations

Chief executive Graham Shortland, of Wallace Group.

Agricultural recyclers Wallace Group has spent $200,000 setting up a new site in Southland.

Southland best young farmer region

Otago/Southland Young Farmers chairman Allen Gregory.

Otago/Southland has beat out six Young Farmer groups to take out for the award for the country's best region.

Ad Feedback