Iwi gets behind $200m roading project despite ongoing internal division

A visual representation of the proposed upgrade at Mt Messenger along State Highway 3 in Taranaki. (File Photo)
SIMON O'CONNOR/STUFF

A visual representation of the proposed upgrade at Mt Messenger along State Highway 3 in Taranaki. (File Photo)

A Taranaki iwi has given its support to a $200 million roading upgrade, but not all its members are happy.

Te Rūnanga o Ngāti Tama was once neutral about its view of New Zealand Transport Agency's (NZTA) plans to upgrade State Highway 3 at Mt Messenger, but its had a change of heart and given the project the green light.

The proposed bypass cuts through land known as Parininihi, which is owned by Ngāti Tama. The whenua (land) had been confiscated by the Crown but later returned as part of its 2003 Treaty of Waitangi settlement.

But the "fractured" relationships within the north Taranaki iwi were once again laid bare at a resource consent hearing connected to the proposal on Thursday.

Members of Te Korowai Tiaki o te Hauāuru provided evidence to independent commissioner Stephen Daysh, which voiced their opposition to the work along with their concern about being left out of the consultation process.

READ MORE:
* Proposed Mt Messenger bypass route has support of trucking companies
The $200m State Highway upgrade that split an iwi
* Iwi close to agreement on cash and compo package connected to $200m roading project

The rūnanga is the post-settlement governance entity for Ngāti Tama and is considered to be its mandated voice in terms of consultation involving major developments.

But Rob Enright, counsel for Te Korowai, questioned NZTA's reliance on getting support for the project from the rūnanga, at the expense of other affected Māori.

He said Te Korowai had a membership of 500 people, who all had whakapapa to Ngāti Tama. 

"The key point I make here is that hapū have a right to be heard and tangata whenua have a right to be heard," he said.

Ad Feedback

"The sign-off from the iwi authority is not enough."

Bill White, a Te Korowai member, slammed NZTA's lack of consultation with the group. 

He said as the proposal stood, there was a risk the land that had been returned to it would be lost, despite any compensation provided.

As part of Ngāti Tama's negotiations with NZTA an agreement is on the table, which includes a land swap involving a 120 hectare section, a cash payment and environmental mitigation measures.

Bill White said Ngāti Tama had already lost too much through historical land confiscation.

"The Crown stole the Rolls Royce and gave back the tow bar," he said.

Te Korowai chairman Amos White endorsed what his brother Bill had said about the lack of contact from NZTA.

"We expected a wider and more open consultation process with hapū and iwi from our treaty partners."

Planner Greg Carlyon, who provided expert evidence for Te Korowai, said there was a growing trend that consultation involved moving beyond just talking to one group.

In his questioning of Carlyon, Daysh described the relationships within Ngāti Tama as "fractured" and pointed out the difficulties this could have presented to NZTA.

However, Daysh pointed out there was enough time for further discussion between the rūnanga and Te Korowai to take place, something he encouraged them to do.

The resource consent hearing has now been adjourned until October 8.

 - Stuff

Ad Feedback
special offers
Auckland

Forty years on the front line

Patricia Prchal, 79, has been a social worker for 40 years, and is showing no signs of stopping any time soon.

The faces and cases you meet as a social worker stay with you, even if you've been in the game for decades.

Farm animals need homes

SPCA Auckland needs willing foster parents for its growing population of farm animals.

There's no more room on the farm at SPCA Auckland.

$35K for fibre in city suburb

Areas selected to receive fibre under the Government's UFB rollout were based on population size and density.

She lives just 15 minutes from a major business district, but an Aucklander with a home office was told getting fibre would cost $35k.

America's Cup given go-ahead

AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND - JULY 06:  Members of Emirates Team New Zealand lift the America's Cup trophy in celebration ...

America's Cup 2021 has been given the green light, with the Environment Court approving Auckland waterfront revamp.

Wellington

Contraception cost barrier

The Mirena is a popular and effective contraceptive option but it's $340 price tag has been found to be cost-prohibitive ...

Research doctor wants Pharmac to subsidise "highly effective" contraception for women who can't afford it.

From PM to Sir Bill video

Sir Bill English with family, from left,  sister Anne Seabrook, son Xavier English, wife Lady Mary English, son Bart ...

Pizza is on the menu for Bill English's first night as Sir Bill, but thankfully he's not doing the cooking.

Minister backs litter campaign

Conservation Minister Eugenie Sage is a supporter of Stuff's Litter by Little campaign. "We  have a strong culture of ...

"We have a strong culture of doing the right thing," says Eugenie Sage.

9 tonnes of produce a week

Long-time volunteer Jean Creelman, 70, sorts oranges beside first-timer Emily Chalk.

An idea planted in a humble Porirua community has grown into the biggest fruit and vege co-op of its type in the country.

Canterbury

Man loses $320k in bitcoin scam

The scam started when the man came across a website dealing in bitcoin.

It started with a $250 "investment". A year later, he'd lost his life savings.

Killed by teen with tragic past

Pierclaudio Raviola was found with serious head injuries in a car park near Sumner on March 23, 2017. He died in ...

Pierclaudio Raviola's killer, Moses Hurrell, first drank alcohol at age 7. By age 16, he was a drug-addicted killer.

Review: Miro, Christchurch

Miro is a stylish and cosy spot for breakfast, lunch or brunch any day of the week.

REVIEW: It's hard to hate cold Monday mornings when they start with waffles and coffee by an open fire.

Artwork comes home after global trip

Christchurch artist Nathan Pohio is pleased to bring his artwork home.

The photograph was taken in 1905, reborn in 2015, and now is returning home.

Waikato

Quake swarms near Lake Taupō

A map showing the locations of the swarm of quakes that occurred near Lake Taupo.

A swarm of 28 earthquakes has hit near Taupō, but the country's quake experts say you can breathe easy.

Adams' fertility journey

Dame Valerie Adams  is sharing her fertility story as part of Fertility week

Dame Valerie Adams hopes her story inspires others to seek fertility help.

Fatal scooter crash

A woman died after her scooter and a car crashed at a Rotorua intersection.

A woman died in Rotorua after a crash involving a scooter and a car.

City council eyes 'area of interest'

Development on land just outside Hamilton could have a big impact on Hamilton City Council, councillors heard (file photo).

Hamilton's growing, and wants more say on land that might become part of the city in future.

northland

Arrest after Northland carjacking

The alleged incident happened in Northland on September 21.

A 17-year-old boy has been charged following an alleged carjacking in which an 82-year-old man was injured.

Cancer test wait excessive

A second gastroenterologist has recently been employed to help pick up the waiting time rate.

A lack of specialists and facilities is being blamed on the long waiting time for bowel cancer tests in Northland.

'We're not just hicks in the country'

Expansion is already underway in Dargaville, Moerewa, Ruakaka and Kerikeri.

"We're not just hicks out in the country". Kohukohu residents just want fast broadband like the rest of New Zealand.

Rare dolphin found dead on beach

The Risso's  dolphin found on Ripiro Beach near Pouto,

A rarely sighted Risso's dolphin was discovered washed ashore on Dargaville's west coast.

Bay Of Plenty

Appeal for information after assault

Tauranga Police are looking for Joel Ross Matiu after an assault in Parkvale on September 15.

Tauranga police are looking for a man in connection to a serious assault in Parkvale on September 15. 

Suburb's bus blacklist broken

Rotorua's Cityride bus services have axed their Fordlands route after a driver was attacked.

Buses are back in a troubled Rotorua suburb but only with help to keep drivers safe.

Two helicopter rescues on Saturday

A 65-year-old man suffered chest injuries after falling from his horse.

Two accident victims flown by rescue helicopter to Tauranga and Waikato hospitals.

Law not kept pace with rental reality, says MP

Labour MP Tamati Coffey said the meeting would be about proposed changes to New Zealand's tenancy laws.

Bay of Plenty MPs to host meeting about rental law changes.

Taranaki

Alleged assault following hack

Daniel Shaun Clout is on trial at New Plymouth District Court for aggravated assault on police, resisting police and ...

He locked himself in his bedroom when police tried to arrest him for breaching a protection order.

Mt Taranaki gets snow dump

The Plateau car park on Mt Taranaki was covered in snow on Tuesday morning after a heavy dump overnight.

A spring snow dump has Taranaki skiers excited about the prospect of one more run this season.

TB case at Fonterra

The infected person works at Fonterra's Collingwood St operation in Eltham.

A worker at a Fonterra plant in Taranaki has been diagnosed with TB and other staff have been tested for the disease.

Hospital deemed earthquake prone

After being reviewed by three engineering firms, a number of buildings have been deemed earthquake prone at Taranaki ...

Five buildings - including the maternity ward - will stay open and occupied despite not meeting earthquake standards.

Manawatu

Staying silent only makes the grieving worse

So much of the infertility journey is grieving the life you thought you were going to have (file photo).

OPINION: Shame has no place for people on an infertility journey, writes Greer Berry.

One critically injured in Pahīatua Track crash

The Pahīatua Track has reopened, over four hours after a crash that critically injured one person.

A car and truck have collided on the Manawatū Gorge alternative route.

Brash 'astonished' at university stance

A Don Brash speaking event at Massey University was cancelled, igniting a debate about free speech.

Massey top brass backs under-fire vice-chancellor in row over free speech, much to the chagrin of man at the centre of the controversy.

Signs no welcome to city

Phil Andrews, Design lecturer at UCOL School of Photography and Design, cast a critical eye over the 2016 crop of ...

Sign farms have been deemed visual clutter not fit for Palmerston North city entrances.

Nelson

Nomad putting cart before horse

Lewis Stanton aka Hone Ma Heke works on the construction of his new cart.

He still has no horse, but former Nelson street protester Lewis Stanton's cart is taking shape as he prepares to resume his nomadic lifestyle.

Plastic tickets rubbished

Nelson Intermediate students Lachlan Vavasour, left and Jordan Kelso with Oliver Brown, top left and Taylor Ryan with ...

Plastic parking tickets are being replaced with paper in an environmental win for campaigning students.

Hair to the throne video

Thompson with the trophy he's earned with four years' beard growth.

Shane Thompson's facial hair attracts looks and comments. Now it's earned him top place at a national beard competition.

Golden at the end of the Rainbow

Rainbow Skifield staff member Thomas Salaskastilio, left, with Rainbow general manager James Lazor. The skifield has ...

Rainbow Ski Area's general manager is urging punters to take advantage of the final few "bluebird days" of spring skiing.

Marlborough

Council to spend a pretty penny

The current toilet block in Seymour Square was built in the 1960s, although some upgrades were done in the 1980s and ...

Cost of new toilets could get you a four-bedroom new build, with games room, home theatre and cash to spare.

Axe murderer released on parole

John Frederick Ericson was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2000 after murdering his wife, Sandra.

A man who killed his wife with a tomahawk while she slept has been released on parole after 19 years behind bars.

Thunder claps 'pretty intense'

Marlborough bore the brunt of a cold front moving up the country, getting 64 lightning strikes in two hours.

Dog on anti-anxiety meds still shaking after 64 lightning strikes in two hours.

Blenheim's Kmart takes shape

The building will be handed over to Kmart in February or March, but it will take time for them to set-up shop, says ...

The building will be handed over to Kmart in February or March, but it will take time for them to set-up shop, says developer.

South Canterbury

Jorja's rugby heads overseas

South Canterbury schoolgirls' rugby star Jorja Miller is off to play sevens tournaments overseas.

Timaru Girls' High School' student is set to get a taste of rugby's big time.

Council ponders $14.5m surplus

Tina Rogers, Timaru District Council's Corporate Services Manager, says there were a number of major projects held over ...

The Timaru District Council has unveiled a $14.5m surplus after another busy financial year.

Armed robbery at Kakanui

Police are seeking information following an aggravated robbery at a dairy in Kakanui, North Otago. (File)

Police seek information following aggravated robbery of dairy in small North Otago seaside town.

Man admits indecent act

Craig John Clifford McNicholl, 47, appeared in the Timaru District Court on Tuesday facing several charges, including ...

A Timaru man left a Dunedin woman petrified when he slid a mirror into her toilet cubicle in Dunedin's Botanic Gardens.

Otago

Airbnb backs 'bed tax' video

Airbnb application icon on Apple iPhone X screen close-up. Airbnb app icon. Airbnb.com is online website for booking ...

Homestay heavyweight Airbnb is throwing its support behind a controversial bed tax proposal.

Man admits indecent act

Craig John Clifford McNicholl, 47, appeared in the Timaru District Court on Tuesday facing several charges, including ...

A Timaru man left a Dunedin woman petrified when he slid a mirror into her toilet cubicle in Dunedin's Botanic Gardens.

Duck season open day bust

A New Zealand scaup, commonly known as a black teal. (File photo)

A Methven farmer killed more than a dozen protected water fowl on the opening day of duck shooting season.

Climbing death review 'private' video

New Zealand Alpine Team (NZAT) members Sarwan Chand, 27, and Conor Smith, 22, died while climbing the south face of ...

Elite Kiwi climbing team's review after four members died in three accidents will not be made public.

Southland

Dealing with meth use

Oranga Tamariki Invercargill site manager Raewyn Hubbard with the office's stars that serve as a reminder to the team of ...

Social workers on the front line of Oranga Tamariki have noted a rise in methamphetamine-related issues in communities.

Proposal moves forward

Site for proposed NZMCA park, highlighted to the left of Stead St near the estuary walkway.

The majority of submitters are in support of the Stead St reserve being used for camping.

Visitor levy draft policy approved

Stewart Island councillor Bruce Ford voted against a draft version of the Stewart Island Levy bylaw and policy, which ...

The Stewart Island visitor levy may rise to $15.

Goddess to be removed

Minerva is being removed this week to go into storage before being restored.

Roman goddess in Invercargill needs a spruce up

Ad Feedback