Unicef report: New Zealand 34th out of 41 developed countries for child wellbeing

New Zealand performs poorly on measures of child health and wellbeing relative to other developed countries.

New Zealand performs poorly on measures of child health and wellbeing relative to other developed countries.

The wellbeing of New Zealand's children places us 34th out of 41 developed countries, according to a report released by Unicef on Thursday.

The report tracks the progress on goals such as reducing child poverty, inequality and deprivation and improving things like education and health for children.

The 34th placing puts us behind Greece, Hungary and Lithuania - but ahead of the United States, Israel and Turkey.

Unicef said New Zealand's presence in the bottom end of the rankings is proof that "high national income is no guarantee of a good record in sustaining child wellbeing."

* Kiwi teen suicide rates among world's worst
* OPINION: New Zealand is failing its kids nad we must do better
Why Stuff is working with Unicef New Zealand 

Here are some of the areas that New Zealand fares worst.

Health and wellbeing

New Zealand ranks 38th ahead of only Bulgaria and Chile, while Mexico was not ranked.

This ranking reflects performance in neonatal mortality, suicide, mental health, drunkenness and teen pregnancy.

New Zealand has the highest rate of adolescent suicide of any country in the report. The report used figures from 2010 of 15.6 suicides per 100,000 people - about two and a half times the average of 6.1.

Ad Feedback

The most recent figures for New Zealand are slightly up on 2010, with 16 suicides per 100,000 in 2016. The rate is so high that it brings the that it brings the entire global average up by 0.26 deaths per 100,000.

New Zealand's neonatal mortality rate is slightly higher than average while our teen pregnancy rate places us sixth behind Turkey, Romania, Bulgaria, Chile and Mexico. Rates of teenage pregnancy have been falling in New Zealand and all other developed nations in the past decade.


New Zealand has a very high rate of childhood obesity, with 32 per cent of 2-14-year-olds overweight or obese. However, as New Zealand only reports obesity rates for 11-14-year-olds no direct comparison was possible with other countries.

"New Zealand is clearly capable of reporting against Innocenti's [the authors] measures for child obesity, but Innocenti calls specifically for the rates of 11-15 year olds, while New Zealand's rates are for 2-14 year olds," Unicef said.

"Innocenti's League Table gives a global average of just 15.2 per cent for children aged 11-15, and the worst rates – Malta (27.4 per cent) Canada (25.05 per cent) and Greece (20.93 per cent) – are nowhere near as high as New Zealand's for 2-14 year olds."

Economic growth and work

Another area where New Zealand performed poorly with a ranking of 34, owing to the 16 per cent of children living in jobless households, only Hungary and Ireland fare worse.



About 11 per cent of Kiwi children under 15 live in a home with food insecurity, slightly lower than the overall average of 12.7 per cent.

Reducing inequality

New Zealand is ranked 26th in this goal, just behind Latvia, Slovakia and Poland and ahead of Portugal, Spain and Estonia.

The share of income that goes to the top 10 per cent of households with children is nearly 20 per cent higher than the share of income in the bottom 40 per cent. 

This inequality flows into our education system where socio-economic advantage has a big impact on performance in reading, maths and science. This effect was only stronger in five countries countries.



New Zealand was not ranked against the goal of ending poverty as it only provided data in one of three indicators used in the report.

That was relative income poverty, with 19.8 per cent of Kiwi children living in a household household with an income lower the 60 per cent of the median. Slightly better than the average of 21 per cent.

However, the report's authors were critical of New Zealand's measurement of poverty.

Saying, "multidimensional poverty" should be measured as the per cent of children being deprived of only two or more material indicators, while the New Zealand Government now defines it as being deprived of seven. 

"New Zealand is clearly capable of reporting against Innocenti's measures for multidimensional poverty, but hasn't, and has instead broadened the definitive lines of measurement for multidimensional poverty when reporting internally to New Zealand audiences."

Promote peace, justice and strong institutions

This ranking comes from rates of child homicide and bullying. New Zealand did not report a rate for bullying but our high rate of child homicide was enough to see us ranked 33rd on this goal. 

With 0.78 child homicides per 100,000 children in 2010, New Zealand was seventh highest in the report, Mexico (5.98) and the United States (2.66) had the highest rates of child homicide.


There are some areas that New Zealand performed above average, including education, low air pollution and gender equality.

Ensure quality education

New Zealand is ranked 15th on this goal with an above average 71.9 per cent of 15 year olds achieving baseline competency in reading, maths and science.

However that figure, which is for 2015, has fallen from almost 80 per cent in 2006.

Clean air

New Zealand's air pollution levels are well below the average for urban areas. Only eight countries had cleaner air in urban areas than New Zealand, including Australia and several Nordic countries.

Gender equality

About 7.4 per cent of adult New Zealand males and 3.7 per cent of adult females agree with the statement "university education is more important for a boy that for a girl."

While still significant, the figure is below the report average of 13.9 per cent.

The Netherlands, Australia and Sweden had lower rates than New Zealand. While Turkey was the worst developed country with about one in three adults agreeing with the statement. 


Labour deputy leader and spokesperson for children's issues Jacinda Ardern said New Zealand should be setting goals and reporting on progress when it came to child health and wellbeing.

New Zealand needed to lift its game, she said. The government had dismissed setting measures in the child poverty space in the past, saying it wanted to focus on getting on with fixing the problem rather than reporting on goals. "But they're not doing that either," Ardern said.

New Zealand should be striving to be "world-leading" when it came to child wellbeing. "This is an area where we need to be aspirational."

The report showed relative to developed, comparable countries, New Zealand was doing poorly. And in some cases, it wasn't reporting on some of the measures at all.

Ardern said the report was "astounding but not surprising", adding that she hoped the government would not dismiss the findings, as it had done with past reports.

Acting Minister for Children Amy Adams highlighted several Government initiatives, including some announced in the May 2017 Budget as evidence that Government was doing enough to lift the wellbeing of Kiwi children.

"This Government is taking a number of steps to support children and young people, especially our most vulnerable, so they can lead healthy, safe and successful lives.

"This includes Budget 2017's $2 billion per year Family Incomes Package, which will lift families' incomes by an average of $26 a week. It's expected to lift 20,000 families above the threshold for severe housing stress and reduce the number of children living in families receiving less than half the median income by around 50,000.

"This year's Budget also invests $28.1 million to help expand Family Start, an intensive home visiting programme, that allows us to intervene early and target support to families whose children are at risk of poor education, health and social outcomes.

* Comments on this article have been closed.



 - Stuff


Ad Feedback
special offers

Voting system learning experience

Liu Chen, reporter for the Eastern Courier, will be voting in her first general election in New Zealand on September 23.

Eastern Courier reporter Liu Chen shares her experiences of getting enrolled for the September 23 general election, her first in NZ.

Wesley College victorious in CNI rugby competition

Ronan Lawrence, Brent Tucker and captain Tupou Vaa'i were stand out players of the Wesley College 1st XV team which won ...

It was a try in referee's time that won Wesley College the CNI trophy for the first time.

Housing crisis clash

The incumbent MP for Mangere and Labour Party candidate Aupito William Sio, left, and the National Party's Agnes Loheni.

Is there a housing crisis? Mangere's two main electorate candidates could only agree to disagree.

Lupton's wise move

Wise Men Say and Isaac Lupton will be one of the leading chances in Saturday's Pakuranga Hunt Cup.

Jockey's high opinion of jumper keeps him in the saddle.


Judges should not rush for plea

Dame Sian Elias' speech raised questions about whether changes had helped
with the certainty and fairness of criminal ...

Chief Justice questions whether her own judges might be rushing to get guilty pleas.

Two escape crash

Two people escaped after a helicopter crashed on a section of farm land near Waikawa Beach.

Two people escaped after a helicopter crashed onto a farm  in the Horowhenua.

Town belt changes approved

Councillors say the proposed reservoir could be essential in an inevitable earthquake.

"It's not going to be perfect in every way, [but] it is as good as we're likely to get."

Jury deliberating in rape trial

A Wellington jury is deciding if a business meeting turned to rape or was a romantic date that ended in sex.

Only one can be telling the truth, Crown tells jury deciding a rape trial.


SH1 reopening let slip

North Canterbury Transport Infrastructure Recovery alliance crews opened up a working track around Ohau Point last week.

Mark it in your calendar. Maybe in pencil for now.

Cash for stadium video

Christchurch's proposed multi-use arena could have a steel roof and a retractable turf.

National pledges extra $120m for new Christchurch stadium on top of $59m already committed.

Deregistered for marrying student

A teacher and her former student established a close relationship while he was in prison, marrying three years later. ...

He was 16, she was 32. They married three years later - after he left prison.

Cranford housing plan approved

Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel says land to be developed as part of the Cranford Regeneration Plan is an "ideal area ...

Plan to build 370 homes at Cranford Basin in Christchurch has been approved by the Crown.


New theatre unveiled

An artist's impression of what the new Waikato regional theatre could look like from the river. Full designs are still ...

The Waikato's new theatre may also house an art gallery and a hotel.

110kmh limit coming

A 110kmh speed limit on some roads will be in place by the end of the year. Digitally altered photograph.

Speed limits on Waikato expressway will be raised to 110kmh by the end of the year, Government says.

Gambling sucks millions away

South Waikato Problem Gambling Foundation counsellor Linda Tiro wants more action to stamp out gambling.

South Waikato has fifth highest spend per head on pokie machines nationally.

Our cold house shame

House designed by Solarei architecture and design practice, using passive solar design principles.

They're killing us yet many homes are still designed for 4pm on a summer's day.


Eaton brawl allegation

Former All Black Jason Eaton.

Former All Blacks lock Jason Eaton linked to early morning assault in France.

Camping consultation

The New Plymouth District Council voted to give ratepayers a say on freedom campers.

The public will get to have their say on whether freedom campers should be allowed in New Plymouth.

Charge against Keenan withdrawn 

A single theft charge against a former police officer was withdrawn in the New Plymouth District Court on Thursday, but ...

A former hapu chief executive is likely to face more charges, but for now his time in court is over.

Z Hawera robbed again

Police at the Z Petrol Station in Hawera following a robbery in the early hours of Thursday, August 24.

The Z in Hawera has been robbed ovenight for the second time in two months.


Trainee pilot in crash

Two people escaped after a helicopter crashed on a section of farm land near Waikawa Beach.

An instructor and a trainee pilot have both escaped a helicopter crash near Horowhenua.

Reports released

Horowhenua mayor Michael Feyen released two self-funded council building inspection reports.

Horowhenua's mayor's has publicly released self-funded reports on the district council building.

Candidates face off

Grey Power members listen to candidates for Palmerston North pitch for votes.

Law and order to the fore at candidates debate in Palmerston North.

Kind Hearts spreading

Central Normal pupils Ngamarama Tuariki, 10, Nevaeh Anihana, 11, and Calais Parkinson, 10, learning about being Kind Hearts.

Winter chills are being chased away, with an explosion of warmheartedness hitting schools.


Rough sleeping ban may be tested

Lawyer Steven Zindel speaks at the protest at the 1903 Square opposing the Nelson City Council's draft City Amenity Bylaw.

A Nelson lawyer expects council's controversial bylaw to be challenged in the courts.

Pooch poo pollution

Littered dog waste is not just a nuisance but also an environmental hazard.

Lazy owners not picking up dog poo isn't just an eyesore, it's affecting Nelson's waterways.

Therapy an adventure

Richard Wilkins, pictured here at Whenua Iti, is organising the first adventure therapy course in Nelson.

Can "adventure therapy", immersive courses in the great outdoors, help troubled youth?

Candidates front up

Forum chairwoman Judene Edgar, right, introduces the candidates, from left, Nick Smith, Sue Sara, Rachel Boyack, Richard ...

Election hopeful answer questions from Nelson's volunteer and community sector.


Teen's three-week meter raid

Dozens of parking meters in Blenheim were vandalised in May. (File photo)

He pried open the parking meters with a screwdriver, returning several times at night as they filled up again.

SH1 opening let slip

North Canterbury Transport Infrastructure Recovery alliance crews opened up a working track around Ohau Point last week.

Road trip to Kaikoura: December 15. Mark it in your calendar. Maybe in pencil for now.

Victims' stories

Lara Glover, 16, died and four others were injured in the car crash on February 19.

The crash killed one but affected many, and some of those affected want to speak at the driver's sentencing.

Vineyards: Investment with 'sex appeal'

Misty Cove founder Andrew Bailey is selling a vineyard the company co-owns with Moa founder Josh Scott in Onamalutu, ...

It's like any commercial investment really, except you get to say you own a vineyard.

South Canterbury

Eyeing up Nashville

Kaylee Bell will release her latest single Next Somebody on Friday, September 1.

Kiwi country pop singer/songwriter Kaylee Bell returns from Nashville to release new single.

$1.5m roading fix

South Canterbury Councils are looking to foot an estimated $1.5 million bill to fix roading damage due to July's deluge, ...

South Canterbury's councils face a $1.5 million clean-up bill for July's floods.

Evans St traffic monitoring video

23082017  News JOHN BISSET/STUFF.    Timaru Engravers and Giftware owner Ewen Lawson is sick and tired of heavy trucks ...

A mobile camera unit on Timaru's busy main road road would record the number of speeding cars.

Sector day for students

Students Summer Scott, 16, (left) and Ebony Keeley, 15, have fun in a McCain potato storage shed in Washdyke with some ...

Students given chance to learn about jobs is food processing and manufacturing sector.


It's good to be back for Binks

All eyes are firmly on Thistle goalkeeper Elliott Binks as he thwarts another Roslyn Wakari attack in their 2017 Chatham ...

Southland United goalkeeper Elliott Binks is enjoying being back out on the football field this season.

World Rugby fails to front

French referee Romain Poite explains his decision to reverse his initial decision to penalise the Lions to Sam ...

Almost seven weeks have passed since Romain Poite's u-turn enraged a nation, yet World Rugby remains silent.

Living the dream in wine country

The Central Otago wine industry should be proud of what it offers.

When attending wine tastings...there's always someone who meets the dictionary definition of pretentious side.

Victim wants to meet his tormentor

Daniel Pryde was the victim of a harassment campaign by police officer Jeremy Fraser Buis.

Victim of a long harassment campaign by a disgraced cop wants to meet his tormentor, shake his hand and ask "Is it finished?".


Celebrate being a Southlander

Sport Southland staff members, from left, Suzie Harrington, Laura Faherty, Nathan Burdon, Gareth Scott, Georgia Timpany, ...

Today is the day to embrace being a Southlander, put your purple shirt on and get behind the Ronald McDonald House and the Southland Stags.

Stags set to play

Southland Stags players unite at the end of the Stags captain's run at Rugby Park on Wednesday before the game against ...

Can Rugby Park's Stags faithful provide the kick-start they need for their 2017 campaign?

Attacked for looking like a boy

The mother took her daughter to the police station after the attack and when they came out the girls were waiting ...

Video of Central Otago schoolgirl being punched and taunted for looking like a boy posted online.

Dog handler's 'horrible' moment

Invercargill police dog handler Constable Adam Thomas and his police dog Zero.

When police dog handler Constable Adam Thomas saw his dog Zero being crushed by a car, he though he was watching his best mate die.

Ad Feedback